OT
Buffett's gloomy economic predictions
The Oracle of Omaha is gloomy about the state of our economy and says the worst is yet to come

Berneke: no pattern of behavior

Take that Sebastion.

Thanks CR.

--bh

The Psychology of a Spender IMO is " I will spend today because I anticipate X income in the future"

Throw in any uncertainty and the spender's mentality is disrupted.

Request repost

CR - It would be nice if you could comment on the final Q1-2009 GDP numbers released today. The top line number was more favorable than expected (-5.5% vs -5.7%) but it came mostly from even greater decrease in Imports.
Personal consumption continued to get revised down. Look at the PCE contribution to GDP
April release: +1.50%
May release: +1.08%
June release: +0.95%

Not a nice looking trend ...

Followed by a " I expect the American people to be repaid" This could be a drinking game.

withdrawals of home equity by households accounted for 2.3% of GDP each year from 2002 to 2006

hooboy

BB is getting a nice little injection of his own right now.

"withdrawals of home equity by households accounted for 2.3% of GDP each year from 2002 to 2006"

I question this number. How would they separate GE selling manufacturing equipment to China to make goods to sell back to the US? Are they just counting retail, leisure, home remodeling/construction?

Every once in awhile, the truth slips out about what was happening...

In 2007, 29% of Californians used HELOC loans to buy new cars, as opposed to an average of 11% of the rest of the country doing so.

Why would this average be any different for anything else bought in the Golden State of plenty?

=========================================

There were only 2 ways to 'win' as the value of your home was going up during the housing bubble. The drastic way was to sell your home and either rent or move to cheaper digs elsewhere, vs. rewarding oneself with consumer accoutrement vis a visa easy no questions asked loans from the 1st National Bank of Your House.

So the upward revision to GDP came from an increased estimate in the reduction in international trade, which ties with the recent Japan and Eurozone numbers showing continuing YoY declines 30%-40%...weekly job loss solidly above 600K per week...record credit card delinquencies...the referenced PCE trends (with an update tomorrow)...

Green shoots and leaves?

BB - going to be difficult for him to survive his lies today, and his 'subprime is contained' comment. One lie was intentional, the other was sheer stupidity.

Turn it on and first thing I see... "that's a good question"...

and now the son is up and wants "playhouse dismey"...

Using this methodology, we find striking results: from 2002 to 2006, homeowners borrowed $0.25 to $0.30 for every $1 increase in their home equity.
....
Finally, the effect of house prices on homeowner borrowing is isolated to homeowners with low credit scores and high credit card utilization rates. These “credit-constrained” households respond aggressively to house price growth, whereas the highest credit quality borrowers do not respond at all.

Taken together, these statements imply that the distribution of MEW activity is skewed, with poor credit quality homeowners probably taking $1 for every $1 increase in home equity and good credit quality homeowners probably taking $0 for every $1 increase in home equity. I wonder if that sort of skew is included in the current models of loss prediction?

Yogi

"And I am saying that the unions must play power politics like anyone else and try to support the candidate likely to win, not the one most favorable to unions."

I agree esp nationally.

Followed by a " I expect the American people to be repaid" This could be a drinking game.

/way ahead of you
/drink

--bh

Would it not be classic if Ben just stood up and shouted " That's it I had enough your all on your own"

I QUIT!

Then the drugs wore off!..dam

The authors need to do a lot more work on establishing dependancies. Normalize these graphs for relative costs of living SF v. Atlanta and much of the "leverage gap" goes away.

Still I find their observation wrt to "credit constrained households" to be very persuasive.

"Our analysis of the microeconomic data has led us to the conclusion that the severity of this economic downturn is rooted in the household leverage crisis, which in turn is closely related to the housing market."

they have got the cart before the horse. If they actually follow their results housing contributed 2.3% p.a. to GDP growth between 2002-2006. Absent that GDP would have been essentially flat and approximately 2,000,000 jobs/year wouldn't have been created during that period and we would have just as many people as we currently do even in the absence of the financial crisis.

This is essentially the point that I have been making- the financial crisis didn't give rise to the economic problems but rather the other way around. The problem is not the financial crisis but a the economic policies that we have been following prior to the crisis. The failure of those policies was masked by the vast debt increase. Which raises my bigger point- what substantial change to economic policies as Obama put into place and even if he is successful at avoiding the reckless lending (and its concomitant growth) what is going to drive economic growth.

ghostfaceinvestah

I agree that the U-6 is more important and the case you made for it...

I know this got pigged...
watching Ben reminds me of what Mary McCarthy said of Lilian Hellman - classic line:
'every word she writes is a lie, including 'and' and 'the'.

BB says

at first I thought Ken Lewis could be shaking us down, but then as I got to know him I decided he was just an idiot who did not know what he was doing. . . . so we left him in control of management........

that seems the soft underbelly to aim for.

@RD

The authors need to do a lot more work on establishing dependancies. Normalize these graphs for relative costs of living SF v. Atlanta and much of the "leverage gap" goes away.

Third, renters in inelastic areas did not experience a larger growth in their total debt.

Comparing the activity of homeowners in SF to renters in SF helps to normalize the data.

The house ATM was the first point of call when the buying urge took people. That window was in most cases ALWAYS open. So spending was almost unrestrained as it is normally by household cash flow. That window is now closed, that alone would be a major recession. Add to this the growing unemployment and rising interest rates and you get a double whammy. The consumer is not the engine to pull the economy out of this whole(sic).

This was all part of Larry Summers' master plan to get himself the FRB chair job...use Paulson/Geithner to suborn lies from Bernanke; then leave him to twist in the wind before Congress. Leading to Summers replacing BB when the bearded devil's term is up.

How about, "The truth? You can't handle the Truth. Paulson wanted martial law..."

Pow , now Geithner is stumbling around in another wood panelled room. Time to go to Home Depot.

"Paulson wanted martial law..."

TARP 1.0 would have made Secretary of Treasury the single most powerful office in the country.

The one thing I hate about these testimony's is... I don't know where the Q&A is archived? Also, what about the questions that are given to BB "for the record" that aren't answered but promised later? I was searching around after his last testimony (not sure if it was same committee) but just couldn't find it. I suppose one would have to listen to the C-Span archive...

I can't wait for Daddy Whorebucks to approach the microphone explaining the macabre financial machinations that helped avoid a meltdown way back when by handing out Golden Parachutes to those that mattered, as the sweat beads upon his furrowed brow and it looks like he has Tourette's, sans obscenity outbursts...

"This was all part of Larry Summers' master plan to get himself the FRB chair job..."

Of course HR 1206 will go into effect just as Summers gets a hold of the chair...

Crazyv--yup! Trickle down didn't work--but they put whipped cream on top to make it look and taste better. Then they had chef Greenspan add the cherries.

2.3% of GDP nationally = what % in CA?

I suspect it's around 12-15%. That number sounds about right given the huge drop in sales and income taxes in CA.

"Year-to-date collections for the three
major taxes were down $13.6 billion
(-16.6%) below last year at this time.
Retail sales were down $2.8 billion
(-11.8%), personal income taxes fell by
$10.2 billion (-20.7%)..."

California has been hit by a double whammy of unemployment. Unemployed people who aren't making money, and unemployed homes which aren't making money via refis and helocs.

Duncan: Is Federal Reserve operating with too much secrecy/refusal to disclose?
BB: We've made enormous strides in past year to expand information release; monthly reports on all the programs. We will work with Congress (hooray C-SPAN online feed just crapped out)

Did Bernake trash the video too? Damn,

John and Jane Doe are broke!

Geithner is stumbling around in another wood panelled room

It is dark.
You are likely to be eaten by a J6P.

In fact, homeowners did not even use home equity withdrawals to pay down expensive credit card debt! These facts suggest that consumption and home improvement were the most likely use of borrowed funds, which is consistent with Federal Reserve survey evidence suggesting home equity extraction is used for real outlays. I'm not sure what they mean. Anecdotally, alot of serial refinancers were paying down their CCs each time. Or do they mean that there was no NET paying down of CC balances because the FBs borrowed them back up quickly?

Jane Chardonnay has convinced herself that $2 buck Chuck ain't all that bad, and Joe 6 Pack can't afford to kill a dozen three times a week anymore.

Jim A,

No. They mean they were not paying down their credit cards, they were buying stuff, hence the uptick in consumer spending.

--bh

Jim...think about the mentality of the person who would run up such debt in the first place. Just because a windfall came and allowed them to pay it off ONCE...why would that change their general view of money and credit? It wouldnt. It would just allow them to run it up again, and reinforce the notion that at some point, lady luck will shine again and magically make the debt go away. These people are for the most part, financially illiterate. They are only taught enough how to be abused by the system for other people's benefit. Did you ever wonder why simple basic personal financial planning 101 isnt taught to you unless you choose to learn it? The sheep must be kept as sheep.

Please pick up a copy of 1984 and read (or reread) it. Its fairly instructive on how this works.

Is this Kaptur going on regarding Blackrock? Inventing, creating, and packaging MBS.
BB: Arrangements with Blackrock are carefluly set up to avoid conflicts of interest and create firewalls.
BULLSHIT!

Kaptur: Do you know what else Blackrock has sold to the government?
BB: No

Kaptur: Difficulty is that you cannot unwind these pools of assets. Can the fed be in collusion with Mr. Fink in covering up his own fraud, by giving him the oppurtunity to shift portfolios and have access to information we don't have access to in ways favorable to his clients and company. How do we know that is not happening.
BB: We can provide you with Blackrock contracts. They have controls that set up firewall...

Kaptur: I asked you for those contracts. They were placed on Fed website, thanks. They had multiple exhibits missing, investment guidelines except for 1 policy objective... along with designated Fed Bank of New York representatives and personnel. Given you used taxpayer dollars, why omit fee schedule and etc.
BB: We have a committee, some of this is propritary and confidential.
Kaptur: If we are going to fix; those who hold power to create money, certainly the NYFED has more power. Something went seriously wrong; and I hear what you said this morning... but... I am concerned the Fed itself is involved in manipulation of the markets, mortgage markets, particularly the toxic assets the public owns. I'm not convinced what you said regarding Blackrock contracts that they are fair and impartial.

(Kaptur's time up)

"Jim...think about the mentality of the person who would run up such debt in the first place. Just because a windfall came and allowed them to pay it off ONCE...why would that change their general view of money and credit? It wouldnt. It would just allow them to run it up again, and reinforce the notion that at some point, lady luck will shine again and magically make the debt go away."

So, are you describing SF residents, or the CA legislature?

Nate...funny. Those arent mutually exclusive ya know.

curious (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 8:18 am

@RD
The authors need to do a lot more work on establishing dependancies. Normalize these graphs for relative costs of living SF v. Atlanta and much of the "leverage gap" goes away.
Third, renters in inelastic areas did not experience a larger growth in their total debt.
Comparing the activity of homeowners in SF to renters in SF helps to normalize the data.

Another instance of needing to be very careful in identifying independent variables. Both groups are already self selecting for certain behaviors not least of which is propensity to take on debt. Think about it. Person "Renter1" buys a house and becomes Person "Homeowner1" and takes on a huge debt load. Person "Homeowner2" sells a house and becomes Person "Renter2" and presumably banks a windfall.

OJ in the market...pushing thru 3 avgs as bb speaks...

@crazyv:

The problem is not the financial crisis but a the economic policies that we have been following prior to the crisis. The failure of those policies was masked by the vast debt increase. Which raises my bigger point- what substantial change to economic policies as Obama put into place and even if he is successful at avoiding the reckless lending (and its concomitant growth) what is going to drive economic growth.

There will not be economic growth of any significance in the USA, until the USA-China pegged relationship gets readdressed. The control to steer USA is outside USA, not inside.

Fed and Govt can pass any policies till their face turn purple, it won't do a damn thing.

If the China peg gets realigned, short term there'll be pain, but long term, it makes USA manufacturing on equal footing and now we can finally service for the massive Chinese population and buy back our debt and begin to right the ship, slowly.

Anything important in economics, always happens at the margin.

A slight change in USD-China peg might, at the very margin, change the equation for an outsourcing project, so that some more jobs remain in USA; and at the other end of the margin, change the equation for production location, so that some products can be made in the USA more. Take this picture and replicate it across millions of margins, and you have the beginning of recovery.

I've always said and I will say it again, the Peg is the chokehold and nothing will change until China, and the rest of BRIC and oil countries depeg. Let forex do it's job of self-correction instead of forcing a static economic status quo.

For the average US Citizen though, it means a choice of wherher you want to starve from no work, or hobble along with no more "cheap walmart" goods. I don't think the populace is ready for that change until several years into more suffering...

(Previous Thread)

Sebastian.........Let me clarify this in my own mind for you........

John, Carol, Ted, & Alice are STILL unemployed today. State benefits were 6-mos., 3-additional months for Federal (9-mos total). Maybe an additional 3-mos state extended but many hoops to jump through (12-months AT MOST). That puts them back to June of '08. That means that if they were laid off prior to that , they are going hungry, correct? I suggest there are already hundreds of thousands in that predicament. Look at the number of unemployed in June of '08 - they are going over the waterfall now! (500K initial).

I found my first evidence of green shoots in Idaho today!

Urban gardening? And all the free fertilizer you could want.

"The problem is not the financial crisis but a the economic policies that we have been following prior to the crisis. "

Which ones?

"Crazyv--yup! Trickle down didn't work"

Oh.

A couple I know ran up credit card debt to about $50,000.00 every couple of years. Then refied and paid off the cards. They did this at least twice, maybe 3 times.

Right before the real estate market tanked, they sold the house. Just lucky timing. However their credit was so bad by that time they had to do some funny paperwork to get the last bit of cash out of the house, then closed escrow with about 0 in their pocket.

The point is that this couplle believe life is always good and they will always find a way to continue to spend. One thing they have going for them is fairly well of parents, who bail them out as needed as well.

MY god I love it. Yuppie d-bags that used their home equity as ATM machines to buy SUVs and trips to europe and tacky bathrooms getting a large throbbing case of reality right in the stink.

burn burn burn!!! I hope debtors prisons are brought back. Sadly these d-bags won't get what they deserve. They should be doing the Tyburn Jig, but the worst that will happen is a bad credit score for 7 years.

I applaud everyone that managed to live within or below their means during the orgy of consumption. It wasn't easy, but we prevailed.

The economy will eventually stop contracting. But as far as what might start a steady upward march again to -- someday -- where we were, or better? Who knows?

Although, one bet might be to decrease socialism in America -- military socialism. A vast high-cost, low-productivity network of corporations and jobs that feed the military-industrial complex and produce items that do not improve American competitiveness. Oh, they improve our clout in the world -- to the advantage of the multi-national corporations which just happen to be based in the U.S. (but will proudly tell you they're multinational, and mean it).

But if we took 200 bill for weapons development and put it into infrastructure and health care and health care research and energy research, that'd do a lot to giving the economy the tools it needs to recover. You could cry "SOCIALISM." And I'd say -- "yeah, just like always. Just a broader range of recipients."

the Peg is the chokehold and nothing will change until China, and the rest of BRIC and oil countries depeg.

Which is why we had Smoot Hawley in the 30s.

I am with you BURN...but looking back I sometime wish I was one of the D-baggers....they had fun and walked away from it all, us frugal types get to pay the bill.

Suckie trade off in my book...but then again flush with cash I can buy their crap for pennies on the dollar...but then again I have enough crap.

MY god I love it. Yuppie d-bags that used their home equity as ATM machines to buy SUVs and trips to europe and tacky bathrooms getting a large throbbing case of reality right in the stink.

burn burn burn!!! I hope debtors prisons are brought back. Sadly these d-bags won't get what they deserve. They should be doing the Tyburn Jig, but the worst that will happen is a bad credit score for 7 years.

I applaud everyone that managed to live within or below their means during the orgy of consumption. It wasn't easy, but we prevailed.

sorry but reads more like envy in that you missed a trick......I've no debt but right now I'm not sure I'm winning.....I'm gettnig zilch on my savings and the $ is losing value, so much for my prudence

"I applaud everyone that managed to live within or below their means during the orgy of consumption. It wasn't easy, but we prevailed."

I have been living within or below my means. Saving to send my girls to college (in 15 years). Renting (to buy when the RE makes sense in So Cal). All our savings is in banks making 3% (don't trust the stock market) But, I don't feel like I prevailed...I feel screwed. Is it just me?

Lurker,

But, I don't feel like I prevailed...I feel screwed. Is it just me?

there are plenty of us!

the Peg is the chokehold and nothing will change until China, and the rest of BRIC and oil countries depeg.

Try this thought experiment:

If USA is trying to be ruthless, it can peg USD at 1000:1 for Euro (i.e. 1000 USD for 1 EU). Aggressively, non-negotiable.

What happens?

Immediately, Euro stuff will be prohibitively expensive in USA, similarly USA stuff will be Walmart nice in Euros.

Cost of oil, materials, etc are transient ultimately, and will flow through the system over the mid term. (Short term pain maybe, not ultimately not disastrous) But LABOR COST and GOVT COST immediately yields a competitive advantage.

So USA will earn some EURO forex; which naturally should cause USD to raise and "fix" the 1000:1 ratio. Let's force the system not to correct by buying Euro treasuries; thus widening their trade deficits. Repeat and rinse.

Over time, we'll have massive amounts of Euro treasuries, we'll have a massive employment and Europe will be struggling and wondering why their interest rate is so low. With their interest rate distorted, they'll probably have a housing bubble or some other speculation bubble. (at this point, if the bubble burst, People will blame the "morals" of the European, etc; but I blame the system. You cannot abscond the enabler of bubble any crime and just say the people's at fault.)

Short of a "Smoot Hawley" foreign import tax; there's no way for Europe to escape this peg. But implement one is like using a nuclear bomb economic wise.

Bob Dobbs:

I agree with you vis-a-vis the military. One reason I am getting out. I long ago came to the conclusion that the bulk of our spending was geared towards job creation, not national defense. I biggest turning point was the privatization boom over the last 20 years. So many jobs once done by privates are now done by highly paid contractors. It doesn't cost less, but it provides more opportunities for pork and graft. We could easily cut the DOD budget by 30% with no real impact on readiness. We will eventually cut the DOD, but because of a fiscal crisis. For a really good analysis of military overspending, look up "The Soldiers Load and the Mobility of a Nation" by SLA Marshall. It discusses how we do our troops a dis-service by overspending and loading them down with gear they don't need (which mostly just benefits defense contractors anyway).

no its not just you...the only people I see winning is those swimming in biggest bonus pool ever and 50% pay increases so they don't leave....

"But, I don't feel like I prevailed...I feel screwed. Is it just me? "

We're all screwed. I saved, too; and my friends who depended on investments for their retirement are now down below me in net worth. But the big boys who ran the investment show -- they always got theirs up front, and sold the trash to the rest of us.

In some sense, I'm not screwed -- good cash in the bank. But I feel that I might be, by what's coming down "for the good of the economy," be it inflation or whatever. So I have taken pains to hedge myself in a couple of directions though this does not come naturally -- not to make money, but to protect it. So that in a few years when this all shakes out, I can say "I'm still standing."

But what does that say rules our economy runs by?

It doesn't really take all that much extra capital to turn MacDonald's into a decent restaurant. I never eat at a fast food chain unless I'm captive to a group. Any Greek diner, any day.

hc-

could not agree more except the part about manu. jobs. We no longer have the workforce to staff any large factories (should they even have the capital to create them) it's only through addressing this part of the equation would that actually have a chance in being a plausible outcome. I'm at a loss as how to do this going forward.....we know how it should be accomplished however the conditions to provide this are not available...and won't be for a very long time.

In other news.....

US Treasury auction changes may overstate indirect bid
| Reuters

We see how the Treasury gets to change the rules when they need to show "appetite" from FCB's. Not fooling me...it's BB doing that buying...why else did the yield rise?

Ciao
MS

hc...agree that the peg is probably the single most important factor, but to get the ChiGov off it will mean taking it from their cold, dead hands...it's the only thing between them and economic/social meltdown in China.

Bob D...also agree...the mil/industrial complex now is about extracting cash from the US taxpayer...consider we built 8600 B-24's in three years or so in WWII from scratch as opposed to a couple hundred F-22's at $200 mil each over a design build cycle of 20 years.

Sure the Fed diddled with BoA.
But for all you anti BB gloaters..
Would you rather ML tanked??

And all those Monday morning QBs were in power then but they did diddly to come up with any ideas..let Ben do it.
My secret fantasy is that BB posts all their e-mails and letters asking for special favors for these pols backers.. and then quits

CR said: "...The results of Atif Mian and Amir Sufi fit with what I've observed."

Well, of course they are! You're in California, Ground-Zero for all the high-risk markers in the study, like this one:

"...the increase in debt among homeowners in high house price growth areas is concentrated in mortgage and home equity related debt."

And this one:

"...Finally, the effect of house prices on homeowner borrowing is isolated to homeowners with low credit scores and high credit card utilization rates. These “credit-constrained” households respond aggressively to house price growth, whereas the highest credit quality borrowers do not respond at all...."

California, Florida, Arizona, Nevada, all centers of high house price growth and sub-prime/Alt-A lending.

If you lived elsewhere, without the high risk factors described in the study, your observations would be different. My observations of local conditions are similar to the Calomiris study.

Sebastian

hc-so what you recommend is that we do to Europe what China did to us? Where does the madness end?

I don't feel like I prevailed...I feel screwed. Is it just me? - Lurker

That about sums it up.
Do I live in a better neighborhood? No. The uber-leveraged took them all.
Do I get any form of financial break? On the contrary I am expect to clean up this mess.

The true disaster is waiting. WE are going to say "no" and TPTB will be left dumbfounded as to their next step.

I agree that the 50% pay increase to the people who enginered this disaster is a slap in the face to most people not living on Wall Street Bankers Ave.

But unless people remove what little money they have left from these Citi, they will not ever get the clue.

Lurker

I've done all the same things (though my savings are not earning as much as 3% - how are you doing that?).

But the differences between us might be

1) reflecting on the reality of the alternative: savings in the bank versus a couple of years in a nice house but with equity vanished into thin air. Would you rather be bankrupt?

2) a longer time horizon, as a longtimelurker versus just a lurker: do you think you will be better off tomorrow or a year or 5 years or 10 years from now . . .better off than those who blew their equity on a bad debt house purchase 2005-2007?

Not about you, but more generally, I think there are elements of projection that come into play in discussions of economics and personal finance that emphasize the issues of virtue and just/unjust rewards, not unlike the kinds of projection engaged in by the Mark Sanfords and John Ensigns of the world when they campiagned for Bill Clinton's resignation/impeachments and rail against gay marriage, abortion, and birth control for teenagers .. . . rant and scream at the devil, then act like him or worse.

hc-so what you recommend is that we do to Europe what China did to us? Where does the madness end?

Relax, I'm only using an analogy to show how it works.

I completely removed China from the picture to show how I can recreate today's crisis from a relatively benign US-EU relationship.

Thus, the peg is the enemy. Spread the news/viewpoint. DOWN WITH THE PEG!

The true disaster is waiting. WE are going to say "no" and TPTB will be left dumbfounded as to their next step.

US PATRIOT ACT.
Martial Law.

Nuke,

In general I agree, even as the evil-federal contractor.

But the best and brightest are not rewarded inside the government. They get ground down and either give-in to the lowest common denominator, or get out. And frankly, I'd rather go from contract to contract on my own terms then get re-orged every friggin 15 months. It is not that the human capital isn't there in the government to do, let's say, IT, but that the human capital has been demotivated and desensitized to any personal and professional ambition. And so the resources are often absent to do complex and specialized tasks.

--bh

I said it before and I'll say it again: I didn't do HELOC, but I sure was thinking about how I was going to spend that extra 100K when my house was worth (for a short time) 300K a year or two ago (like retire soon) Well, its gone now, I probably won't retire in two years, and when if I do retire, I will be spending about 100K less than I thought.
One could say that as I never got the money, it never exerted any stimulative affect, or deleverageing affect. But it certainly has a negative psychological affect - no more starbucks, less eating out, no new ties, no weekend jaunts to NY, etcetera.

Mad Max in Home Gnome, with Michelle Bachmann warning you not to fill out a census form because all the white middle class people will be rounded up into internment camps.....Oh, the insanity.

The markets are relentless this morning. Did I miss out on some news of new ponies? Or are we just window dressing with insane amounts of liquidity?

If you lived elsewhere, without the high risk factors described in the study, your observations would be different. My observations of local conditions are similar to the Calomiris study.

Sebastian,
Have you ever read one of CR's posts and attempted to digest it, or are you here simply to lecture your elders?

Ike saw the military political pitfall--but nobody could stop it. Politics is all about money--just as Marx explained war--our system doesn't work anymore. Haven't a clue for a replacement. The dx is cancer, the rx is unknown, the symptoms are getting unbearable.

elements of projection that come into play

Debt is a mathematical function.

The Bubble was inevitable, which means the Crash was inevitable.
Most people choose not to see but the U.S. is looking a lot like Germany of the 1930s.

"Would you rather ML tanked??"

It HAS failed....stuffing it into BAC just makes it look like it has not. That's the biggest part of the problem they just won't accept an actual failure. Downside of capitalism is failure.

We are not allowing that.

Ciao
MS

foolonthhill wrote:
Sure the Fed diddled with BoA.
But for all you anti BB gloaters..

Would you rather ML tanked??

Yes, I would rather ML tanked.
Liquidate the banks.

"Oh, the insanity."

Didn't TPTB already threaten martial law?

Well, it will never happen here in America.
We're special.
Like the kids on the short bus.

Well, LongTime, what do you think is going to happen?

could not agree more except the part about manu. jobs. We no longer have the workforce to staff any large factories (should they even have the capital to create them) it's only through addressing this part of the equation would that actually have a chance in being a plausible outcome.

The equation won't be fixed overnight, the jobs/manufacturers at the margin will find profit, and over time, build up their capacity. The margin is the key in any economy.

It's a lot easier to expand existing manufacturing than to rebuild; ditto to easier to regrow your existing base if you still have the technology and know-how. (we do)

I would submit that you're absolutely right that the skills is gradually going out the window the longer our manufacturing lays in waste and our previous skilled generation is forced to retire or switch careers. I would say we're stuck with our situation after majority of baby boomer all retire (another 10-15 years); but we still have a fighting change yet.

Alas, the govt/fed/china TPTB will not give USA that chance.

Black Star Ranch: "Sebastian.........Let me clarify this in my own mind for you........

John, Carol, Ted, & Alice are STILL unemployed today. State benefits were 6-mos., 3-additional months for Federal (9-mos total). Maybe an additional 3-mos state extended but many hoops to jump through (12-months AT MOST). That puts them back to June of '08. That means that if they were laid off prior to that , they are going hungry, correct? I suggest there are already hundreds of thousands in that predicament. Look at the number of unemployed in June of '08 - they are going over the waterfall now! (500K initial)."

And permit me to clarify my point, cold-blooded as it might sound: Even if they starve to death, that doesn't mean the economy can't grow.

I can appreciate their plight, as I have been in that situation before, but economic growth can and will occur regardless of the misery-level of a minority of our citizens. Even at a peak of economic growth there are lots of people in desperate straits.

Sebastian

Would you rather ML tanked??


Yes...its called dead wood.

Window dressing for end of quarter, natch

Fannie, Freddie tanking and the homebuilders soaring.
Here's a market basket.

Lennar up 18%? New bubble in HB stocks?

Ike was a lot smarter than most people give him credit for. I think the last president who truly understood how the military worked and its limitations was GHW Bush. Which is why he didn't want to occupy Iraq. Clinton was enamored with open ended nation building campaigns (which tie up resources to this day) and GW Bush, well, you know how that story ends.

And Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice STILL have not managed to pull off that foursome, even with all that time on their hands.

"But, I don't feel like I prevailed...I feel screwed. Is it just me? "

I don't feel anything but disappointment for people that got in over their heads. They consumed and spent until their garage was full of unnecessary crap and then wasted the rest of the money. What little I had I raked together and bought a little pile of sand. It's not much, but it's ours and paid for. Since the "day of enlightenment" 20-years ago, I haven't contributed a dollar to this mess and have lived in abject poverty just so I can't be accused of condoning or fostering it.

Things won't get any better until they get MUCH worse this time. The temporary fixes are no longer working.

@BSR.
But you DO have fresh milk, cheese and eggs, brother.

"Downside of capitalism is failure."

That, to me is not a downside, but instead a key component that allows the market to get bad business out of the way for the good. Capitalism ceases to be effective without it.

Large plants only employ a fraction of what they did 20 years ago. That has been the only way the survivors are still here; head count reduction by various methods.

healines mrktwatch

Dollar consolidates after Fed-inspired rally...
better one...
were extending programs to buy more recylced trash...were going green....

HomeGnome (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 9:08 am

@BSR.
But you DO have fresh milk, cheese and eggs, brother.

AND a friend in SoCal who will trade for olives and avocados.

If you lived elsewhere, without the high risk factors described in the study, your observations would be different. My observations of local conditions are similar to the Calomiris study.

Sebastian, what aspect of the Mian/Sufi 'elastic' model fails to represent your area? Bear in mind I know NC quite well.

Dow Monster: Me not take 401k money, me eat the 401k money.

..........But you DO have fresh milk, cheese and eggs, brother.

Amen........And more importantly, a family that thinks I might be a touch crazy, and not so bad......

"Clinton was enamored with open ended nation building campaigns (which tie up resources to this day) and GW Bush, well, you know how that story ends."

My recollection was that he had a pretty light and effective touch. What actions do you refer to?

Today in The Zombieconomy
Today in The Zombieconomy - Umair Haque - HarvardBusiness.org

Psst — want to know why our capital markets don't work? Because "investors" are mostly agitpropagandists, seeking a more and more ephemeral informational edge — instead of analyzing companies better.

Just like food companies no longer produce real food — but the experience of having eaten food.

Just like the media industry dumped durable, high-quality content, like analysis and reporting — in favour of disposable, low-cost entertainment.

Just like venture investors are investing in...minigames — instead of launching a wave of 21st century industrial revolutions in energy, finance, education, and healthcare.

Welcome to the Zombieconomy — want fries with that layoff?

Nuke...double +10....totally agree...based on my experience with a former employer that was involved with DOD procurement.

Market Basket? You do miss New England.

AND a friend in SoCal who will trade for olives and avocados.

you guys are killing me...
I was thinking of trying a few olive trees here in scenic South Carolina.
Where you still can, from time to time, see a beehive hair do.

I'm heading to Italy in Sept.
I'll get plenty of olives to eat then.
and wild boar.
I can't wait.

"economic growth can and will occur regardless of the misery-level of a minority of our citizens"

Yes, yes that miracle is what got us here today! We will get to test that concept real time against the continuing increase in record consumer credit default rates - next up, a sermon on the virtues of the oxymoron 'jobless recovery.'

Don't worry, there's enough credit for everyone. We can go back to pouring coffee and hanging chinese drywall now.

YouTube - Let the Eagle Soar **FAST**

"Didn't TPTB already threaten martial law?

Well, it will never happen here in America.
We're special.
Like the kids on the short bus."

I'm not sure they could do it effectively. Might be wrong, but this is a big country. The multitudinous wartime rules and regs were widely flouted by the population in WWII (no matter what the official history says) -- and that was for a crisis people bought into. If they don't buy in -- how many millions of troops do you have? And how many come from the areas you're trying to hold down.

Before Obama put a stop to the practice, my city and county had stopped cooperating with the feds when they came to make raids on medical marijuana plantations. Bump that level of local noncooperation up a couple of notches in various parts of the country, and how much control does martial law get you?

lama: "Sebastian,
Have you ever read one of CR's posts and attempted to digest it, or are you here simply to lecture your elders?"

Leaving aside the fact that I'm CR's elder, do you ever give me the benefit of the doubt and attempt to digest my posts?

Two academic studies, two conflicting points of view. What's wrong with my taking up one side of the debate, the one that actually reflects what I'm seeing, except that you don't agree with it and it's an unpopular viewpoint on this board?

And why are you making this personal, instead of advancing the discussion with points of your own?

Sebastian

One question... If you "live within your means" .. Who defines " your means" and why should you care?

Since we all live only once, and kids are at best a means to propogate genes, does not the " you" die with you?

broward (homepage, profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 9:04 am

elements of projection that come into play

Debt is a mathematical function.

The Bubble was inevitable, which means the Crash was inevitable.
Most people choose not to see but the U.S. is looking a lot like Germany of the 1930s.

projection, big time. Right wing militia campers who think the country looks like Germany (!) in the 1930s. Projection and wishful thinking on their part, too.

How about the secret 13th Amendment, Broward? And Obama's birth certificate?

Michelle Bachmann worrying that she will be thrown in an internment camp is funnier, but no less illogical and unhinged.

creditcriminalslovetarp (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 9:05 am replyIgnore userfed extends programs....

Fed extends credit programs until Feb. 2010 - MarketWatch

"improved and impared" in the same sentance. Interseting. Although they seem to have made the decision with the weight on the "impared".

@ Bob
I never said they'd be able to effectively pull off martial law; only that they would attempt it if things get bad enough.

My 4th of July wish:
The repeal of the US Patriot Act.

Geez, LongTime, you still haven't answered the question I posed:
What do you think will happen?
Go on, express yourself.

Debt : Economic recovery

as

Mannequin : Life

Wicked pissah. Visit, not return.

Heck if this economy plays out at worst case* I'll buy 400 acres in Western Mass and a D-9 with grader option and build an executive fly-in 4 season resort. Golf/fishing April-Oct, snowmobiles/x-country Dec-Feb. A few dozen acres dedicated to heirloom varietals and gentleman farming.

  • worst case - you know like if unemployment exceeds the adverse scenario. Wink

Government Taking Stakes In Two AIG Insurance Companies

WTF? The wire reports state AIG is "paying back" $25 billion to the government. Well, sort of, but here's how it is really going down.

Under the deal, AIG will give the New York Fed preferred interests in its two largest life insurance units outside the United States — American International Assurance, or A.I.A., and American Life Insurance Company, or Alico.

The Fed will hold an equity stake in A.I.A. worth $16 billion, and a stake in Alico worth $9 billion, according to the AIG statement.

Curiously, the statement says that:

The face value of the preferred interests represents a percentage of the estimated fair market value of AIA and ALICO.

But, then the statement does not provide what the percentages actually are. Does this smell or what?

Last month AIG said that it would "accelerate steps" to spin off AIA through a public listing on an Asian stock exchange, as part of its efforts to repay a government bailout totaling up to $173.3 billion. This is part of that step, but clearly the government doesn't appear to be planning on an immediate liquidation of its position at the time of the IPO. More curious paper in the drawer of the Fed.

@nuke

One quibble. Bush senior left Clinton a post election booby prize - sent troops into somalia.

Here's the deal: A lot of us who didn't tap into home equity for spending sprees are still affected. We thought of our homes as part of the retirement plan. We thought we could save a bit less because on retirement, we could downsize to a cottage or condo, and be a few hundred thousand dollars to the good. Now, not so much. We're scrambling to save more and spend less, because we realize our houses are likely going to return far less than we thought. I own my own home free and clear at this point, but the drop in its value has affected my spending habits for this reason. Couple that with the 401K effect, and you've got a lot of demoralized consumers out there, whether they were thrifty or spendthrifts up to this point.

In our area, a number of unsold condos are headed into foreclosure sale because empty-nesters don't want to sell their four-bedroom nests at current prices. That drastically reduces the number of "move down" buyers interested in condos.

Kanjorski just drops the ball, like the others. No one ever demands a detailed explanation of why the financial collapse would be any worse for anyone except bankers.

OT (hard to tell what isn't sometimes lol) on the post election unrest in Iran. A real fracture may be developing amongst the elites there:

Iran opposition leader Mousavi defies crackdown
By Jay Deshmukh – 1 day ago
[snip]
At the same time, conservative parliament speaker Ali Larijani and more than 100 MPs stayed away from a victory dinner hosted by Ahmadinejad on Wednesday, press reports said.
AFP: Iran opposition leader defiant amid pressure to back down

Gnome

I think the militia, mad maxer, end of the worlder stuff is a pipe dream delusion.

The economy will suck for a long time - a W double dip, a long awful L_____________, or maybe even a GD 2.0 (though odds of the last seem lower now it is still a non-trivial possibility)

But I think GWB will be the low point for civil liberties. The history of the country has seen this before and responding in similar ways. There is a powerful reaction against what Bush did. Not powerful enough for my tastes, but powerful all the same.

Martial Law? Unless there is a nuclear war or a giant metor hits, I think the odds are very low. It is mainly the stuff of right wing fantasy and projection: a nightmare of fear for what is, in fact, desired.

shill (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 9:21 am

Government Taking Stakes In Two AIG Insurance Companies
...Under the deal, AIG will give the New York Fed preferred interests in its two largest life insurance units outside the United States — American International Assurance, or A.I.A., and American Life Insurance Company, or Alico.

AIG has been shopping Alico for months internationally. Who benefits from not letting Alico fail? Yup. Got it right with one guess.

Gnome

p.s.

I would also love to see a repeal of the Patriot Act, or at least substantial parts of it. We agree on that, at least.

I'd also like to see all the torture photos and documents released to the public, and I think will happen over the next couple of years. Nothing ever happens in a day - well, not most things political, anyway.

I supose I wasn't being clear in my question at 11:27. It sounds like they were saying that people weren't using MEW money to pay off thier CCs. Since that flies in the face of ALOT of anecdotal evidence and would be very surprising indeed, I suspect that what they MEANT was that since these FBs just racked up the balances again there was no NET decrease in CC balances that was associated with the increase in MEW. I was jus wondering whether somebody who read the whole article was a little clearer on what they were saying.

I weep for my bear call spread.

Rob,
The original Market Basket (Demoulas) in Lowell used to buy produce from my Papere's farm.
If they're still buying locally you could make the nut on your resort.

Not so much a U, V, W or L recession IMHO. We're looking at a Winnie the Pooh economy that goes bumb, bump,bump on all the way down the staircase.

Thanks for the reply, LongTime.
I, too, think that martial law is a long shot possibility but I also note that the Dem's have NOT repealed the Patriot Act.

Weren't the private mercenary units of Blackwater sent to New Orleans during Katrina?
Aren't National Guard units of the individual states now under FEDERAL control?
Doesn't every state have a DHS office now?

Again, martial law a definite long shot; but a possibility nonetheless.

RE: Torture Photos
But King Rush said they just show what amounts to "harmless fraternity pranks" so what's the problem with releasing them?
Guess he's already seen them...

Sebastian?

Is a mighty response in progress to my question at 12:10, or does the 'elastic' model perhaps reflect conditions in much of the North Carolina market, so no answer required?

@ Jim.
But Winnie the Pooh is a bear.
Shouldn't a bull take the trip down the stairs instead?

@ Shill
What an incredible waste of resources this whole credit bubble has been.
A damn shame.
and for what?
a bunch of wankerbankers?

Blackhalo:

I was referring to the Balkans and Haiti. Few people realize that, 10 years after the fact, much of Bosnia and Kosovo are directly administered by foreign powers in one of the few nakedly colonial societies left.

Homebuilders, retailers, and zombie banks all have risen mightily since March.

It is a Weimar rally where garbage stocks rise because they are chased with printed money and bank stocks rise because they get direct injections of free printed money .

None of this crap makes consumers solvent. None of this crap feeds the hungry. None of this crap stabilizes political anger. None of this crap creates jobs. None of this crap helps end medical bankruptcies.

The current situation reminds me of 2005 when it was heresy and madness to suggest house prices were silly. Currently, to suggest some form of sovereign default and monetary hyperinflation is seen as loony but it couldn't be more obvious.

US cattle wish to believe what they see on TV. They have invested their whole lives in the glowing blue Hypnosis Machine. Next time you go to the airport sit under the TV looking at the TV watchers. Watch the same expression form on every face. You will see mass hypnosis.

The truth is widespread ubiquitous insolvency is being papered over with $Trillions in pixellated cash. There will be extra cash in the system relative to lowered economic activity so prices will rise for no apparent reason (see stocks). The reason is debasement derived inflation an it is right in front of your face, just on the other side of the television.

How about the secret 13th Amendment, Broward? And Obama's birth certificate?

Evidence for the 13th Amendment is well-documented and your continued denial is your issue, not mine, and not particularly surprising, I've seen it often enough over the years.

Likewise the original birth certificate jpg posted on Obama's site was photo-shopped, I downloaded and examined it myself. and I've seen no explanation of why yet.

but.... you wouldn't know any of that because you never bothered to examine any source evidence, you "knew" that none of it could be true. Yes, the U.S. looks a lot like Germany circa 1930s.

Watch the same expression form on every face

We call them "mouth breathers" around here, Otiz

Hi, guys.

I am tired but my mom's house was closed, the money has been wired, and
the stuff has been moved.

Great anguish with movers who lied to me, and didn't show up until 5:30 in the evening.

The purchasers and I were freaking out. They had movers coming immediately.

The buyers got 4.75% rate. Young couple by my son overheard somethings indicating
they were under financial stress. Both working! Both good jobs!

We went to Fells Point, which is a small pleasant enclave on Near-Boston ambiance.

Food in restaurants is much more expensive than in South Florida.

Out to lunch and move my mom's money around.

Ours is the culture of denial.

"US cities may have to be bulldozed in order to survive "

I'm sure that's what they end up doing.

From a green philosophy point of view, I resent that a lot.

A lot of resource and Earth-hurting damage went into building the houses. It is very wasteful to completely bulldoze it.

To be, it's waste is akin to cutting down trees for sport, hunting animals and letting the meat rot; fishing whales just for the fun of killing it.

I cannot fathom why they cannot find some less wasteful ways of using these properties? And why we cannot leave them alone so the city can eventually grow back into them?

""I did not tell Bank of America's management that the Federal Reserve would take action against the board or management," Bernanke told the House of Representatives Oversight and Government Reform Committee."

Uh, huh. That might come back to bite him in the ass.

Yahoo! 404 - Page Not Found

And this just magnifies my dislike for GE/CNBC.

Yahoo!

The homes will rot before they can be used.

At least in Fla.

Black Mold and Chinese Drywall.
Yep, that's rot.

Averages don't work. The analysis shows averages and they will not work in this economy from an analysis perspective.

If averages did work, and extrapolating them into infinity, we should all just did a hole and jump in it now....

The more the government takes stakes in banks and businesses with the line of protecting the taxpayer the more fear I have. Simply put they are seeking more government revenue streams that the taxpayer will never see the the profits from. Indirect taxation hidden as taxpayer profit with government control. Beware!

The current US situation is not unique to history. We are a dead empire.

The twist was that our empire was corporate colonialism instead of the sovereign colonialism of history. Globalism and free trade were the cover story for corporate colonialism.

Corporate colonialists are now overextended and trying to extract all they can from their colonies (see credit cards).

The colonized are rejecting the colonists.

The people are rejecting corporate con games and the ponziconomy.

1940's post-war Germany: Marshall Plan

2010's post-war America: Martial Plan?

Springtime for Broward, and Idaho, di do di do.
Winter for liberals and their rants.

Tell us about the real 13th amendment, Broward, and everything else you have held in your hands.

1968 Producers: Sell 25,000% of a play, hope it bombs

2009 Producers: Sell 25,000% of a play, hope it doesn't bomb.

Unqualified - for years I knew people who looked at the debt to income ratio of american consumers and thought everyone was ok. I said, well, can we stratify that, to see who holds the debt and who gains the income. Silence.

Well, of course, the income was all taken by the top, and a lot of the debt by the bottom - you could infer this from other data sources, even if you couldnt necessarily build yourself a stratified debt to income ratio. It's all sitting in the survey of consumer finances from the FED, which of course, just got released with 2007 data. Lot of help that is.

But my point is that your point is well taken..averages can be woefully misleading.

Farrah Fawcett, 62, dies of cancer: reports

Time to break out the old pin up in memory.

It doesn't take an expensive research study looking at data back to 98 that consumption patterns and elevated house prices correlate. Common sense is enough.
This country has lived for too long on credit and false valuations. Time to buckle up.

rob dawg
why are they up so much,they going to start building new homes? or are they buying their own stock( they can do that,cant they ? but why would they want )

"I'm sure that's what they end up doing.

From a green philosophy point of view, I resent that a lot.

A lot of resource and Earth-hurting damage went into building the houses. It is very wasteful to completely bulldoze it.

To be, it's waste is akin to cutting down trees for sport, hunting animals and letting the meat rot; fishing whales just for the fun of killing it.

I cannot fathom why they cannot find some less wasteful ways of using these properties? And why we cannot leave them alone so the city can eventually grow back into them? "

I spent last night researching WWII era propaganda posters for a project of mine -- particularly those aimed at the U.S. home front.

And I was surprised at how "green" so many of the messages were: Grow your own food! And can it! Repair household goods instead of placing them! Eat less meat, don't waste food! Save gasoline! Carpool! (My favorite poster: "When you drive alone, HITLER rides with you!") Vacation locally! Learn useful skills! Work on farms! (Join the U.S. Crop Corps!) Collect waste and recycle it: rubber, metal, rags, cooking fat (for bombs!). All couched in terms of helping to defeat an evil enemy.

Not everybody took all this seriously, but many did. With the right motivation and coordination -- including impending poverty -- it could come around again, if couched in terms of achieving a vitally important goal.

While everyone was focused on Ben

Fed buys $3.25 billion in Treasurys

Dearest Broward,

Please show us one supreme court justice who has ever maintained that there was any other 13th amendment besides the real one that everyone knows about. One justice, just one. Alito? Roberts? Scalia? Any of them ever mention it? Or are they all closet pinkos?

Or how about one reputable historian? One? Or is that word "reputable" nothing but a placeholder for the vast conspiracy that has been destroying your liberty since the early nineteenth century?

Today's Funniest Job Ad -

craigslist | Page Not Found

Must posses a degree in design, and own your own equipment and software
Compensation: $9-$10 an hour DOE

Shill,
Re:Farah F
that was the time to have a poster business..rip

Fed extends emergency liquidity facilities and swap lines until Feb 2010

A bearded financier of academic veneer
had the full faith and credit of the nation,
then his memory went on permanent vacation
as men of means covered his rear.

He couldn't fin the OFF switch
Green shoots and transparancy were in the way
The prestidigitizerpaperprinter printed more each day
Using legal and ethical means, payback is a bitch.

Count de Monet: It is said that the people are revolting.

King Louis XVI: You said it! They stink on ice!

"But, I don't feel like I prevailed...I feel screwed. Is it just me?"

".I've no debt but right now I'm not sure I'm winning."

The pigs that lived above their means are either wiped out or on the verge. Imagine the stress they are going through with the bill collectors hounding them. The stigma.

Deflation is our friend. When the bigger crash comes later this year, you'll see that we made the right moves.

Hi liz, I was in TN looking at chiggerland.

Must posses a degree in design, and own your own equipment and software
Compensation: $9-$10 an hour DOE


$9 TO $10 Hmm! no thanks I would rather sit at home and collect, or walk the street collecting Nickle Cans for a living.

Juvenal Delinquent (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 12:56 pm

Count de Monet: It is said that the people are revolting.

King Louis XVI: You said it! They stink on ice!

Actually, as a Spaceball fan, my favorite line is--"We're surrounded by assholes."

de Money, Juvenal, de Money!!

"The stigma."

Not so sure there is a stigma for many. Some are boldly proud claiming they beat the system with BK and still have the home and stuff they over bought. Those of us with standards of responsibility suffer the reality of those who cheated and walk away to play another day.

no thanks I would rather sit at home and collect,

I averaged $16 / hr as part-time student (lab sysadmin) and that was seventeen years ago. Smile

"Today's Funniest Job Ad -"

That's complete lunacy - interns make more than that, and don't need their own tools or a degree.

Although the work I have seen coming out of some web shops makes me think that this sort of thing is not unusual.

Sorry to burst your bubble...

But I believe the Fed/Govt will do much more policy changes to ensure inflation is the end result, not deflation.

You ain't see nothing yet. The QE we see now is only an indication of the strengths of their intention, not their limit of power.

Try worshipping deflation when govt just doubles every govt job's salaries and forgive/monetize all the "assets" currently parked in Fed's books.

I don't see extended deflation after the new Fed/Govt stance.

And in an inflationary world, savers are screwed. This is not meant as an insult (I'm a saver too, and crying over my loss), just saying it as is.

Not so sure there is a stigma for many. Some are boldly proud claiming they beat the system with BK and still have the home and stuff they over bought. Those of us with standards of responsibility suffer the reality of those who cheated and walk away to play another day.

When the bigger crash comes, those sorts of people will get dragged into the streets and immolated.

To everyone that has saved for rainy days, the monsoon is coming... Evil

"Not so sure there is a stigma for many. Some are boldly proud claiming they beat the system with BK and still have the home and stuff they over bought. "

Maybe society gives them no stigma, but these are not the sort of people I invite into my home.

burnside: "Sebastian, what aspect of the Mian/Sufi 'elastic' model fails to represent your area? Bear in mind I know NC quite well."

I'll also bear in mind that you've already got your mind made up that I'm wrong. Why else would you imply that you'd be in a position to know if I was deliberately lying, instead of simply asking me to explain my viewpoint?

Well, how about let's cut to the chase. The thing that kicks the support out from under anything Mian/Sufi have to say is that there hasn't been a major drop in consumption!!!

U.S. Department of Commerce. Bureau of Economic Analysis

From NIPA Table 1.1.5 Gross Domestic Product, personal consumption expenditures (PCE) in Q1 2006 were $9.0263 trillion. In Q1 2007 PCE was $9.5249 trillion. In Q1 2008 PCE was $10.0023 trillion. In Q1 2009 PCE was $9.9385 trillion.

So, during the time that housing prices were collapsing (circa 2006-08), PCE was rising. When PCE did finally drop recently, it fell by 6/10 of 1%.

I mentioned this issue before when CR last put up his MEW "cliff-diving" chart, pointing out that while MEW ( the alleged support for all this profligate spending) was falling through the floor, consumption was rising, a clear disconnect from the contention that housing prices and MEW are major players in our spending.

Unfortunately, people prefer to ignore facts that get in the way of a good story.Smile

Sebastian

I posted an ad for a web designer to program an interactive bike builder and got about 90 respondents in a few days. None qualified. All "interested in a challenge." All had a ridiculous idea of what their skills were worth and most were, how do you put it, um, seething .

Collage artists.

I pulled the plug on the ad and gave up.

A friend of mine did something like this with a computer science degree, in a guys living room in southern california in 2005.

$14 an hour though, but he did have to bring his own laptop. And he was working in a guys living room like 45 hours a week.

I would assume the equivalent of $14 an hour in socal is $10 in ohio.

Sebastian, please note that when MEW was falling, it was still positive. That means its add on effect to consumption was diminishing, not that it was supposed to make spending drop. You arent really this daft, are you?

Consumption began to decline in q408, just after MEW finally returned to its mid 90s level.

GDD9000 said: "Sebastian, please note that when MEW was falling, it was still positive. That means its add on effect to consumption was diminishing, not that it was supposed to make spending drop. You aren't really this daft, are you?"

6/10 of 1% drop in consumption. Three years into our housing "collapse", the one that's going to send us into the next Great Depression? I'm not daft enough to believe that.Smile))

Sebastian

For the most part, I disagree that Bush's administration was the low point for civil liberties--unless Congress suddenly changes its ways or the courts get quite defiant--nothing much is going to change. I went to a civil liberties forum last week, in PDX, the panelists were attorneys working w/the National Lawyer's Guild (or for), head of a local ACLU chapter, a community organizer who's a former state rep (discussed racial profiling by police in PDX), and Stephen Wax, from the PDX Public Defenders' office. He was part of the PDX PD's office team that has represented some of the Gitmo detainees and Brandon Mayfield, the PDX attorney who was the subject of warrantless wiretapping & secret searches of his home (and attempted search of his law office) based on lousy evidence, fingerprint evidence that turned out to be completely wrong, and even after the feds knew that they continued to claim that the fingerprint match was valid. The two National Guild attorneys have been represented an Islamic charity & a few other clients

The general consensus was that the Obama administration has adopted the Bush Administration stand/position on warrantless wiretapping--meaning that the Executive branch says it & only it has the power to determine when it's ok to do wiretapping, etc., that includes US citizens. No warrant, not even a warrant procured through the FISA court, which at least would subject the alleged "evidence" to examination by a judge.

The O admin has also (explicitly) adopted the Bush admin position on the "state secrets" privilege. So it would seem that the Obama administration is also going for the Chief Exec as Great Poobah & dictator.

One of the biggest concerns expressed by the attorneys was that the evidence the Exec. uses as a basis for warrantless wiretapping is often of extremely poor quality. As in, more the expression of bias then based on any objective evidence. Yet, during the Bush admin, strategic "leaks" out of DC were used to effectively convict the accused prior to trial.

The one favorable point made is that upon Obama's taking office, he (allegedly, the panelist wasn't sure) revoked or repealed all of George jr's executive orders. There was also some discussion about classification & reclassification of the Gitmo detainees and how that might affect their ability to obtain due process, etc.

The panelists felt that the best possibility of a check on Exec power (since Congress seems to be wholly ineffective & unwilling to exercise its legitimate authority & power) was the courts. The general conclusion was that the trend, historically, was that judicial deference tends to decline as the originating "emergency" recedes into time. So, absent another 09/11, etc. one could expect the courts to offer greater resistance to the idea of an unfettered/unchecked executive branch.

Since these were people who have been involved in litigating some important cases, their POV carries considerable weight for me.

I too would like to see the Patriot Act repealed, also the Military Commissions Act.

The PDX PD's written a book you might be interested in reading: "Kafka Comes to America" by Stephen Wax. Great title, good book.

" MrM (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 11:06 am
......
Personal consumption continued to get revised down........Not a nice looking trend ..."
Depends....maybe we'll be better off with lower levels of consumption and greater levels of saving.

lama (profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 9:30 am

Rob,
The original Market Basket (Demoulas) in Lowell used to buy produce from my Papere's farm.
If they're still buying locally you could make the nut on your resort.

Cripes, I'm neveah gonna be allowed to leave am I?

We bought at Lapinski's in West Springfield. And Derby's Cider Mill of course.

" broward (homepage, profile) wrote on Thu, 6/25/2009 - 11:27 am

Geithner is stumbling around in another wood panelled room

It is dark.
You are likely to be eaten by a J6P."

Is this a D&D reference?!

@curious Comparing the activity of homeowners in SF to renters in SF helps to normalize the data.

That's an interesting idea...I also found the tidbit regarding the inverse relationship between creditworthiness and the strength of the effect interesting...not surprising really, but just interesting to see it crop up, yet again. What is that about lottery winners always winding up in horrible debt?

Borrow at 0% and loan at 5-8%
is just like printing money.

You forgot about the part where one in ten or one in eight or one in six borrowers never pay you back...

GDD9000 said: "Sebastian, please note that when MEW was falling, it was still positive. That means its add on effect to consumption was diminishing, not that it was supposed to make spending drop. You aren't really this daft, are you?"

PCE slowed and fell in staggered lockstep with MEW.

PCE
2006 Q1 4.3
2006 Q2 2·8
2006 Q3 2.2
2006 Q4 3·7
2007 Q1 3.9
2007 Q2 2·0
2007 Q3 2.0
2007 Q4 1.0
2008 Q1 0·9
2008 Q2 1·2
2008 Q3 -3·8
2008 Q4 -4·3
2009 Q1 1.4

Just superimpose that on the MEW chart:
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_pMscxxELHEg/Scj-vk4_KVI/AAAAAAAAE3o/uMkhuOAViqA/s1600-h/MEWactiveQ42008.jpg

The correlation is so tight...well, only a special type of person could miss it...or miss the worst recession or housing bust in 70 years.

Lama said: "The correlation is so tight...well, only a special type of person could miss it...or miss the worst recession or housing bust in 70 years."

Another personal insult based on the assumption that you think you're right and I'm stupid, but that's progress, I guess.

CR's MEW chart is in dollars, your data is in percentage growth, not the same measure or scale. However, if you measure dollars of PCE and dollars of MEW and superimposed them, the correlation goes right out the window. It would show MEW utterly collapsing while PCE sailed higher. Add housing prices to the chart, and it would show housing prices collapsing and MEW collapsing, while PCE went higher.

Just because I missed seeing the recession and housing bust (which I have publicly admitted to without any attempt to avoid it) doesn't mean that CR or Mian/Sufi are right about the reasons, especially when now that we have the benefit of hindsight the reasons are a debatable fit to the data.

Sebastian

I'm done. If you want anything else, send a retainer.

CR proposed that MEW was the only driver of PCE, not credit cards, not the defined wealth effect. Hmmm. I missed that post by CR.
"The worst kind of troll is the one who doesn't know he's a troll" - Tanta

lawyerliz (profile) wrote on Sat, 6/27/2009 - 7:05 pm edit reply Even if you add just 50 or 100 bucks a month, you will pay
your mtg down much faster.

Our first Fla house, they would give us only a 25 year mtg, 'cause
they said the house was only rated to last another 25 years, so
we paid it off slightly faster. The new owners got a 30 year mtg when
we sold 9 years later, in 81, and it's still very much there.

Then, here, we again got a 25 year mtg, and whenever we got a
windfall or the hub got a bonus, paid down the mtg. It's was paid
off a year and a half ago.

There is hardly any difference in payment between a 25 and 30
year mtg. And only a little more with a 20 year mortgage.
The 15 has a significantly increased payment, but a lower
rate.

The Kathy McM article is sad, but no doubt true.

Thanks Costs

lawyerliz (profile) wrote on Sat, 6/27/2009 - 7:05 pm edit Double post deleted.

Login or register to post comments
Syndicate content