The Obama Regulatory Reform Plan

Oh good, another dog and pony show from the Obama Administration.

Smoke and teleprompters.

Expect an even more watered down version from our US Congress...

How does it address the moral failure of regulators and politicians? I.E. the Greenspan Syndrome.

Some of the darkest periods of human history have been accompanied by lots and lots of regulation.

"ORRP!" : the sound one makes having mistakenly bent-over in debtors-prison; taxpayer's exclamation (universal)

--bh

Lawyers, accountants, politicians and bankers, insurance execs should not be in charge of this country or any country.

You want reform bring back Glass-Steagall

OT: From a couple of threads back on inflation (wasn't awake early enough to post Smile )

I'm surprised at people's dramatic reaction over core CPI (a useless government data, which excludes food and energy prices). What's next? We go ga-ga over the U3 unemployment numbers stabilizing? And what's with the weird belief that unemployment or lack of cash prevents hyperinflation? No it doesn't; a loss of faith in the dollar leads to hyperinflation. A panic triggered by a massive selloff of dollar will lead to dollar dropping 30-40% overnight. Something affected by, let's say, BRIC's sudden formation of a new currency (when they finally got rid of enough dollars) like:

China's holding of US bonds drops first time in 11 months (as well as Russia/Brazil)
AFP: China's holding of US bonds drops first time in 11 months

BRIC - Russia stresses need for new reserve currency
Dollar slides after Russia comments, BRIC summit |
Business |
guardian.co.uk

Oh good, another dog and pony show from the Obama Administration.

Hey wait a minute. Where the hell did my pony get off to?

On Eastern Front of the Potomac, it takes a Potemkin Village

...another dog and pony show from the Obama Administration

But this pony will poop Skittles! We promise!

New rules are swell and all, but what do we do about all the problems from the old rules?

And giving the Fed more power is dumb.

Damn, CR got it in twice already. But he was quoting, mine was original.

Yes! More power to the private bankers at the Fed!

I propose the creation of at least 4 new regulatory bodies to supervise the financial sector. These will add thousands of jobs to the economy and act as a stimulus in themselves.
Their effectiveness is secondary to a govt. job creation scheme.

They could be:
- Department of financial regulation and supervision
- Department of financial supervision and regulation
- Department of supervision and financial regulation
- Department of regulation and financial supervision

  • splat

If this is another dog and pony show, maybe the SPCA is what we need, since I suspect it's being run by a puppy mill.

Isn't it hilarious how the Wide Elephant Party is trying to pin the tale on the Donkey?

They could be:
- Department of financial regulation and supervision
- Department of financial supervision and regulation
- Department of supervision and financial regulation
- Department of regulation and financial supervision

Their net effect on the economy and financial markets will be:
- splat

Fixed your post. I'm sure it was just an innocent oversight on your part. Laughing out loud

"The Financial Services Oversight Council will replace the President’s Working Group on Financial Markets and will have a permanent, full‐time staff at Treasury."

So, the PPT will be renamed to the FSOC. And it will have a permanent, full-time trading account at State Street Bank, Goldman Sachs, and JPM.

Obama wants to dumb finance down so even we dumb Americans can understand it.

Bubbles (and the bursting of the bubbles) are not created by the market. They are the results of government interventions in the market in order to get elected. The sheer fact that the man in charge of bank regulation during the subprime mess, Mr. Geithner, then in charge of the central bank of NY, is now the treasury secretary is the proof that Obama has no respect of the truth or the people. You want regulation, you start by stopping promoting the crooks.

Hey BHO

How do you expect the banks to make money?

Any serious attempt at reform must start with two core principles:

1) "Incentives matter." (Appraisers were bought; ratings agencies had conflicts of interest; executive compensation was aligned with betting the global financial system on "red"; etc.)

2) "Too big to fail is too big to exist." Kind of obvious, actually.

The proposed reforms come nowhere near either of these, and thus do we sow the seeds of the next crisis.

Maybe after that one, we will actually do something.

I am sure Obama is making it sound really, really good though.

It's all just high-fructose con syrup, ladled out generously...

Band-aids on gaping chest wounds

Maybe after that one, we will actually do something.

I think things will have to get a lot worse (crowds marching with torches and pitchforks, etc.) before any serious reforms will be put through. After all, the problems are contained.

So new contracts will include simple language and pictures for the unsophisticated consumer?

This is garbage, as I said this morning. 8 trillion for this?

p.53

"We will propose legislation that broadly defines the characteristics of systemically
important payment, clearing, and settlement systems (covered systems) and sets
objectives and principles for their oversight. We propose that the Federal Reserve, in
consultation with the Council, to identify covered systems and to set risk management
standards for their operation. We will propose legislation that defines a covered system
as a payment, clearing, or settlement system the failure or disruption of which could
create or increase the risk of significant liquidity or credit problems spreading among
financial institutions or markets and thereby threatening the stability of the financial
system. "

@Ben - probably pictures like that old/young lady...

"Obama: Government's role is to unleash creativity in markets"

Now, can anyone show me where that is stated or implied in the Constitution or Bill of Rights?

Yeah, I'm with Tim. How can banks make uberprofits without shenanigans?

A Potomacan Village.

Well, I've been working. Futilely I might add.

Has Cali been bailed out yet?

  • no "going forwards" or "moving forwards"
  • no "the Economy is strong"
  • no flight jacket and carrier landing
  • no attack yet on another country
  • he doesn't acknowledge that the foundation is rotten - it has to be rebuilt not propped up
  • "everlasting prosperity"....fiction

Whenever I read the word "transparency" in Obama press releases, it pisses me off. Transparency means removing your earlier forecasts on unemployment from your web site when it turn out worse, and getting information from the Fed only through force of Congressional subpoena. Yeah, transparency.

Then didn't bother to edit the barrage of the royal "we" halfway through.

So after 8 years of complete and utter negligence and willful blindness, within 6 months we have an administartion putting out proposals for oversight and reform, and the comments sum to:

Teh Obama is teh suxx0r!

And that's not counting the miscreants on my ignore list (instituted this week for the first time)

Nemo wrote
2) "Too big to fail is too big to exist." Kind of obvious, actually.

DAMN RIGHT.

  • splat

ac (profile) wrote on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 10:01 am

*

How does it address the moral failure of regulators and politicians? I.E. the Greenspan Syndrome.


I believe Thomas Jefferson said this problem should be addressed by the patriot.

Where is Sheila Bair in all of this? FDIC gets absorbed or something? And no predatory lending? What will all those salesmen do for a living - cars, jewelry, furniture, annuities, insurance.... And also no mandate to the schools to teach any kind of financial wisdom...

I was listening to a thing on medical costs & insurance on NPR.

One the the interviewees said that drs are ENTITLED to a comfortable living.

Hmmm.

Substitute other occupations there.

Lawyers (!) are ENTITLED. . .

Auto workers are ENTITLED. . .

Sales Clerks are ENTITLED.. . .

Farmers are ENTITLED . . .

Etc.

He didn't think he was saying anything in any way unusual or exceptional, and
indeed the interviewer did not challenge him on it.

Edit: the interviewee was a doctor. Gotta make that clear.

There was a gawdawful consortium called AMF in the 60-70's, that tried to be everything to everybody and ended up being nothing to nobody...

small is beautifuller

Financial Bubble Vison previewed an interview with O yesterday.
They spent a minute on the economic topics and 5 minutes on how he swatted a fly.
(they even gave us a close-up)

I put a couple of hours into this on the overnight thread, Gary. Check it out. I'm beat. Strengthen this, enhance that. Very little substance, and no check on the power of the FED.

Where do you think we are on this chart of "Recovery Prognosticators" ?

(note I have nothing to do with this site. Just thought it was interesting because of all the recovery talk!!)

1927-1933 Chart of Pompous Prognosticators

BURN!! Tear it DOWN!!

That was my fly on the wall, that got the swat.

Gary wrote:
So after 8 years of complete and utter negligence and willful blindness, within 6 months we have an administartion putting out proposals for oversight and reform, and the comments sum to:

Teh Obama is teh suxx0r!

It's not that we don't blame the previous administration or administrations before that one. It's just that these proposals seem to come up far short of what most of us think is needed. So, it is an expression of disappointment. I was hoping for better, but got about what I expected.

Perhaps if we built a large wooden badger....

by now your eyeballs are tired from all these postings and comments... so here's a little eye candy from Cambodia
to relieve the stress (something for everyone...)
should do the trick...
YouTube - Holiday in Cambodia on a Happy Shake & Booze Cruise with Wild & Crazy Beautiful Girls

and the comments sum to:

Teh Obama is teh suxx0r!

I think you see what you want to see.

Reality is a harsh taskmaster and we were able to shield our eyes from it during the Section 8 Years...

Bubbles (and the bursting of the bubbles) are not created by the market. They are the results of government interventions in the market in order to get elected...

I think an honest assessment of the historical record leads to the conclusion that markets do go to excesses on their own, but in modern markets these excesses have not become extreme until they began to correct and threaten the economy at which point politicians use government machinery to halt the correction of these excesses in the name of rescuing the economy. Once the market knows it has a government provided safety net as well as the additional liquidity usually provided by these rescues that's when it really goes insane and you get the extraordinary destructive bubble events we saw post 1927, 1998, 2001, 2007 as well as the Japan debacle.

Unleash creativity by bogging us down with debt, taxes, and regulations? That's a new one. Might as well tie up a runner to a ball and chain and tell him to do his best.

Vampire Economics anyone?

RATM (profile) wrote on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 11:08 am

Obama wants to dumb finance down so even we dumb Americans can understand it.


Fine by me.
'
"There are three kinds of financial instruments: stocks, bonds, and bullshit."

Or someone else said "financial innovation" is the latest technique to make a bad loan.

There are good uses for futures, options etc, but most derivatives = BS.

yogi, which thread? There are many. I suspect CR may be a Cylon.

"While the crash only took place six months ago, I am convinced we have now passed through the worst -- and with continued unity of effort we shall rapidly recover. There has been no significant bank or industrial failure. That danger, too, is safely behind us."
- Herbert Hoover, President of the United States, May 1, 1930

BURN
Tear it DOWN

Excuse me, are we females chopped liver that we don't get pictures of handsome men?

Gary, Gary, Gary.

You are right about one thing: Compared to Bush, Obama looks competent.

Unfortunately, that is the only sense in which he does.

Lawyerliz,

Doctors in McCallum, Texas seem to believe that they are entitled to 100% more Medicare payments per patient than the Menninger Clinic!

McAllen, Texas and the high cost of health care : The New Yorker 

Gold Star to whomever can find the loopholes first.

Red Pill,

I agree with you, to an extent. But I also notice most people don't want to know about finance, and go out of their way to avoid it. They are shocked, just shocked when they lose money and don't know why.

Well, of course they do; they are ENTITLED.

I printed out all the jolly comments from GD I.

Thanks.

The first thing we do, let's kill all the bankers.

People in general don't want responsibility for their decisions. Ever notice casinos have mostly slot machines and not gaming tables? Pull the handle and the thinking is done for you.

The first thing we do, let's kill all the bankers.


They are already dead, they just don't know it yet.

More power to the fed? Are any of you as flabergasted as I am?

The unregulated fed?
The fed owned by bankers?
The fed that won't even tell us how bankrupt they are by letting the public know what toxic stuff they loaned against?
The Fed that created the bubbles?

That fed?

OMG!!!

Obama Revises Campaign Promise Of 'Change' To 'Relatively Minor Readjustments In Certain Favorable Policy Areas'

May 29, 2009 |

WASHINGTON—In a slight shift from his campaign trail promise, President Obama announced Monday that his administration's message of "Change" has been modified to the somewhat more restrained slogan "Relatively Minor Readjustments in Certain Favorable Policy Areas." "Today, Americans face a great many challenges, and I hear your desperate calls for barely measurable and largely symbolic improvements in the status quo," said Obama, who vowed never to waver in his fight for every last infinitesimal nudge forward on the controversial issues of torture and the military ban on homosexuals. "Remember: Yes we can, if by that you mean tiptoeing around potentially unpopular decisions that could alienate a large segment of the populace." Washington insiders said that, while the new mottos are certainly in keeping with Obama's pledge of government transparency, they are significantly less catchy.

From The Onion

Dean Baker said this :

"Even a perfect regulatory structure will not work, if the regulators do not do their job. They will not have an incentive to do their job, if there are no consequences for not doing their job.

In this case, we have seen the most disastrous possible regulatory failure -- this is like the drunken school bus driver who gets all his passengers killed driving into oncoming traffic -- and no one is held accountable. The message to future regulators is therefore to simply go along with the powers that be (i.e. the financial industry) and you will never suffer any negative consequences."

"Gold Star to whomever can find the loopholes first. "

The Fed needs Treasury permission. The Treasury and FRB people are all former (or current) Goldman Sucks senior management/board members.

Yep, people are always trying to get me to make their decisions for them.

I explain to a point then say you can do x or y; that's your decision. They don't want to make it.

The sec'y sez that a helicopter is circling over our bldg. I said maybe someone was gonna
throw money out. She doessn't think so.

RATM,
I agree as well. Funny thing though, many around me are starting to learn a bit more about this stuff! Nothing like fear as a motivator. I anticipate "financial advisers" taking a BIG hit with this catastrophe.

ac,
Another good example of government/financial synergy in really ramping up a bubble is John Law's bubble in early 1700s France. It was a doozy and financial historians credit a lot of went on as early examples of the financial innovations (fiat currency and central banking) that are ubiquitous today!

I don't know why this one doesn't come up more often.

The one on the "near-final draft". Not one cent collaborated.

Well, Pill, it is history. . . Don't know much about history.

Oompa Loompa Loopholey
You get a Gold Star
If you find one for me

A few comments on the doctors...

While we have all mocked the "brain drain" comments on Wall Street, anyone want to bet how many people are going to go through 4 years of med school, 3-5 years of residency, another 1-3 (or more) of fellowship to emerge $100K (minimum) in debt?

Yes, I'm biased. It's still something to consider and I don't think they are entitled to anything as such. My 2 cents.

booze, a cruise and beautiful women ( a few guys tossed in to) tossed in to... forget the financials for a second
and think of the essentials....

yes, there is a brief glance at the Duke himself.... (got so burned yesterday from reading....

YouTube - Holiday in Cambodia on a Happy Shake & Booze Cruise with Wild & Crazy Beautiful Girls

Gary, Gary, Gary.

You are right about one thing: Compared to Bush, Obama looks competent.

Unfortunately, that is the only sense in which he does.

I still don't know what to make of Obama. I always felt that Bush meant well but was incompetent and didn't understand reality or the fact that he wasn't on a mission from God.

It's hard for me to think of Obama as being incompetent. It seems to me he has the intellect and ability to be highly competent. What I worry is that maybe he lacks enough real-world experience and wisdom to really question his own abilities and beliefs (sometimes that's a strength I'll admit).

I've personally gone through periods where I had absolute faith in my own abilities as well as certain beliefs I held.

After a good ass kicking and a lot of personal harm my perspective was adjusted by the world outside my head. The thing is I realize that I could have only gotten that experience via the ass kicking.

Per prior thread, how slow a recovery does it have to be before it isn't a recovery at all?

Mish said this :

"Note how increased power is given to the Fed, an agency that did not see this coming and whose premise is that bubbles are best dealt with after the fact because no one can tell bubbles in advance.

The best way to limit appetite for risk is to prevent the Fed from manipulating interest rates to ridiculously low levels. The way to do that is to abolish the Fed, not strengthen its power."

~ I would nationalize the privately owned and operated Federal Reserve and place it in the Treasury Department ... but we agree, as presently constituted and enabled the Fed is an institution that needs to be reconciled to a much lesser or no role in the regulatory scheme ...

If you paraphrase Shakespeare, don't add words.

The first thing, let's kill all the tax breaks.

ac,
Another good example of government/financial synergy in really ramping up a bubble is John Law's bubble in early 1700s France. It was a doozy and financial historians credit a lot of went on as early examples of the financial innovations (fiat currency and central banking) that are ubiquitous today!

I don't know why this one doesn't come up more often.

If I recall correctly, even during the original Tulipomania the Dutch government tried (unsuccessfully) to prop up the tulip market when it collapsed.

No response on Cali bailout question. Please don't make me read all the prior threads.

"Even a perfect regulatory structure will not work, if the regulators do not do their job. They will not have an incentive to do their job, if there are no consequences for not doing their job.

I'm more worried about the active incentives not to do their job. There needs to be harsh restrictions on leaving regulatory bodies and moving into finance.

Good article on John Law - he was way ahead of his time - and he died broke too - hear that, Dick Fuld?

John Law (economist) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 

My feeling has been that part of the healthcare reform (maybe it is a bribe but hey) is to pay off the doctors. Pay off their debt and pay for the new one's school (mostly anyway) then you would get people who want to be doctors not greedy who want to be rich. Then they can afford to get paid what the govt will pay which will be generous but not outlandish. They have to work for govt for certain amount of time before they can go completely outside govt system. This would bring those people on board and not penalize the people that went into debt when they thought they could make lots of money as doctors.

Me and the VP already got our Medicare Card and now we are waiting on our goverment issued credit/ration slip.
Life is good.

No CA bailout announced yet...

The fastest growing component of health care inflation is medical technology, which is basically the intersection of finance and patents.

Yep, I have no objection to those going into gov't doc services getting a bunch of their debt \
(up to a quarter mil!) forgiven.

I have a feeling, one way or the other, most of those school loans will not be paid, In all
fields.

We are moving towards total govt dependency with a monthly allowance... food debit card, medical debit card, etc... Too bad we dont have the smart robots to do all the work - we still need people to do that... So I'm sure all you suckers will go to work to support my debit cards, wont you... Those who become dependent will become a meal for those who still know how to do things...

One power loop

The FED cannot lend money without the Treasuries permission. It gives the illusion of oversight but actually concentrates more power in the two agencies.

The Capital requirements will be determined by the FED who will not put more stress on the banks than they know they can handle. The FED doesn't want to oversee a large failure. Remember how BB deflected questions about Lehman, basically said "talk to the Treasury"

Ivy Tower BS of the highest order

If Newton was alive hanging out in the Big Apple presently instead of jolly olde way back when, would he grasp the gravity of the situation, or just get caught up in the moment, and take another bubble-bath?

@lawyerliz,

I head on the radio yesterday that the legislature is supposed to have a budget proposal at the end of this week, but everyone doubts it will get done. I've heard no other news about it.

@MsAnn - guess where the doctors do their residencies? The county hospitals for the most part. Those are not "for profit" institutions. They already go through 3-5 years of being paid on a fixed scale depending on post-grad years and the city they live in. For a 3rd year, I believe the pay is something around 47K/year.

So 44 or 45 days left to Calisposion?

Thx Shadow.

And I meant I know those who owe a quarter mil, not that I necessarily think that much should be forgiven.

Juvenal Delinquent (profile) wrote on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 10:42 am

If Newton was alive hanging out in the Big Apple presently instead of jolly olde way back when, would he grasp the gravity of the situation, or just get caught up in the moment, and take another bubble-bath?

Not sure about Newton, but Einstein would find that all currencies are relative.

Basel on Med tech

That technology would not be implemented without the endorsements of hospital directors and doctors.

Cap reimbursement rates via Medicare/Inurance reumbs and that spending will end very quickly IMO.

I bet 100 quatloos that the Cali legislature will not pass anything remotely
viable in the next week.

OT:
I love living in South Carolina.
We have a 56% high school graduation rate and this fool suggests this:

TheState.com 404

CA legislature could not pass gas without a tax increase...

Basel

The only reason hospitals spend more on technology is two reasons.

  1. They can bill for new procedures, tests etc
  2. They can save time to see more patients or do more procedures.

Oh yeah and there is a little ego and reputation involved.

A Fart Tax?

Don't give 'em any ideas, Shadow.

Well, if they learned to swim, I guess they'd have learned SOMETHING.

hahahahahah, Shadow.

I passed 17 CHP cruisers debt on the side of the road, with quarry intact last week, on a 200 mile stretch of what i've renamed Route $666...

The Fed and Law Enforcement Officers both have a printing press and aren't afraid to abuse it~

In the overall scheme the only way to regulate the financial system is to regulate the overall amount of credit available to the system ...

To do this we need to prohibit fractional reserve banking and have the Treasury auction credit with the proceeds going into the Treasury

to reduce debt and taxes ...

Only by having one source of credit will we have the ability to manage credit ... having thousands of financial institutions with

the ability to leverage 10 to 1 is Not manageable ...

Sunday, July 08, 2007
Swimming and the Talmud...

"According to the Talmud, A Jewish parent is required to teach his/her child three things (Kiddushin 29a).

1. The first is Torah (that is, the rules of the world as we understand them and wrong from right).
2. The second is to prepare them for some way to make a living so that they can support themselves and their families.
3. The third is to teach them how to swim."

Don't forget the coolness factor of all that gleaming equipment purchased by hospitals.

Anyone notice that the transports seem to be leading us down. Bearish IMO

Sign of the times: The Office of Thrift Supervision gets abolished.

"The fastest growing component of health care inflation is medical technology, which is basically the intersection of finance and patents. "

And a system in which none of the major customers exercise effective pricing power.

Saw a Frontline special on national healthcare systems in other countries. In Japan, there was a need for cheaper, simpler MRI (I think) scanners to do jobs that you don't need the Cadillac version for -- and all that was made was the Cadillac version. The gov't was the chief procurator in this case and they told private industry -- make 'em this way, or sell very few more in these parts." And they made 'em that way.

That doesn't much happen here. The just buy the Cadillac version and pass the costs along.

Medical technology is wonderful - ever get a cat scan? New cat scanners are basically using HDTV technology and can detect even smaller tumors etc... There is one on the way that will be able to detect colon polyps so the colonoscopy will become much less common - if you have never had one yet it takes 2 days of fasting and drinking really nasty colyte stuff before you can have the procedure, which requires sedation... I'll be real happy if I never have to do that again...
I'm waiting for the smart bed that monitors vitals while sleeping, and the smart toilet that does analysis... and both of those items are networked to your medical record...

I need an attitude adjustment.

Right now, I'm saying to myself "The resulting legislation will be so full of holes that it'll sound like a steam calliope when the wind blows."

Maybe I'm drinking the wrong coffee...

OT: A teacher friend from California reports that his district has put its staff on notice that anyone with fewer than 12 years seniority can consider themselves layoff fodder--and if you're in a "non-mission-critical" position, such as band director, you might as well start looking for your next job.

It's really grim south of the (Oregon) border...

"Sell a man a fish, he eats for a day, teach a man how to fish, you ruin a wonderful business opportunity. "

We need to practice preventative Medicine.

lawyerliz wrote
Per prior thread, how slow a recovery does it have to be before it isn't a recovery at all?

The new metric is, if the line on the graph is not pointing straight down and/or the rate of decline has slowed, then it is clearly an indicator that the recovery is in full swing.

  • splat

MsAnnaNOLA,
I basically agree about the doctor pay solution but disagree on the characterization of motives. Most med students are good intentioned. My wife is finishing her fellowship and I have seen large parts of the training process. It is four years of med school, 2-5 years of residency (3 years for my wife), and more years of fellowship (3 years for my wife). She has a bachelors of science, and MD and soon to be 6 years of post MD training. She has never earned more than $56,000 dollars. We are still paying off student debt. She has worked weeks up to 100 hours in a week before new regulations were in place. When she is on call she often has to go in at 1-5 AM even while having worked the day before and after.
There is fear of lawsuits and business types are telling you how much time you have to see a patient. PAtients demand the purple pill (or insert advertised whatever) and are not convinced when you tell them they don't need it.

In surveys, around 70% say they wish they did something else. After watching a number of people go through this I have concluded we have a system that takes well intentioned people, beats them down, puts them into debt, and voila! you get jaded people trying to go home to sleep and earn "their due." It's misery becoming a doctor.

It needs to change.

"A Fart Tax?"

Coming to cows soon!

@Red Pill - I see we're in the same boat regarding spouses.

"graduation rate and this fool suggests this:"

Wendell is an idiot. Always has been.

Yeah, If all the docs actually do ultimately is operate on your leftest toenail, there is no reason for all to go to
a zillion years of school.

one reason med technology is so high is that the consumer can't put apply a price-utility function to an MRI or PET scan, since there are no alternatives (the patent part). On the other hand, a patient can forgo birthing in a hospital for midwife services. How often have you thought "the doctor did 5 minutes worth of work, and billed me what?"

Yep, farts are a significant part of greenhouse gases (as are termites), so let's tax 'em.

ShadowInventory

Isn't that part of the crap and trade tax they are talking about?

Termites account for over 85% of the biomass of the planet...

"The thing is I realize that I could have only gotten that experience via the ass kicking."

I've had my share of hard lessons - and my opinions today are significantly evolved from the ignorant and arrogant of my early 20s as a result.

On Bush: I think he's deeply flawed, not evil in the sense that Cheney is evil, but weak and in way over his head. Still, i hold him 100% responsible for everything that happened on his watch.

On Obama, the jury is still out. I have been disappointed in a few things so far, but I firmly believe it is far too early to make any meaningful assessments. I also believe that significant wrongdoing from the prior administration will be dealt with, but these things take time.

Think of turning around a container ship.

If you paraphrase Shakespeare, don't add words.

I don't.

"A Fart Tax?"
Coming to cows soon!

Ban meat !! Make everyone vegetarian ! It'll save the planet or the agricultural farming industry one of the two..

  • splat

Crap and trade - that sort of sums up our relationship with China, doesnt it...

Red Pill wrote:

It's misery becoming a doctor. It needs to change.

Maybe you should look at the AMA. Who imposes the rules? Who controls the requirements and number of doctors certified?

I am not placing blame, but doesn't the AMA play a role in the how the process works?

"In surveys, around 70% say they wish they did something else. After watching a number of people go through this I have concluded we have a system that takes well intentioned people, beats them down, puts them into debt, and voila! you get jaded people trying to go home to sleep and earn "their due." It's misery becoming a doctor."

The most societally-important physician slots (family practice, public health, etc.) are the ones that pay the least -- and then there's that debt.... Any decent national health plan should include incentives to get doctors to train for the jobs that are most important to the most people -- not simply the most remunerative. One way is to incent doctors who train for those positions by paying some or most of their medical school debt in return for a promise of service -- and a carrot of even more training in that field.

If you structure a system so that you're rewarded only for going for the bucks and punished for thinking of society as a whole -- what do you think happens?

regulations, regulations and more regulations and then Stalin or is that obama.

I read about a 22 year old commercial airline pilot pulling down $22k a year, the other day...

Wouldn't a Mickey D's manager make more than that?

"Excuse me, are we females chopped liver...

It ain't much, ll, but it's what I got... me out on the back patio of my room at the Casa Marina in the Keys this past Saturday morning.

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2007/3635508109_8ca0b1c05b_o.jpg

Healthcare : We need HR 676 Single Payer ...

Cuts profit ~ 20%

Cuts overhead ~ 15%

Bargaining for Drugs ~ 10%

~~~~

Allows standardization for billing, records and treatments ... Through records with names being withheld for privacy, data regarding treatments can be

gathered to find the best treatments and drugs for injury and disease ...

But you fly for the hours not the wages.

It's SC - I'm surprised he's not suggesting they teach abstinence from swimming.

The marketplace would work on it's own with medical care, if the govt would let it happen - look at plastic surgery - no insurance covers it, people have to pay out of pocket, if they want it they use referrals to find a good doc... and plastic surgery is one of the least costly medical procedures available... No govt, no insurance companies, system works fine.... Hong Kong medical services used to work that way when Hong Kong was independent - people were not interested in buying insurance, a lot of doctors practiced from storefronts in neighborhoods, people told each other who was good, who was too expensive, just like any other service... System worked well - I'm not sure what they do now that they are part of China - it's probably all screwed up too...

It's misery becoming a doctor.

It needs to change.

Yes, I see no reason for the abusive work loads for residents. It's just stupid.

I have noticed that as the inevitability of limited resources sets in, that the trash talk of other people's professions and how they are overpaid is ramping up. The implied message is that whatever the trash talker does for a living is paid just right. This does not bode well for the mass joining of hands and solving our problems in wonderful heart felt cooperation.

But what do I know. I am just and underpaid science dork. Wink

I try to be open minded, but I am really pissed at bankers.

Those small tumors they are detecting are the ones most likely to go
away by themselves without treatment.

mmckinl (profile) wrote on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 2:00 pm

* reply
* Ignore user

Healthcare : We need HR 676 Single Payer ...

Cuts profit ~ 20%

Cuts overhead ~ 15%

Bargaining for Drugs ~ 10%

And you better get a passport so you can go someplace else for healthcare. I heard Osama will provide better care than osama!

homegnome: i've met wendell gillaird a couple of times. not the sharpest tool in the shed. Most of the drowning deaths have involved kids under the age to 12, so i'm not sure how a graduation requirement would help that group. Darwin might have a word or two regarding 18 year olds that dont know how to swim hanging around unsupervised swimming pools.

Take it off, Take it alllll off.

Perzbo does not have too much more to Nationalize to have seized total dominance.....I'm pulling for you COMRADE!!!!!!! From the Peoples Republic of Amerika

Oops. My bad. I'm sticking to the 5 books. Shakespeare's better heard than read, anyway.

It's misery becoming a doctor.

I would agree. During the Nazcrash, I looked into my non-offshorable options. It was far too late in life for me to think about being a doctor.

The sweet spot seemed to be PA. Bio or some other pre-medical degree. 3 years graduate school. In 2002, I was seeing an average around here of $105K salary plus a $100K signing bonus.

America becomes Ameribabwe - 100 million dollar notes in every wallet...

"The marketplace would work on it's own with medical care,"

Proven to be false ...

~~~~

By example we can prove that single payer health care is the "best" approach to health care ...

G7 countries that some form of single payer cover all their citizens for less cost and better outcomes ...

"I am not placing blame, but doesn't the AMA play a role in the how the process works? "

Big time. Clinton gave in to them back in the '90s and cooperated with a limit on the number of doctors than the nation's medical schools would graduate.

Meh. I've been defending universities to some degree, but setting up a monopoly like this only favors the few. Me, I'd say let there be a path from nurse practitioner up to full MD, or so close that the difference is hard to see. But of course the AMA is blocking that path.

@sdtfs - The alternatives to fewer hours per week are more years of residency. It's a bad trade-off either way. When training, there are a certain number of patients/cases you need to see - the doctors themselves would likely tell you the same thing. There's no getting around the experience required.

I don't want the government in our medical system. Want lower cost? Deport illegals, cut welfare no pays out and the hospitals won't screw their cost into you bills.

Aaand, goodbye, Comrade Mike.

Thanks Ken!

And the no-pays just. . .die?

Might be ok, except I have two words:

Communicable diseases.

I am not placing blame, but doesn't the AMA play a role in the how the process works?


I think the AMA only represents about a third of doctors now. It is a weakened trade organization. I was listening to the spokesperson the other day and I admit their rhetoric makes them seem disconnected from the severity of the problems. Like the rhetoric from finance.

The "system" is an inhuman cogwheel machine with big cogs being insurance, drug companies, lawyers, AMA, and much entrenched infrastructure. My sad conclusion is that real change only comes with severe systemic failure.

A system that treats people as cogs (I am looking at you Bernanke and economists in general) creates unhappy people. Is this really surprising.

And it is insane giving power to profit motivated organizations over a "product" that you can easily extort people with. Duh.

Lobbyist Ben Dover

~I don't want the government in our medical system. Want lower cost? Deport illegals, cut welfare no pays out and the hospitals won't screw their cost into you bills.~

~~~~

Until you lose your job and your health care with it ...

I know some personally who want to make money which I think negatively affects patient care and costs. I wish I didn't have first hand knowledge of this.

I am glad they changed the law so they don't have to work as many long hours, clearly that would lead to errors.

Debt is the enemy. It is very very bad to have people trapped in debt having to do jobs they don't like. It give bad incentives to milk the system and have fraudulent care.

I think universites should have in addition to truth in lending they should show what the people getting any given degree make 1, 5 and 10 years after graduation. This would give people pause. Until recently financial advisors always said "student loan debt is good debt" the financial community is finally fessing up that this is not always the case.

Residency could be replaced with a sort of master craftsman program - apprentice, journeyman, master - new graduates would work alongside more experienced doctors until they had the skills to function on their own... But only working a reasonable number of hours per day and week, not the Giant Hoop to jump through as it is now...

One other tangentially related observation on health-care... anyone know what the typical commission structure on health insurance products is like? Is that efficient? Near as I can tell an insurance company consists of:

A) A finance/investment firm attached to
B) A bureaucracy that
i) pays claims when forced/obvious
ii) tries like hell to avoid paying claims
iii) HR/functional departments

I'm not sure but aggregating a lot of the bureaucracy might actually be efficient. Would the same people that defended MSFT as a monopoly refuse the same claim about something like health insurance?

If you care to read it, here's the transcript of a Frontline special on universal health coverage in five different countries (England, Germany, Switzerland, Taiwan, Japan), ran last year -- an EXCELLENT comparison of the different approaches, and their weaknesses.

FRONTLINE: sick around the world: dvd + transcript | PBS

I find it interesting that the Swiss PM, a conservative, came right out and said unrestrained free market health care just won't do the job. And that it would be a national scandal if somebody had gone bankrupt from health costs. The Swiss had a totally private system like ours into the '90s.

OT:

Has anyone ever ordered from APMEX?
Good/ Bad/ Ugly?

I never had a job that paid health care and paid my for my own. Still do and have paid some big dollars. Employer health care is not free it is earned by the employee or they get fired.

@MsAnn- the med students are more or less aware of what the specialties make. That's why nobody goes into geriatrics. There is a massive range of salaries within the medical profession as any doctor will tell you. There is also a massive range of "quality of life" that goes with that. And there isn't necessarily a direct relationship between those two.

One doctor told me that an HMO takes about 35% of the premiums collected as overhead, using the remaining 65% to pay for care... So you could probably get at least that much of a discount if you paid the doctor directly... But in a market system, it would be supply and demand - if there were not enough doctors, they would raise their prices, and then more people would become doctors... And the reverse also... the market self regulates...

Employer health care is not free

A lot of people are going to find that out soon if Congress decides to tax ESI.

MsAnnaNOLA (profile) wrote (in reply to...) on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 12:08 pm

I know some personally who want to make money which I think negatively affects patient care and costs. I wish I didn't have first hand knowledge of this.

I guess there are only so many saints MsAnnaNOLA. Imagine people wanting to make money. . . in a capitalist system! Wink

@Shadow - "Overhead", eh? I realize this is treading dangerously close to socialism but all that "profit" is someone else's inefficiency. Anyone who has ever sat a negotiating table knows the "let's be partners" line is a bunch of BS. They want you to squeeze your profit to a bare minimum so that they can increase their own margin.

"I guess there are only so many saints MsAnnaNOLA. Imagine people wanting to make money. . . in a capitalist system!"

Unfortunately, we live in a country that takes the measure of a man by his skill at making money.

Everybody squawks about the pay prison guards are pulling down, but the beauty of a story most have never heard, is the medical staff's payment scheme, from orderlies to M.D.'s on a 24/7365 basis.

A doctor can make twice as much working on convicts, (no malpractice insurance is needed either) as he or she can serving the hoi ploy. ha!

OT:
From CBS:

The Mexican Navy gave reporters a firsthand look Tuesday at what they described as one of the largest methamphetamine labs ever found in the country, with enough ephedrine to produce more than 40 tons of the drug.

WOW!

"A lot of people are going to find that out soon if Congress decides to tax ESI."

I think health care as part of a benefit package should be taxed at the employer level. Why should many of us pay with after taxed dollars. It makes you more aware of cost.

@HomeGnome

Apmex is very good; easy to do business with, and fast delivery. Although I highly recommend finding a local dealer; the premium over the spot will be way less. I buy from Apmex when I need a large quantity right away.

Bob Dobbs (homepage, profile) wrote on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 12:17 pm

"I guess there are only so many saints MsAnnaNOLA. Imagine people wanting to make money. . . in a capitalist system!"

Unfortunately, we live in a country that takes the measure of a man by his skill at making money.


Unfortunately indeed. If this crisis changes this, then I welcome it with open arms.

" splat (profile) wrote (in reply to...) on Wed, 6/17/2009 - 1:57 pm

"A Fart Tax?""

Damn! I'm in trouble. Guess I'll have to stop eating chili...

[Aghhhhh! Pigged again!]

OT:
My DoublePlusGood Fart Recipe:

a six pack of beer and half a dozen pickled eggs followed by a BBQ sandwich.

comment in response to above...makes healthcare expensive...that is all...

By example we can prove that single payer health care is the "best" approach to health care ... G7 countries that some form of single payer cover all their citizens for less cost and better outcomes ...

Don't forget the rationing and waiting lists. See the UK national healthcare system for examples. Having experienced the British National health system first hand several times and the US healthcare system, don't believe the bullshit about the nationalized system. Think of the DMV running hospitals.

Granted something has to be done about healthcare costs and wide availability but a "Department of Health" isn't the best solution.

  • splat

ok I want to talk about new Federal Reserve powers anyway...healthcare is not going to happen because Obama has not the balls to pull it off...IMHO.

So how are we going to stop the Fed from getting new unchecked powers?

Anyone?

And to you Obama lovers let me recall

" I don't have to pay my Mortgage '
" I don't have to pay my electric bill "
"I won't have to worry about putting gas in my car",

Key word being "worry" not "pay".

ShadowInventory writes;
"I'm waiting for the smart bed that monitors vitals while sleeping, and the smart toilet that does analysis... and both of those items are networked to your medical record..."

Do you really want test results networked to your medical record? That means that insurance companies would have the opportunity and information necessary to cancel your coverage the instant any anomaly was detected.

This is probably a dead thread, but is there any reason that national health insurance not be limited to catastrophic coverage only. With the number of obese Americans ending up with diabetes, heart attacks, high blood pressure and all the rest...shouldn't that be their lookout? If you want to live a short but fat life, keep eating that KFC chicken.
And anything voluntary is on your own dime...I'm thinking fertility treatments, etc.
Otherwise, health insurance will be the same scam as SS "disability" payments.

And a last thought...anyone else catch the VA hospitals disaster with colonoscopies done by undertrained people leading to HIV infections and Hepatitis B and C cases?
If this is what the government offers veterans, I'd rather stand in line in Canada, with cash in hand.

I know this is a pigged thread but....

The way we educate & train doctors is barbaric & archaic. It needs to be restructured and actually, the idea of an apprenticeship is a good one.

As it is now, much material is memorized then forgotten in an 8-year period. Working with actual cases would increase ability to diagnose through experience & intuition.

The debt load of medical students is obscene and leads to the desire to get out of debt any way you can.

"All OTC derivatives markets, including CDS markets, should be subject to comprehensive regulation that addresses relevant public policy objectives"

How about a simple rule that says you can't bet on something you don't own and/or have a direct stake in? And that the bets on any individual asset etc cannot exceed the face value of the asset

Seems that boils down the vast majority of the financial meltdown cause right there ... allowing massive CDS "bets" on assets they ahd nothing to do with ... and faking bets many times the face value of the asset bet on ...

They still don't get it. Writing more meaningless crap regulations is a waste of their, our & mostly the economy's time. Giving people more authority & responsibility over the financial sector without holding them accountable is an exercise in futility.

Bernanke, Geithner & their thousands of subordinates were given authority & responsibility (and paid fat salaries) to prevent a crash of the financial system & they failed miserably. And Obama still hasn't held them accountable. If fact he's added insult to our intelligence by giving these same inept failures authority over fixing the crash they had the authority & responsibility to prevent.

I think accountability is a meaningless concept for Obama. Look at his association with the illustrious Rev. Wright. Does anyone think that Bernanke & Geithner would have given trillions of our dollars to the stupid bankers if they knew they were going to be held accountable for the results?

Either these people are too stupid to see this or they are knowingly doing extreme damage to the long term viability of the country they happen to live in. Like Congress. I'm voting on stupidity.

Login or register to post comments
Syndicate content