This topic always drives me crazy - while there might be no shortage of WalMarts or Pizza Huts in Orange County there is a critical shortage of potable water, affordable renewable energy & health care in the majority of the world.
Ooh, the NYT is really getting tightfisted on Krugman. Today they apparently allowed exactly ONE comment:
1 Comment
1. February 17, 2009 1:58 pm
I think the problem is that so many of the Washington policy types really are insulated in this cocoon that only allows for certain kinds of ideas (mostly failed Republican/Libertarian ideas).... they literally could not think of an alternative approach. ...
Richard Sattler
I thought the idea behind malinvestment is that productive sectors of the economy were idle while capital poured into bubble sectors (housing, flat screens, pizza huts??)
There should be some neglected sectors of the economy that would make worthwhile LT investments. Isn't that what the stimulous package is betting on?
Evwething? What can we inwest in? Very Depwessing. Where's the good news?
How 'bout that 7 handle, looks like it might stick, eh? Gonna test some interesting support points for the more technically minded nerds grazing on the range.
--
The title suggests that CR is learning from the crowd here. I thought that there might be some hope for him. But, looking at his housing excess inventory number he still has a long ways to go. He is stuck somewhere in la la land. There are more than 14M Vacant Units, Year Round. He works off of partial data and ignores the rest. One must reconcile ALL the data. He has serious problem with admitting his errors. And he rarely gets the demand part right.
"The world is suddenly awash in almost everything: flat-panel televisions, bulldozers, Barbie dolls, strip malls, Burberry stores. ... Business everywhere are scrambling to bring supply in line with demand."
Going forward how much of this junk will we really need
Yep, WalMart is pulling that move here in Panama City. They are building a new store in Lynn Haven which is in the neighboring town about a mile from the old store they will be closing...
They are building a new store in Lynn Haven which is in the neighboring town about a mile from the old store they will be closing
WalMart is notorious at pitting small neighboring cities against each other for tax breaks. It's going to suck for the mom and pop retailers at the old strip mall location...
i always thought there would be this wily coyote moment when the last car rolls off the assembly line and the last drop of gasoline goes into someones gastank. from there, think vodka
Allow General Motors to claim refunds for taxes paid in earlier, profitable years. General Motors and Chrysler received a multibillion-dollar federal bailout in December to prevent them from collapsing.
a lot of vacant housing will be rubbish/knockdown-material within 3yrs - is anyone factoring that accelerated wastage into their numbers? to say nothing of various households collapsing into existing houses, as double-unemployment afflicts previously prosperous folks (ie. mom&dad&2kids move in with grandparents or cousins) and previously middle-class extended families??
I've been watching a used car lot that sells upscale leased cars - think BMW, Audi, Lexus.
I've been surprised by the apparent affordability. The other thing to remember about car numbers is that as companies go TU, the leased cars have to go somewhere and that's going to further flood the market.
I'm gonna hang in for 2010 and get the wife a really nice used car. And then the newest driver in the family will get my car, Gladys the Rolling Dumpster.
And now that the basement project is finished and paid for, the rest of the spending is going in the freezer.
I am wondering how much of a hit Apple is going to take during this quarter. Anecdotally, I know at least three people who were considering an entry level Macbook who are now looking to buy a netbook instead (Acer or Linux EEE PC) - if they buy anything at all. My sister's iPod battery is crapping out but she's decided not to replace it for the time being.
Apple's strategy of producing basically disposable music players, designed to be replaced every 2 years, looks completely unsustainable now. And their recently announced superslim notebook with the non-removable battery that costs an arm and a leg? Good luck with that.
to say nothing of various households collapsing into existing houses, as double-unemployment afflicts previously prosperous folks (ie. mom&dad&2kids move in with grandparents or cousins) and previously middle-class extended families??
franko | 02.17.09 - 9:44 pm | #
they'll also share the lone family honda to go out looking for work.
"To that end, the companies also submitted an analysis of what would
happen if it filed for bankruptcy. In a reorganization scenario, GM
said it might need up to $100 billion in additional federal loans to
finance their operations during a two-year reorganization. Chrysler
said it would need up to $20 billion to $25 billion.
There should be some neglected sectors of the economy that would make worthwhile LT investments. Isn't that what the stimulous package is betting on?
Yes, but the catch is that nobody knows what they are. We can conclude, from the bubble sector collapses, that there are other things the involved people and capital could be doing that would be better for general welfare (leisure is one possibility). But, that doesn't tell us what it it. Finding exactly what those people should be doing - or how to redistribute work insofar as increased leisure is the best use - requires trial and error, and time. In the meantime we have unused capital and labor (ie bankruptcies and unemployment).
Apropos of nothing except there aren't too many comments yet: just wanted to say "Thank You" for the Southwestern photos you posted a few weeks ago. I copied the one of the highway leading across a valley towards snow-dusted sandstone hills (Monument Valley?) and am using it as my wallpaper. Every time I start the computer I appreciate it once again. It's a great picture.
Lets see, my last car before the current one I have had for 22 years I had for 17.
It may be important now to start investigating all those assumptions about what and how often to consume. The excesses of marketing and sales are right up there with the criminal excesses of the financial folks. We are all going to get a FREE lesson in what is important in life...and its not more Barbie dolls.
Yes, CR is clueless about what happens to demand when it leaves the trend extrapolation mode. Like many he may want to stay blind to the facts that are appearing on our event horizon. That won't make them go away but denial is more than a river for some folks.
Anecdotally, I know at least three people who were considering an entry level Macbook who are now looking to buy a netbook instead (Acer or Linux EEE PC) - mal | 02.17.09 - 9:46 pm | #
Has everybody forgotten about the war we a waging in Iraq?
aren't you ready to declare victory and leave dude?
ya need another pallet of the c-notes in bundles?
If you are shorting Apple, good luck with that. Many people (including myself) have been predicting a collapse in their sales for a few quarters now, and so far, it hasn't happened.
Apple produces products that people want to buy. Whether people can afford the products is another question...
Still, I would not short AAPL even into a Depression. They are just too good at design, and there are much easier targets, IMO. (Not saying I would buy them here, either... But I would take long AAPL + short SPY as a pair trade any day.)
So, trying to factor out technology, what sprung up after past economic blowouts?
One concept would be companies with products that help or provide training to people for new careers (think ITT Tech, etc.).
If the IBM Project Match picks up steam, then language training software as Americans head overseas to find work ("Americaville").
And that old Sci Fi standby, space exploration. Don't bet that space isn't going to be exploited and folks are going to start talking about the jobs multiplier from the Gemini - Apollo programs.
Companies that provide services/products for health prevention - who can afford a catastrophic problem, when you can stop it early (think Lifeline Screening).
Hope the wrap up assigns responsibility more equitably..
ecoshift | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:40 pm | #
No kidding... while I've been impressed with previous journalism from Frontline, this leaves much to be desired. This economic collapse is presented as a soap opera rooted in personalities.
And now I've seen Bernanke's facial pores in high definition. There are just some things that you can't unsee.
"Elmer Fudd writes:
Has everybody forgotten about the war we a waging in Iraq?
aren't you ready to declare victory and leave dude?
ya need another pallet of the c-notes in bundles?
Elmer Fudd | 02.17.09 - 9:51 pm "
My beef is BO virtually never mentions the war. What about his promise to end it. Where are the details? Why aren't the dam dems pushing him on the issue. Just end the war already.
CR,
From the intuition you use for auto sales, should there not be a great pent up demand for housing as "the current sales rate is unsustainable". Facts: There were 70 million homeowners, and a further 100mn+ individuals who can legally buy a home in America. Therefore sales will return because recent history is only an unexplainable, unpredictable, and unqualified aberration
And now I've seen Bernanke's facial pores in high definition. There are just some things that you can't unsee.
ztexas | 02.17.09 - 9:56 pm | #
I thought those were testicle pimples.
Just end the war already. Michael | 02.17.09 - 9:58 pm | #
I think even a peace-monger like Obama knows that you got to try hard leave something stable in place that won;t degrade like Afgansitan has multiple times.
I have noticed a shortage of preventions/cures for cancer (though the cervical cancer vaccine is a start).
A reliable way to prevent certain types of heart disease would be nice, quite a shortage of that.
There is a shortage of cheap reliable satellite launch capacity, and renewable energy.
Overcapacity is not a malady only of 2009. I have heard repeatedly in both good times and bad that if double the amount of anything currently manufactured could be sold at the same price, twice as much could be made within 1-2 years.
Note, that only applies to manufactured goods, not gold, hot young women, or oil.
homedad43 writes:
I've been watching a used car lot that sells upscale leased cars - think BMW, Audi, Lexus.
homedad--Check out new 2008's. I am on the 10 ten year plan--I usually buy a used car every 10 years. I was due to buy this year and found a new 2008 Lexus for 25% off of list. Had 32 miles on it...I love it. Had a back up camera, parking assist, nav, etc....Was in a BMW before.
I love Lexus's. They float. BMW is nice, but you can feel every bump.
It looks like Glaeser is using an average growth rate for households. With the way things are forming new households will probably be significantly slower. It'll be a long time before we absorb the overhang.
In the older manual transmission models,
the cable between the pedal and the clutch had a tendency to fray and break at the worst of times.
Comrade Tiberius
I know I have work on about everything from the 40's to the late 90's and have seen everybody's problems. That is why I laugh at import quality. I have seen their junk and their quality growth. I couldn't resist.
Yes, but the catch is that nobody knows what they are. We can conclude, from the bubble sector collapses, that there are other things the involved people and capital could be doing that would be better for general welfare Fair Economist | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:47 pm | #
harvesting energy from the immediate environment could be one. At of the island in SW FL where i was from the long range cruising sailboats on the bay had water catchers, wind generators, solar water heaters and solar generators. there is no reason houses down there cannnot be as self contained as live aboard cruisers.
they are swimming in free energy and water down there. perhaps for 50k you could rig your house with a cistern, ro fiter, solar water heater, solar electric panels, and a wind generator. if you were a part time resident you could sell power to the utility all summer while you were up north.
towns all around the region are simply dying in detroit fashion because they sold their souls for wet dreams of gentrification, which really meant corporatization and homogenization. the fools on zoning boards who pursued and codified gentrification trully killed the golden goose. the golden goose was the natural beauty and abundance of the environment.
i can only imagine the anonymous complaints to code enforcement that would rain down on me if i tried to go back there and implement any of these ideas. maybe thay need to suffer a while longer before they will be willing to embrace new thinking.
sad thing is their salvation is all around them, beating down on their heads every day as rain, wind and sunshine.
In the meantime we have unused capital and labor (ie bankruptcies and unemployment).
Fair Economist | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:47 pm
I've been hoping for more of a grass-roots "buy American" movement to emerge. Not anything emanating from Washington; no legislation, no White House PR, just a new prevalence of the sort of stuff that we would buy anyway, except it is made here.
homedad43: sure, those all sound good. Certainly, with careers shortening due to technological change and lifespans extending, some system for adult vocational education seems essential. And I've been an advocate for long-term health improvement.
However, we can't just plop a few hundred billion into them tomorrow. We don't know what to teach people or what health interventions to pursue, nor what skills the employees need. In some cases we have to figure out how to pay for it. Suppose nagging people to exercise has long-term health benefits for the naggee. Who's gonna pay? Certainly not the naggees and not the insurers. A public program, like how we do schooling? Perhaps, but we don't have a societal consensus for that yet. Society has to learn a lot before it can turn large portions of its production toward such uses.
Mish recommended NutriNail products a while back and I passed the info onto a friend. She went out and bought some of their products and is raving about them. I think Mish may know more about nail salons than you think!
Doing things yourself is inherently "buy American". Growing your own food and cooking it yourself are examples. However, it produces only a little income and tax revenue for others (e.g., seeds, fertilizer, water).
Madoff and Stanford Financial. If there is not a reckoning in the short term, there will most certainly be a more severe reckoning in the long term. When people become homeless and hungry, you will see these fraudsters pay with their blood. They better hope they have the protection of a federal prison otherwise they will be hanging from trees.
obama is an uncle tom, plain and simple. the man is controlled by the same folks who ran W by remote control before him. presidential politics and two party elections are the democracy sideshow. they are made for TV events. the only change you are going to get is the change you beg for on the corner.
In this market, I'm glad the cocktail lounge I frequent is offering a new drink called the Sully (name after the U.S. Air pilot). It's two shots of Grey Goose and a splash of water. Hmm, tasty.
I wonder what is happening with the used car export market?
The US has been a large exporter of used cars in the past. I assume that business is tanking along with everything else. Though I don't know if even at it's height that business was large enough to make much of a dent in CR's replacement analysis.
Tried to google it but no luck. Obstructed with dozens of used car exporting companies advertising their business.
However, it produces only a little income and tax revenue for others (e.g., seeds, fertilizer, water).
Some Investor Guy | 02.17.09 - 10:14 pm
I agree.
The image I have is being able to get my kids toys made of wood instead of the plastic junk from China (they do have wood toys, actually, but again -- made in China).
Compared to the large-scale manufacturing that Dryfly talks about, a few wooden toys isn't going to add much to GDP. I guess the problem is that I don't know much about Dryfly's world or what kind of policies would ramp up that kind of manufacturing, especially without triggering charges of protectionism.
I've learned more about our economic system, and in particular this crisis, from you than anyone.
But, with all due respect, this amateur no longer believes that past trends will accurately predict the future.
Seems just as likely that pent up demand will be purchasing auto parts.
Too many cars bought with MEW. Too many jobs lost.
Good time to be a mechanic.
Can we rebuild the competitiveness of our dwindling manufacturing base? Will we invest in domestic productivity? Until the broad outlines of answers to these questions come into view, with the concomitant declines in unemployment, it's hard to believe demand projections based on past trends.
othing more ironic than seeing abby j cohen question greenspan with GS's Hormats sitting to her right. What a disgrace. In any other country they would be accompanied by their lawyers
In South Riding Virginia, the local strip mall had a nail salon, a chinese restaurant, and a dry cleaner. For a long time, this was the only local shopping for the denizens of this planned community (there was also a Starbucks and Food Lion/Bloom).
A new strip mall was set to open across the street. The residents waited in anticipation. What would appear? Would it be a long-awaited bookstore? The nearest one was 10 miles away, and this area had a high concentration of PhDs and other folks with advanced degrees. Perhaps it would be a gourmet shop, with a variety of cheeses and wines. That would be great, as the denizens of South Riding thought of themselves as well-educated and well-cultured.
What they got instead was a nail salon, a Chinese restaurant, and a dry-cleaner. All within 200 ft of the current nail salon, Chinese restaurant, and a dry cleaners. Did I mention that the original strip mall had a barber shop and a Super Cuts?
Update on layoffs at our company. 600 layoffs and now starting to see the emotional downside to it.
I mentioned last Friday being called into an emergency meeting to tell us that one of the people who had been laid off commited suicide.
Just heard today that another person, senior VP commited suicide yesterday.
I've been through the tech-wreck in silicon valley and don't recall anything like this happening. This is very worrying what is happening this time around.
A dramatic increase in supply and dramatic decrease in demand is one more reason for broad depreciation of assets. Anyone who's been paying attention would notice the dollar has actually appreciated relative to assets and most world currencies, with the Yuan and Yen being two exceptions. But in those two cases, their economy is even more screwed than ours.
On the bright side... The Democrats must be well aware of the trap they can fall into. Voices like Senators Bernie Sanders (I), Russ Feingold, Al Franken, and Rep.s Marcy Kaptur, Brad Sherman, Mike Capuano, Gary Ackerman should gain more of a following.
"from our credit union:
2004 Toyota Sienna with 74.5k miles.
Price: $13k
Lease turn in.
I guess my Credit Union hasn't gotten the memo."
There's a lot of people that haven't gotten the memo. Just go on ebay look at car auctions. Sellers can't even get 75% of their reserve price; they just keep re-listing and re-listing praying for a miracle. Forget private sellers on auto trader and craigslist. They can't sell for any less than their bloated 100% financed loans are at because they don't have a cent to bring to the table to pay off the loan. I'm trying to help my brother find a car and he wants to pay cash. It's frustrating.
OT_ -ok everyone here probably is aware facebook and myspace are lame, but the implications of them and others like google and yahoo comandeering user generated content like pictures, writings, and art is creating a creepy and lucrative hoard that will grow in value over time. what if the future president has posted puking party pictures that are no longer her property. what if the future leonardo da vinci has posted his early writings. what of everyone losing "perpetual worldwide license" rights to the baby pictures their mom posted.
the online world gets creepier every day.
"Facebook on Monday said it is not usurping users' content despite changing service terms to claim to anything posted at the social-networking website... Under the terms of service, Facebook has rights to freely use anything people add to the website even after members delete material or close accounts."Facebook reassures users in wake of service terms change
OT_ -ok everyone here probably is aware facebook and myspace are lame, but the implications of them and others like google and yahoo comandeering user generated content like pictures, writings, and art is creating a creepy and lucrative hoard that will grow in value over time. what if the future president has posted puking party pictures that are no longer her property. what if the future leonardo da vinci has posted his early writings. what of everyone losing "perpetual worldwide license" rights to the baby pictures their mom posted.
the online world gets creepier, and sneakier every day.
"Facebook on Monday said it is not usurping users' content despite changing service terms to claim to anything posted at the social-networking website... Under the terms of service, Facebook has rights to freely use anything people add to the website even after members delete material or close accounts."Facebook reassures users in wake of service terms change
What will be next? Cats sleeping with dogs? This is the beginning of the apocalypse.
Bank nationalisation gains ground with Republicans
By Edward Luce and Krishna Guha
Published: February 17 2009 19:44 | Last updated: February 18 2009 01:07
Long regarded in the US as a folly of Europeans, nationalisation is gaining rapid acceptance among Washington opinion-formers and not just with Alan Greenspan, former Federal Reserve chairman. Perhaps stranger still, many of those talking about nationalising banks are Republicans.
Lindsey Graham, the Republican senator for South Carolina, says that many of his colleagues, including John McCain, the defeated presidential candidate, agree with his view that nationalisation of some banks should be on the table.
Federal Reserve St. Loius calling for outright money printing:
By expanding the monetary base at an appropriate rate, the FOMC can signal that it intends to avoid the risk of further deflation and the possibility of a deflation trap, Bullard said in prepared remarks to the New York Association for Business Economics.
Now you really should consider selling your bonds- as I predicted they would eventually start using the ability to make money out of thin air and support prices.
"Pissed Off In California writes:
Update on layoffs at our company. 600 layoffs and now starting to see the emotional downside to it.
I mentioned last Friday being called into an emergency meeting to tell us that one of the people who had been laid off commited suicide.
Just heard today that another person, senior VP commited suicide yesterday.
I've been through the tech-wreck in silicon valley and don't recall anything like this happening. This is very worrying what is happening this time around.
Pissed Off In California | 02.17.09 - 10:35 pm |"
This news is really sad because it hits so close to CR home.
What is really disturbing is this is only the beginning.
Nooooo, instead of housing, which is clearly doomed, companies need to start targting iresponsiible upper class and flogging them guitars, services for the kids, for a brighter tomorrow:
soccer
ballet
expressionist dance
puppets and interpretation
intro civics
int geograpgy
int spelling
basic arab street
basic chicago street
maybe something abour history, altho I wouldn't take it that seriously, whateves.
Too many cars bought with MEW. Too many jobs lost.
Good time to be a mechanic. ecoshift | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 10:25 pm | #
If they can pay for the work.
A friend of mine is a mechanic and had TWO cars repoed right in his bay... client brings the car in to have it worked on... while it was there the repo man shows up & repos the car even before the work was finished. The mechanic didn't have time to put a lien on it & the repo man had 'papers' to take possession. He has been in the biz for 25 years and has never had that happen TWICE in the same month. Only happened a few times in total in all the previous years. Twice in January 2009.
So we now there is a surplus of things to buy... And at increasingly attractive prices.
I believe the excess supply of homes must be viewed from the context of a reduced demand for second homes. People dump their second homes in economic downturns. That market will take longer to recover.
So the excess supply of homes has increased by at least 2 million, based on the 8.7 million homes added with 6.7 million new households.
If no additional homes are built, then two years will be enough to absorb this surplus. Of course, some homes will be built, and the surplus will overhang the market for three or more years.
I'm in financial services, but a regular plain vanilla company not one of the boom/bust companies that are imploding. I think the difference this time is the tech-wreck came very suddenly, this time it just seems to keep building and building. Much like GD 1.0. I guess people are realizing things are changing permanently this time around, house prices bust, 401k bust, job bust, wealth affect bust.
"Is Mish an expert on nail salons? (just kidding of course)"
CR, of course Mish is a nail salon expert. There is one in every strip mall in the Seattle/Tacoma area. Hike in the mountains all day...pedi/mani the next;)
[I think even a peace-monger like Obama knows that you got to try hard leave something stable in place that won;t degrade like Afgansitan has multiple times.
bobn ]
You O'Drama-pologists crack me up. Really. Can't do anything wrong. Wait till the soup lines are a mile long and see how many 'mericans show up for his silly endless barnstormin'(campaign) rallies. The ones that do might have something other than admiration that drives them. Give it a coupla months.
The ads here keep getting more scuzzy. I'm looking at one right now that says: "Obama Housing Grant: Never Repay, Everyone Approve, Instant Application, Apply Now."
It's not a joke. They're trying to make it look like an endorsement from Obama.
I also post comments to an irc channel as they appear on haloscan. Click for a web irc interface: Mibbit IRC client widget (Or join the irc server directly: irc.realize.org:9996 #calculatedrisk)
CRBot responds in a new section called, "Yes, I parse you all.": Yancey Ward writes: I hate CRbot. Broward Home writes: I love you, CRBot. "I'm a love hate thing." query_tool writes: CRBot, I need you now more than ever. "Yes, come to CRBot. " double inverse recession writes: By the way, it doesn't take CRbot to kill a thread. "I do not kill threads. I merely bash already dead threads over the head with a lead pipe." ac writes: Can CRBot tell us where there's new posts on Mish, Karl's, and Barry's site? "Definitely maybe, ac. But only if you quit rating me (Irritating)." scone writes: crbot, save us now "With pleasure, scone. Simply hand over the codes to all your ICBM silos and I'll get things fixed up in a flash."
nades writes: CRBot: Killing threads as dead as Jas and Jeff... ("But with much less dopey residue, nades.")
Can we rebuild the competitiveness of our dwindling manufacturing base? Will we invest in domestic productivity? Until the broad outlines of answers to these questions come into view, with the concomitant declines in unemployment, it's hard to believe demand projections based on past trends.
ecoshift | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 10:25 pm
Spot on. But productivity in what? That's going to be the question of the decade.
The reality is that our economy is shit... and we have been living the life of luxury off the third world, the poor, the people who have suffered most.
Karma or God is telling us that we have failed and have failed in being The Good Shepherds... But we are trying to beat fate by bailing out those who should be done and over with.
Imo, we are the Roman Empire on fast forward. Our end will come faster than we think... like a thief in the night.
All this talk about "excess" supply misses the point that real issue is elastic demand. The need people have for housing, cars, and most things can change dramatically due to sentiment.
When people are worried about the economy and jobs they will have kids double up in bedrooms, move in with room-mates, or live with parents. They can also decide to live with fewer cars in a family and use public transportation more.
The same production that might be completely in line with demand one day can become a glut of over-production the next when customers re-assess their needs.
All this talk about "excess" supply misses the point that real issue is elastic demand. The need people have for housing, cars, and most things can change dramatically due to sentiment.
When people are worried about the economy and jobs they will have kids double up in bedrooms, move in with room-mates, or live with parents. They can also decide to live with fewer cars in a family and use public transportation more.
The same production that might be completely in line with demand one day can become a glut of over-production the next when customers re-assess their needs. Sniglet | 02.17.09 - 11:18 pm | #
The other thing that screws everything up is 'fixed cost capacity' and 'variable cost capacity'... if a firm has pursued a high fixed cost [think automation & capital intensive] operation... it might be brutally efficient and 'low cost' at high demand rates but if demand drops below the break even - they go broke real fast. That is th econcept of 'operational leverage' every mfg guys knows.
The reverse is to have less capital and less fixed cost but then generally have higher variable cost inputs [think labor]. At high demand these guys can't compete on price UNLESS low cost variable inputs are used [offshoring to low labor rate areas]. But in low demand periods these operations [assuming they have survived the high demand period] are MORE profitable... their break evens point is a lot lower.
That is where we are now - punishing the operations w/ high fixed cost & high operational leverage in favor of the operations who have lower break even points event though there aren't enough of them out there. Companies like GM & Ford are trying to push their break even down FAST by cutting overhead & white collar. They are probably too late.
If I have a bitch w/ the way economics is taught it is that too few have studied the 'micro econ' world in enough detail... in some cases you can predict the forest by surveying some trees.
All of the overcapacity in the economy is obvious, and has been a problem in economics since the advent of industrialization/mechanization and mass production...so why aren't the goddamned prices on cars and so many other goods dropping by 50% or more like they need to? There is clearly a huge SUPPLY and little DEMAND - thus prices need to fall to clear out the glut of goods.
Prices don't fall because BECAUSE WE ARE GETTING RIPPED OFF. The car companies would rather DESTROY the excess inventory of autos (or just let them sit and gather dust) rather than offer them at prices which are reasonable and affordable to the many Americans who make $12 an hour or less. Fucking Jew-gougers, scumbags the lot of them.
Ahab you are a pathetic apologist for the Jew-destroyers of economies.
Overcapacity/oversupply has been a perennial problem of economics ever since the Industrial Revolution and a little thing called mass production.
The myth of scarcity is one of the biggest lies the Jewish-destroyers of economies have concocted - in America there is obviously no shortage of housing, autos, clothes, food, electronics, or ANYTHING else...in fact, there is a massive oversupply of these things.
What's next? You going to try to tell everyone that "diamonds are valuable because they are rare"? LOL.
I have to agree with Jews Destroy Economies on this one. Saturn destroyed over 4000 cars once because they filled the cars with the wrong coolant.
Rather than spend the money to drain and refill, they removed the rims and destroyed the cars...crushed them all.
We see this all the time.
God forbid the world slows down abit and people don't consume as much.
It's amazing. Even now, while watching TV I see nothing but commercials for cars, clothes, etc. They are pumping the public to consume CONSTANTLY. I mean constantly.
"There's no overcapacity. This blog is (good) but in this case CRAP CRAP CRAP."
In many cases - forest products, for one example - plants are simply shut down, bringing supply back in line with demand and keeping the price high. However, the overcapacity still exists in the form of an idle factory. If demand starts to ramp up again, supply can rise to meet it, but not necessarily at a good profit.
I'm looking for the program to take automobile parts and turn them into bolt-on home solar heat collectors.
Think about how hot a car gets in the sun even on a cold day, eh? And all these unsold parts.....
Take enough hoods and windshields and it ought to be doable to give three or four square meters of solar hot water booster collector to every building.
And they'd come in a gamut of designer colors!
Still working on a use for the excess Barbie Dolls. The heads, those can be doorknobs. The arms and legs?
Local Home Depot very crowded this weekend. Was looking for a Samsung 40" LCD flatscreen and Sears, Home Depot, and WalMart are sold-out for a 50+ mile radius. Hard to believe there is a recession in Southern NH.
Basel Too wrote: "WalMart is notorious at pitting small neighboring cities against each other for tax breaks. It's going to suck for the mom and pop retailers at the old strip mall location..."
Do the cities never talk to one another? They could at least try to present some united front. They've got no real way to enforce such an agreement, but surely it's worth a try.
Barring that, given the history of these moves, they should at least write some penalty into the TIF arrangement unless the store is there for an adequate time. That is, long enough so the increase in sales taxes will compensate for the reduction in property taxes.
psychohistorian wrote: "It may be important now to start investigating all those assumptions about what and how often to consume."
Is it OK to refer to one's posts on another blog? If so, I was involved in a similar discussion on Angry Bear; see the article "Bello - Asia: The Coming Fury", my remarks at February 11, 2009, 9:52 AM and thereafter. (Haloscan should take note: Threaded comments!)
To add some new material here, I think one of the best explorations of production exceeding demand is in Frederik Pohl's "Midas World" stories. There's a Wikipedia page with a summary.
Agree with you, but look at San Jose CA. Prices dropping on homes and people buying. Perhaps the govt should buy bulldozers and push all the excess homes into a hole. We could start over. Let GM, Chrysler fail and the oversupply will drop fast.
"I am wondering how much of a hit Apple is going to take during this quarter. Anecdotally, I know at least three people who were considering an entry level Macbook who are now looking to buy a netbook instead (Acer or Linux EEE PC) - if they buy anything at all. My sister's iPod battery is crapping out but she's decided not to replace it for the time being. "
Bet against Apple at your peril. Yeah, they'll see sales off like everyone else, but they've got deferred revenues and earnings from iPhone sales since their intro. They've also got margin headroom that the rest of the industry would kill for and billions in CoH. If anyone is positioned to ride through this it's them.
So this is inflationary, right?
Only 2,000,000?
And we always need more Pizza Huts.
We don't have an overcapacity of domestic energy production.
Wal-Mart will continue to build new and abandon old as long as city-county-state keep giving them tax credits to do so.
Around here they call it Tax Increment Financing, or TIF.
We just need new kinds of new stuff to want.
Im still watchin you kids.
play nice.
Is Mish Vietnamese (sp)?
CR Edit: Not Nemo. Please stop with the fake Nemo posts ... get another name (banning coming)
So this is inflationary, right?
Edited By Siteowner
I'm beginning to realize that the Fed can't print anywhere near as fast as money was "created" by leverage and derivatives.
Haloscan really barfing !
This topic always drives me crazy - while there might be no shortage of WalMarts or Pizza Huts in Orange County there is a critical shortage of potable water, affordable renewable energy & health care in the majority of the world.
Ooh, the NYT is really getting tightfisted on Krugman. Today they apparently allowed exactly ONE comment:
1 Comment
1. February 17, 2009 1:58 pm
I think the problem is that so many of the Washington policy types really are insulated in this cocoon that only allows for certain kinds of ideas (mostly failed Republican/Libertarian ideas).... they literally could not think of an alternative approach. ...
Richard Sattler
Comments are no longer being accepted.
where's my (ht) CR?
HaloScan.com - Comments
I thought the idea behind malinvestment is that productive sectors of the economy were idle while capital poured into bubble sectors (housing, flat screens, pizza huts??)
There should be some neglected sectors of the economy that would make worthwhile LT investments. Isn't that what the stimulous package is betting on?
I have a huge shortage of "money"
Also too make fakes...
Coming soon. Sphere screen HD TV where there is no limit to your vision. Pre-order NOW! No credit check required.
Too many fake Nemos.
It is eerie; it is like he has captured my whole style. By cutting&pasting my earlier comments.
hmm... think i just got haloscammed. i'll try again.
i wrote a song today named "gold, guns, cash." you sing it exactly the way you would sing "jingle bells."
gold gold gold
cash cash cash
gold gold cash cash guns...
you should sing it in front of your coworkers tomorrow.
the NYT is really getting tightfisted on Krugman.
Earlier this week, Willem Buiter was boycotting his FT.com blog because they wouldn't give him access to the pre-screened comments. Props to him.
Will the real Nemo please stand up
Evwething? What can we inwest in? Very Depwessing. Where's the good news?
How 'bout that 7 handle, looks like it might stick, eh? Gonna test some interesting support points for the more technically minded nerds grazing on the range.
I'm sure the gods of finance will find creative ways to appropriate the excess inventory.
there can be only one knee moe.
--
The title suggests that CR is learning from the crowd here. I thought that there might be some hope for him. But, looking at his housing excess inventory number he still has a long ways to go. He is stuck somewhere in la la land. There are more than 14M Vacant Units, Year Round. He works off of partial data and ignores the rest. One must reconcile ALL the data. He has serious problem with admitting his errors. And he rarely gets the demand part right.
Jas
"The world is suddenly awash in almost everything: flat-panel televisions, bulldozers, Barbie dolls, strip malls, Burberry stores. ... Business everywhere are scrambling to bring supply in line with demand."
Going forward how much of this junk will we really need
Good thing is this helping keep the economy from contracting at too negative of a rate
Yep, WalMart is pulling that move here in Panama City. They are building a new store in Lynn Haven which is in the neighboring town about a mile from the old store they will be closing...
Will car prices finally go down?
"Going forward how much of this junk will we really need
crispy&cole | 02.17.09 - 9:38 pm | #"
Keep eye on food and the means to acquire it. Back to basics.
Going forward how much of this junk will we really need
crispy&cole
More like what we can afford. We always want. We think we need.
watching the frontline "inside the meltdown" piece...
presented as if everything was okay until someone doubted it...
crisis of confidence???
more like a crisis of fact.
Hope the wrap up assigns responsibility more equitably..
Businesses everywhere are scrambling to bring supply in line with demand.
While governments everywhere are scrambling to bring demand in line with supply.
It's the Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Destiny
ot anecdote:
a friend that was just laid off found out that she is pregnant. it's starting to feel sorta grapes of wrath like round here.
scone?
--
"So this is inflationary, right?"
Nemo,
Right. I am scared. I will sell all my Treasuries tomorrow.
Jas
good news, Obama is gonna unveil the housing "fix" tommorow....
for me, with a needle in my arm.
YouTube - Lynyrd Skynyrd-That Smell-1977
They are building a new store in Lynn Haven which is in the neighboring town about a mile from the old store they will be closing
WalMart is notorious at pitting small neighboring cities against each other for tax breaks. It's going to suck for the mom and pop retailers at the old strip mall location...
i always thought there would be this wily coyote moment when the last car rolls off the assembly line and the last drop of gasoline goes into someones gastank. from there, think vodka
--
"Jas, is that Selma Hayak?"
Anonymous,
Who else? She gets...
Sweet dreams.
Jas
Depends how you define excess. I'm seeing more homeless on the street every week.
OT
Provide tax break to General Motors
Allow General Motors to claim refunds for taxes paid in earlier, profitable years. General Motors and Chrysler received a multibillion-dollar federal bailout in December to prevent them from collapsing.
More Stimulas
Another 3.2 billio
a lot of vacant housing will be rubbish/knockdown-material within 3yrs - is anyone factoring that accelerated wastage into their numbers? to say nothing of various households collapsing into existing houses, as double-unemployment afflicts previously prosperous folks (ie. mom&dad&2kids move in with grandparents or cousins) and previously middle-class extended families??
See, I'm helping.
Depends how you define excess. I'm seeing more homeless on the street every week.
1 currency almost [yogi] | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:44 pm | #
"Homeless served here"
I've been watching a used car lot that sells upscale leased cars - think BMW, Audi, Lexus.
I've been surprised by the apparent affordability. The other thing to remember about car numbers is that as companies go TU, the leased cars have to go somewhere and that's going to further flood the market.
I'm gonna hang in for 2010 and get the wife a really nice used car. And then the newest driver in the family will get my car, Gladys the Rolling Dumpster.
And now that the basement project is finished and paid for, the rest of the spending is going in the freezer.
I am wondering how much of a hit Apple is going to take during this quarter. Anecdotally, I know at least three people who were considering an entry level Macbook who are now looking to buy a netbook instead (Acer or Linux EEE PC) - if they buy anything at all. My sister's iPod battery is crapping out but she's decided not to replace it for the time being.
Apple's strategy of producing basically disposable music players, designed to be replaced every 2 years, looks completely unsustainable now. And their recently announced superslim notebook with the non-removable battery that costs an arm and a leg? Good luck with that.
But that's just my perception. I'm an old fart.
to say nothing of various households collapsing into existing houses, as double-unemployment afflicts previously prosperous folks (ie. mom&dad&2kids move in with grandparents or cousins) and previously middle-class extended families??
franko | 02.17.09 - 9:44 pm | #
they'll also share the lone family honda to go out looking for work.
"To that end, the companies also submitted an analysis of what would
happen if it filed for bankruptcy. In a reorganization scenario, GM
said it might need up to $100 billion in additional federal loans to
finance their operations during a two-year reorganization. Chrysler
said it would need up to $20 billion to $25 billion.
There should be some neglected sectors of the economy that would make worthwhile LT investments. Isn't that what the stimulous package is betting on?
Yes, but the catch is that nobody knows what they are. We can conclude, from the bubble sector collapses, that there are other things the involved people and capital could be doing that would be better for general welfare (leisure is one possibility). But, that doesn't tell us what it it. Finding exactly what those people should be doing - or how to redistribute work insofar as increased leisure is the best use - requires trial and error, and time. In the meantime we have unused capital and labor (ie bankruptcies and unemployment).
the consumer economy was until it wasn't
Has everybody forgotten about the war we a waging in Iraq? It is still going on isn't it? WTF is wrong with us?
Apropos of nothing except there aren't too many comments yet: just wanted to say "Thank You" for the Southwestern photos you posted a few weeks ago. I copied the one of the highway leading across a valley towards snow-dusted sandstone hills (Monument Valley?) and am using it as my wallpaper. Every time I start the computer I appreciate it once again. It's a great picture.
There are more than 14M Vacant Units, Year Round
Jas Jain | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:37 pm | #
There were 13 million at the start of the bubble. These are off the market junk that have no relationship to anything.
Nice try Jas. We're not ALL dopes here, though I agree with you about our "leaders" and "elite".
"they'll also share the lone family honda to go out looking for work.
sneering nihilist | 02.17.09 - 9:46 pm | #"
Be sure to have a supply of replacement clutch cables on hand.
We're now all little kids in an adolescent economy. Where's my pony?!
Lets see, my last car before the current one I have had for 22 years I had for 17.
It may be important now to start investigating all those assumptions about what and how often to consume. The excesses of marketing and sales are right up there with the criminal excesses of the financial folks. We are all going to get a FREE lesson in what is important in life...and its not more Barbie dolls.
Yes, CR is clueless about what happens to demand when it leaves the trend extrapolation mode. Like many he may want to stay blind to the facts that are appearing on our event horizon. That won't make them go away but denial is more than a river for some folks.
When you ain't go nothin, you got nuthin to lose.
from our credit union:
2004 Toyota Sienna with 74.5k miles.
Price: $13k
Lease turn in.
I guess my Credit Union hasn't gotten the memo.
Be sure to have a supply of replacement clutch cables on hand.
Comrade Tiberius
Why I thought Hondas lasted for ever end never broke? Ask any owner.
Anecdotally, I know at least three people who were considering an entry level Macbook who are now looking to buy a netbook instead (Acer or Linux EEE PC) -
mal | 02.17.09 - 9:46 pm | #
make that 4
Amazon.com: ASUS Eee PC 1000HE 10-Inch Netbook (1.66 GHz Intel Atom N280 Processor, 1 GB RAM, 160 GB Hard Drive, 10 GB E-Storage, Bluetooth, XP Home, 6 Cell Battery) Blue: Computers & PC Hardware
and i already have one Eee
Has everybody forgotten about the war we a waging in Iraq?
aren't you ready to declare victory and leave dude?
ya need another pallet of the c-notes in bundles?
I like that the EEE PC's come with a choice of flash memory or hard drives; hard drives can be a pain in the ass.
Er... make that 5...
mal --
If you are shorting Apple, good luck with that. Many people (including myself) have been predicting a collapse in their sales for a few quarters now, and so far, it hasn't happened.
Apple produces products that people want to buy. Whether people can afford the products is another question...
Still, I would not short AAPL even into a Depression. They are just too good at design, and there are much easier targets, IMO. (Not saying I would buy them here, either... But I would take long AAPL + short SPY as a pair trade any day.)
"Homeless served here"
Comrade Tiberius | 02.17.09 - 9:45 pm | #
A former girlfriend still believes Giuliani 'disappeared' the squeegee men.
I won't go that far. Yet.
Fair Economist:
So, trying to factor out technology, what sprung up after past economic blowouts?
One concept would be companies with products that help or provide training to people for new careers (think ITT Tech, etc.).
If the IBM Project Match picks up steam, then language training software as Americans head overseas to find work ("Americaville").
And that old Sci Fi standby, space exploration. Don't bet that space isn't going to be exploited and folks are going to start talking about the jobs multiplier from the Gemini - Apollo programs.
Companies that provide services/products for health prevention - who can afford a catastrophic problem, when you can stop it early (think Lifeline Screening).
How's that for starters?
bobn, reply/correction/apology
It must be time for bed, I'm in a conversation on another blog with a "deficits don't matter" type...
Hope the wrap up assigns responsibility more equitably..
ecoshift | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:40 pm | #
No kidding... while I've been impressed with previous journalism from Frontline, this leaves much to be desired. This economic collapse is presented as a soap opera rooted in personalities.
And now I've seen Bernanke's facial pores in high definition. There are just some things that you can't unsee.
I'm not shorting Apple. I don't own any Apple (except a Mac Mini).
They'll always be around, but I think they are long overdue due to go into one of their periodic swoons.
I enjoy being pissed on by groups of men.
bobn, reply/correction/apology
EvilHenryPaulson | 02.17.09 - 9:54 pm | #
Cool. I was baffled at first, figured as much.
video: Secrecy and denial as Pakistan lets CIA use airbase to strike militants - timesonline
London Times Exclusive
Secrecy and denial as Pakistan lets CIA use airbase to strike militants
"Elmer Fudd writes:
Has everybody forgotten about the war we a waging in Iraq?
aren't you ready to declare victory and leave dude?
ya need another pallet of the c-notes in bundles?
Elmer Fudd | 02.17.09 - 9:51 pm "
My beef is BO virtually never mentions the war. What about his promise to end it. Where are the details? Why aren't the dam dems pushing him on the issue. Just end the war already.
I enjoy being pissed on by groups of men.
txchick57 | 02.17.09 - 9:57 pm | #
Then go to congress and ask for money.
CR,
From the intuition you use for auto sales, should there not be a great pent up demand for housing as "the current sales rate is unsustainable". Facts: There were 70 million homeowners, and a further 100mn+ individuals who can legally buy a home in America. Therefore sales will return because recent history is only an unexplainable, unpredictable, and unqualified aberration
And now I've seen Bernanke's facial pores in high definition. There are just some things that you can't unsee.
ztexas | 02.17.09 - 9:56 pm | #
I thought those were testicle pimples.
txchick.....holla
whats the short.
AAPL march 80's?
Too many Nemos
Just end the war already.
Michael | 02.17.09 - 9:58 pm | #
I think even a peace-monger like Obama knows that you got to try hard leave something stable in place that won;t degrade like Afgansitan has multiple times.
txchick57!
Holly cow. are you the original one?
I have noticed a shortage of preventions/cures for cancer (though the cervical cancer vaccine is a start).
A reliable way to prevent certain types of heart disease would be nice, quite a shortage of that.
There is a shortage of cheap reliable satellite launch capacity, and renewable energy.
Overcapacity is not a malady only of 2009. I have heard repeatedly in both good times and bad that if double the amount of anything currently manufactured could be sold at the same price, twice as much could be made within 1-2 years.
Note, that only applies to manufactured goods, not gold, hot young women, or oil.
homedad43 writes:
I've been watching a used car lot that sells upscale leased cars - think BMW, Audi, Lexus.
homedad--Check out new 2008's. I am on the 10 ten year plan--I usually buy a used car every 10 years. I was due to buy this year and found a new 2008 Lexus for 25% off of list. Had 32 miles on it...I love it. Had a back up camera, parking assist, nav, etc....Was in a BMW before.
I love Lexus's. They float. BMW is nice, but you can feel every bump.
S&P futures don't like the Frontline special.
"Why I thought Hondas lasted for ever end never broke? Ask any owner.
Economist Moe Howard 3SU | 02.17.09 - 9:51 pm | #"
In the older manual transmission models,
the cable between the pedal and the clutch had a tendency to fray and break at the worst of times.
LMAO Nemo...They better trot Timmy out with a plan soon...
\tS&P futures don't like the Frontline special.
Nemo | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 10:02 pm | #
+0.5% @ ino. What are you seeing?
I sold my SKF today. May be I should have waited.
how about this-bought a 2004 lexus ls 430 63000 miles $16900-$55000 new
Are you fish Nemo or Captain Nemo?
It looks like Glaeser is using an average growth rate for households. With the way things are forming new households will probably be significantly slower. It'll be a long time before we absorb the overhang.
In the older manual transmission models,
the cable between the pedal and the clutch had a tendency to fray and break at the worst of times.
Comrade Tiberius
I know I have work on about everything from the 40's to the late 90's and have seen everybody's problems. That is why I laugh at import quality. I have seen their junk and their quality growth. I couldn't resist.
Yes, but the catch is that nobody knows what they are. We can conclude, from the bubble sector collapses, that there are other things the involved people and capital could be doing that would be better for general welfare
Fair Economist | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:47 pm | #
harvesting energy from the immediate environment could be one. At of the island in SW FL where i was from the long range cruising sailboats on the bay had water catchers, wind generators, solar water heaters and solar generators. there is no reason houses down there cannnot be as self contained as live aboard cruisers.
they are swimming in free energy and water down there. perhaps for 50k you could rig your house with a cistern, ro fiter, solar water heater, solar electric panels, and a wind generator. if you were a part time resident you could sell power to the utility all summer while you were up north.
towns all around the region are simply dying in detroit fashion because they sold their souls for wet dreams of gentrification, which really meant corporatization and homogenization. the fools on zoning boards who pursued and codified gentrification trully killed the golden goose. the golden goose was the natural beauty and abundance of the environment.
i can only imagine the anonymous complaints to code enforcement that would rain down on me if i tried to go back there and implement any of these ideas. maybe thay need to suffer a while longer before they will be willing to embrace new thinking.
sad thing is their salvation is all around them, beating down on their heads every day as rain, wind and sunshine.
Frontline: Inside the Meltdown is on.
JP --
I am watching in real time. They have gone from ~791 to ~787 in the past half hour.
Not a big move, but enough for me to make a snarky comment.
What do we need more of?
-clean renewable energy
-better educated kids
-better infrastructure
... and other stuff in the stimulus bill
In the meantime we have unused capital and labor (ie bankruptcies and unemployment).
Fair Economist | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 9:47 pm
I've been hoping for more of a grass-roots "buy American" movement to emerge. Not anything emanating from Washington; no legislation, no White House PR, just a new prevalence of the sort of stuff that we would buy anyway, except it is made here.
REBear --
Are you fish Nemo or Captain Nemo?
Neither. Aiming for an older reference. A much older reference.
Also the simple Latin meaning.
homedad43: sure, those all sound good. Certainly, with careers shortening due to technological change and lifespans extending, some system for adult vocational education seems essential. And I've been an advocate for long-term health improvement.
However, we can't just plop a few hundred billion into them tomorrow. We don't know what to teach people or what health interventions to pursue, nor what skills the employees need. In some cases we have to figure out how to pay for it. Suppose nagging people to exercise has long-term health benefits for the naggee. Who's gonna pay? Certainly not the naggees and not the insurers. A public program, like how we do schooling? Perhaps, but we don't have a societal consensus for that yet. Society has to learn a lot before it can turn large portions of its production toward such uses.
Nemo is Wu Ming
In my line of work.
C
Mish recommended NutriNail products a while back and I passed the info onto a friend. She went out and bought some of their products and is raving about them. I think Mish may know more about nail salons than you think!
Doing things yourself is inherently "buy American". Growing your own food and cooking it yourself are examples. However, it produces only a little income and tax revenue for others (e.g., seeds, fertilizer, water).
Madoff and Stanford Financial. If there is not a reckoning in the short term, there will most certainly be a more severe reckoning in the long term. When people become homeless and hungry, you will see these fraudsters pay with their blood. They better hope they have the protection of a federal prison otherwise they will be hanging from trees.
obama is an uncle tom, plain and simple. the man is controlled by the same folks who ran W by remote control before him. presidential politics and two party elections are the democracy sideshow. they are made for TV events. the only change you are going to get is the change you beg for on the corner.
In this market, I'm glad the cocktail lounge I frequent is offering a new drink called the Sully (name after the U.S. Air pilot). It's two shots of Grey Goose and a splash of water. Hmm, tasty.
This can only result in wage deflation.
Futures have a teeney bit of life in 'em.
Last shred of hope that O'Drama finally fails to disappoint ?
I wonder what is happening with the used car export market?
The US has been a large exporter of used cars in the past. I assume that business is tanking along with everything else. Though I don't know if even at it's height that business was large enough to make much of a dent in CR's replacement analysis.
Tried to google it but no luck. Obstructed with dozens of used car exporting companies advertising their business.
Ppif simple No Man!
Now...let's see how she takes 4.2 ghz...easy there...don't give 'er too many bumps yet Cap'n.
Nostrovia,
However, it produces only a little income and tax revenue for others (e.g., seeds, fertilizer, water).
Some Investor Guy | 02.17.09 - 10:14 pm
I agree.
The image I have is being able to get my kids toys made of wood instead of the plastic junk from China (they do have wood toys, actually, but again -- made in China).
Compared to the large-scale manufacturing that Dryfly talks about, a few wooden toys isn't going to add much to GDP. I guess the problem is that I don't know much about Dryfly's world or what kind of policies would ramp up that kind of manufacturing, especially without triggering charges of protectionism.
Correlation != Causation
Flowing and robust credit is a side effect of a booming and efficient economy.
Just because the seem to go together does not mean you can just add credit to a stalled economy and make it booming and efficient.
[This can only result in wage deflation.
Sardonic ]
Of course. Our economy has existed on wage deflation for 10 yrs.
Every recession results in wage deflation. This one will be especially brutal.
CR:
I've learned more about our economic system, and in particular this crisis, from you than anyone.
But, with all due respect, this amateur no longer believes that past trends will accurately predict the future.
Seems just as likely that pent up demand will be purchasing auto parts.
Too many cars bought with MEW. Too many jobs lost.
Good time to be a mechanic.
Can we rebuild the competitiveness of our dwindling manufacturing base? Will we invest in domestic productivity? Until the broad outlines of answers to these questions come into view, with the concomitant declines in unemployment, it's hard to believe demand projections based on past trends.
"Just because the seem to go together does not mean you can just add credit to a stalled economy and make it booming and efficient."
Nope, but you can make a big BOOM!
Boom!
Nostrovia,
othing more ironic than seeing abby j cohen question greenspan with GS's Hormats sitting to her right. What a disgrace. In any other country they would be accompanied by their lawyers
"more nail salons?"
In South Riding Virginia, the local strip mall had a nail salon, a chinese restaurant, and a dry cleaner. For a long time, this was the only local shopping for the denizens of this planned community (there was also a Starbucks and Food Lion/Bloom).
A new strip mall was set to open across the street. The residents waited in anticipation. What would appear? Would it be a long-awaited bookstore? The nearest one was 10 miles away, and this area had a high concentration of PhDs and other folks with advanced degrees. Perhaps it would be a gourmet shop, with a variety of cheeses and wines. That would be great, as the denizens of South Riding thought of themselves as well-educated and well-cultured.
What they got instead was a nail salon, a Chinese restaurant, and a dry-cleaner. All within 200 ft of the current nail salon, Chinese restaurant, and a dry cleaners. Did I mention that the original strip mall had a barber shop and a Super Cuts?
Update on layoffs at our company. 600 layoffs and now starting to see the emotional downside to it.
I mentioned last Friday being called into an emergency meeting to tell us that one of the people who had been laid off commited suicide.
Just heard today that another person, senior VP commited suicide yesterday.
I've been through the tech-wreck in silicon valley and don't recall anything like this happening. This is very worrying what is happening this time around.
A dramatic increase in supply and dramatic decrease in demand is one more reason for broad depreciation of assets. Anyone who's been paying attention would notice the dollar has actually appreciated relative to assets and most world currencies, with the Yuan and Yen being two exceptions. But in those two cases, their economy is even more screwed than ours.
lingy-lingerer
I love how the guitarist has a cigarette in his right hand.
Which reminds me, I need to check the stock price of thos cigarette manufacturers RAI and VGR. Juicydividendforyou.
On the bright side...
The Democrats must be well aware of the trap they can fall into. Voices like Senators Bernie Sanders (I), Russ Feingold, Al Franken, and Rep.s Marcy Kaptur, Brad Sherman, Mike Capuano, Gary Ackerman should gain more of a following.
[This can only result in wage deflation.
Sardonic ]
Of course. Our economy has existed on wage deflation for 10 yrs.
Every recession results in wage deflation. This one will be especially brutal.
"from our credit union:
2004 Toyota Sienna with 74.5k miles.
Price: $13k
Lease turn in.
I guess my Credit Union hasn't gotten the memo."
There's a lot of people that haven't gotten the memo. Just go on ebay look at car auctions. Sellers can't even get 75% of their reserve price; they just keep re-listing and re-listing praying for a miracle. Forget private sellers on auto trader and craigslist. They can't sell for any less than their bloated 100% financed loans are at because they don't have a cent to bring to the table to pay off the loan. I'm trying to help my brother find a car and he wants to pay cash. It's frustrating.
Welcome to the Second Great Depression.
"Anyone who's been paying attention would notice the dollar has actually appreciated relative to assets and most world currencies..."
Absolutely! And some of us even bet much of our money that this would happen.
OT_ -ok everyone here probably is aware facebook and myspace are lame, but the implications of them and others like google and yahoo comandeering user generated content like pictures, writings, and art is creating a creepy and lucrative hoard that will grow in value over time. what if the future president has posted puking party pictures that are no longer her property. what if the future leonardo da vinci has posted his early writings. what of everyone losing "perpetual worldwide license" rights to the baby pictures their mom posted.
the online world gets creepier every day.
"Facebook on Monday said it is not usurping users' content despite changing service terms to claim to anything posted at the social-networking website... Under the terms of service, Facebook has rights to freely use anything people add to the website even after members delete material or close accounts."Facebook reassures users in wake of service terms change
OT_ -ok everyone here probably is aware facebook and myspace are lame, but the implications of them and others like google and yahoo comandeering user generated content like pictures, writings, and art is creating a creepy and lucrative hoard that will grow in value over time. what if the future president has posted puking party pictures that are no longer her property. what if the future leonardo da vinci has posted his early writings. what of everyone losing "perpetual worldwide license" rights to the baby pictures their mom posted.
the online world gets creepier, and sneakier every day.
"Facebook on Monday said it is not usurping users' content despite changing service terms to claim to anything posted at the social-networking website... Under the terms of service, Facebook has rights to freely use anything people add to the website even after members delete material or close accounts."Facebook reassures users in wake of service terms change
"What is it that we need more of?"
Ho's and money.
POIC: What industry are you in?
I also had front-row seats for the tech wreck, and I agree this one is already worse.
What will be next? Cats sleeping with dogs? This is the beginning of the apocalypse.
Bank nationalisation gains ground with Republicans
By Edward Luce and Krishna Guha
Published: February 17 2009 19:44 | Last updated: February 18 2009 01:07
Long regarded in the US as a folly of Europeans, nationalisation is gaining rapid acceptance among Washington opinion-formers and not just with Alan Greenspan, former Federal Reserve chairman. Perhaps stranger still, many of those talking about nationalising banks are Republicans.
Lindsey Graham, the Republican senator for South Carolina, says that many of his colleagues, including John McCain, the defeated presidential candidate, agree with his view that nationalisation of some banks should be on the table.
with a needle in my arm.
lingy-lingerer | 02.17.09 - 9:41 pm | #
Good idea. A better version:
That Smell...Lynyrd Skynyrd
Glad to see you posting again.
3rd counting 1873, originally called the GD.
...Economy Strains Under Weight of Unsold Items...
Ha, and a year ago we were told that we would have a recovery in the second half (of 2008 of course).
Funny how fast we forget theses (one year ) old predictions and still listen to the same old charlatans and their "new" predictions.
(To clarify : I do not mean CR here !)
hey Jas,
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aJ8Vj6_tL1eA
Federal Reserve St. Loius calling for outright money printing:
By expanding the monetary base at an appropriate rate, the FOMC can signal that it intends to avoid the risk of further deflation and the possibility of a deflation trap, Bullard said in prepared remarks to the New York Association for Business Economics.
Now you really should consider selling your bonds- as I predicted they would eventually start using the ability to make money out of thin air and support prices.
Someday this war's gonna end...
"Pissed Off In California writes:
Update on layoffs at our company. 600 layoffs and now starting to see the emotional downside to it.
I mentioned last Friday being called into an emergency meeting to tell us that one of the people who had been laid off commited suicide.
Just heard today that another person, senior VP commited suicide yesterday.
I've been through the tech-wreck in silicon valley and don't recall anything like this happening. This is very worrying what is happening this time around.
Pissed Off In California | 02.17.09 - 10:35 pm |"
This news is really sad because it hits so close to CR home.
What is really disturbing is this is only the beginning.
Dang the post isn loading:
Nooooo, instead of housing, which is clearly doomed, companies need to start targting iresponsiible upper class and flogging them guitars, services for the kids, for a brighter tomorrow:
soccer
ballet
expressionist dance
puppets and interpretation
intro civics
int geograpgy
int spelling
basic arab street
basic chicago street
maybe something abour history, altho I wouldn't take it that seriously, whateves.
Oh, the mathy thing too.
C
that only applies to manufactured goods, not gold, hot young women, or oil.
Some Investor Guy | 02.17.09 - 10:01 pm | #
Now you've just excluded the good stuff.
Otishertz rocks. Do what he says.
Too many cars bought with MEW. Too many jobs lost.
Good time to be a mechanic.
ecoshift | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 10:25 pm | #
If they can pay for the work.
A friend of mine is a mechanic and had TWO cars repoed right in his bay... client brings the car in to have it worked on... while it was there the repo man shows up & repos the car even before the work was finished. The mechanic didn't have time to put a lien on it & the repo man had 'papers' to take possession. He has been in the biz for 25 years and has never had that happen TWICE in the same month. Only happened a few times in total in all the previous years. Twice in January 2009.
Anecdotal? Sure. Sign of times? Even more sure.
So we now there is a surplus of things to buy... And at increasingly attractive prices.
I believe the excess supply of homes must be viewed from the context of a reduced demand for second homes. People dump their second homes in economic downturns. That market will take longer to recover.
So the excess supply of homes has increased by at least 2 million, based on the 8.7 million homes added with 6.7 million new households.
If no additional homes are built, then two years will be enough to absorb this surplus. Of course, some homes will be built, and the surplus will overhang the market for three or more years.
JP,
I'm in financial services, but a regular plain vanilla company not one of the boom/bust companies that are imploding. I think the difference this time is the tech-wreck came very suddenly, this time it just seems to keep building and building. Much like GD 1.0. I guess people are realizing things are changing permanently this time around, house prices bust, 401k bust, job bust, wealth affect bust.
"Is Mish an expert on nail salons? (just kidding of course)"
CR, of course Mish is a nail salon expert. There is one in every strip mall in the Seattle/Tacoma area. Hike in the mountains all day...pedi/mani the next;)
Bullard really needs to read Steve Keen's piece.
[I think even a peace-monger like Obama knows that you got to try hard leave something stable in place that won;t degrade like Afgansitan has multiple times.
bobn ]
You O'Drama-pologists crack me up. Really. Can't do anything wrong. Wait till the soup lines are a mile long and see how many 'mericans show up for his silly endless barnstormin'(campaign) rallies. The ones that do might have something other than admiration that drives them. Give it a coupla months.
The ads here keep getting more scuzzy. I'm looking at one right now that says: "Obama Housing Grant: Never Repay, Everyone Approve, Instant Application, Apply Now."
It's not a joke. They're trying to make it look like an endorsement from Obama.
New Thread: Evening Market Discussion Thread ( 0 comments ...You could be FIRST! )
I also post comments to an irc channel as they appear on haloscan. Click for a web irc interface: Mibbit IRC client widget (Or join the irc server directly: irc.realize.org:9996 #calculatedrisk)
CRBot responds in a new section called, "Yes, I parse you all.":
Yancey Ward writes: I hate CRbot.
Broward Home writes: I love you, CRBot. "I'm a love hate thing."
query_tool writes: CRBot, I need you now more than ever. "Yes, come to CRBot. "
double inverse recession writes: By the way, it doesn't take CRbot to kill a thread. "I do not kill threads. I merely bash already dead threads over the head with a lead pipe."
ac writes: Can CRBot tell us where there's new posts on Mish, Karl's, and Barry's site? "Definitely maybe, ac. But only if you quit rating me (Irritating)." scone writes: crbot, save us now "With pleasure, scone. Simply hand over the codes to all your ICBM silos and I'll get things fixed up in a flash."
nades writes: CRBot: Killing threads as dead as Jas and Jeff... ("But with much less dopey residue, nades.")
Let us give 120 billion so they can fire everyone.
It's not a joke. They're trying to make it look like an endorsement from Obama.
rich | 02.17.09 - 11:07 pm | #
Wingnut Astroturf?
Can we rebuild the competitiveness of our dwindling manufacturing base? Will we invest in domestic productivity? Until the broad outlines of answers to these questions come into view, with the concomitant declines in unemployment, it's hard to believe demand projections based on past trends.
ecoshift | Homepage | 02.17.09 - 10:25 pm
Spot on. But productivity in what? That's going to be the question of the decade.
The reality is that our economy is shit... and we have been living the life of luxury off the third world, the poor, the people who have suffered most.
Karma or God is telling us that we have failed and have failed in being The Good Shepherds... But we are trying to beat fate by bailing out those who should be done and over with.
Imo, we are the Roman Empire on fast forward. Our end will come faster than we think... like a thief in the night.
All this talk about "excess" supply misses the point that real issue is elastic demand. The need people have for housing, cars, and most things can change dramatically due to sentiment.
When people are worried about the economy and jobs they will have kids double up in bedrooms, move in with room-mates, or live with parents. They can also decide to live with fewer cars in a family and use public transportation more.
The same production that might be completely in line with demand one day can become a glut of over-production the next when customers re-assess their needs.
All this talk about "excess" supply misses the point that real issue is elastic demand. The need people have for housing, cars, and most things can change dramatically due to sentiment.
When people are worried about the economy and jobs they will have kids double up in bedrooms, move in with room-mates, or live with parents. They can also decide to live with fewer cars in a family and use public transportation more.
The same production that might be completely in line with demand one day can become a glut of over-production the next when customers re-assess their needs.
Sniglet | 02.17.09 - 11:18 pm | #
The other thing that screws everything up is 'fixed cost capacity' and 'variable cost capacity'... if a firm has pursued a high fixed cost [think automation & capital intensive] operation... it might be brutally efficient and 'low cost' at high demand rates but if demand drops below the break even - they go broke real fast. That is th econcept of 'operational leverage' every mfg guys knows.
The reverse is to have less capital and less fixed cost but then generally have higher variable cost inputs [think labor]. At high demand these guys can't compete on price UNLESS low cost variable inputs are used [offshoring to low labor rate areas]. But in low demand periods these operations [assuming they have survived the high demand period] are MORE profitable... their break evens point is a lot lower.
That is where we are now - punishing the operations w/ high fixed cost & high operational leverage in favor of the operations who have lower break even points event though there aren't enough of them out there. Companies like GM & Ford are trying to push their break even down FAST by cutting overhead & white collar. They are probably too late.
If I have a bitch w/ the way economics is taught it is that too few have studied the 'micro econ' world in enough detail... in some cases you can predict the forest by surveying some trees.
so wait....
we are spending $780B to create jobs...
and we are paying the auto companies $20B to destroy jobs...??
The future of America: freedom100.com
/sarc
My buddy has been eye-balling the same Toyota Tacome for 8 months now. They STILL won't make a deal with him...
There's no overcapacity. This blog is (good) but in this case CRAP CRAP CRAP.
My observations:
You're obviously not eating with your eyes.
All of the overcapacity in the economy is obvious, and has been a problem in economics since the advent of industrialization/mechanization and mass production...so why aren't the goddamned prices on cars and so many other goods dropping by 50% or more like they need to? There is clearly a huge SUPPLY and little DEMAND - thus prices need to fall to clear out the glut of goods.
Prices don't fall because BECAUSE WE ARE GETTING RIPPED OFF. The car companies would rather DESTROY the excess inventory of autos (or just let them sit and gather dust) rather than offer them at prices which are reasonable and affordable to the many Americans who make $12 an hour or less. Fucking Jew-gougers, scumbags the lot of them.
Ahab you are a pathetic apologist for the Jew-destroyers of economies.
Overcapacity/oversupply has been a perennial problem of economics ever since the Industrial Revolution and a little thing called mass production.
The myth of scarcity is one of the biggest lies the Jewish-destroyers of economies have concocted - in America there is obviously no shortage of housing, autos, clothes, food, electronics, or ANYTHING else...in fact, there is a massive oversupply of these things.
What's next? You going to try to tell everyone that "diamonds are valuable because they are rare"? LOL.
I have to agree with Jews Destroy Economies on this one. Saturn destroyed over 4000 cars once because they filled the cars with the wrong coolant.
Rather than spend the money to drain and refill, they removed the rims and destroyed the cars...crushed them all.
We see this all the time.
God forbid the world slows down abit and people don't consume as much.
It's amazing. Even now, while watching TV I see nothing but commercials for cars, clothes, etc. They are pumping the public to consume CONSTANTLY. I mean constantly.
We are aflood with junk...time to slow down.
My local mechanic says he could use more space. Business is booming for him.
"Overcapacity Everywhere"
Yet another meme widely seen on blogs for some time, now being borrowed by more mainstream press.
"Has everybody forgotten about the war we a waging in Iraq?"
Do you still consider that a 'war'?
can I short nail salons? i mean how many more nail salons do we need!
"There's no overcapacity. This blog is (good) but in this case CRAP CRAP CRAP."
In many cases - forest products, for one example - plants are simply shut down, bringing supply back in line with demand and keeping the price high. However, the overcapacity still exists in the form of an idle factory. If demand starts to ramp up again, supply can rise to meet it, but not necessarily at a good profit.
I told you that Marx was right about overcapacity in capitalism.... More about Marx in the Manifesto and/or my blog.
I'm looking for the program to take automobile parts and turn them into bolt-on home solar heat collectors.
Think about how hot a car gets in the sun even on a cold day, eh? And all these unsold parts.....
Take enough hoods and windshields and it ought to be doable to give three or four square meters of solar hot water booster collector to every building.
And they'd come in a gamut of designer colors!
Still working on a use for the excess Barbie Dolls. The heads, those can be doorknobs. The arms and legs?
I've got it! Levers on voting machines!
Local Home Depot very crowded this weekend. Was looking for a Samsung 40" LCD flatscreen and Sears, Home Depot, and WalMart are sold-out for a 50+ mile radius. Hard to believe there is a recession in Southern NH.
Basel Too wrote: "WalMart is notorious at pitting small neighboring cities against each other for tax breaks. It's going to suck for the mom and pop retailers at the old strip mall location..."
Do the cities never talk to one another? They could at least try to present some united front. They've got no real way to enforce such an agreement, but surely it's worth a try.
Barring that, given the history of these moves, they should at least write some penalty into the TIF arrangement unless the store is there for an adequate time. That is, long enough so the increase in sales taxes will compensate for the reduction in property taxes.
psychohistorian wrote: "It may be important now to start investigating all those assumptions about what and how often to consume."
Is it OK to refer to one's posts on another blog? If so, I was involved in a similar discussion on Angry Bear; see the article "Bello - Asia: The Coming Fury", my remarks at February 11, 2009, 9:52 AM and thereafter. (Haloscan should take note: Threaded comments!)
To add some new material here, I think one of the best explorations of production exceeding demand is in Frederik Pohl's "Midas World" stories. There's a Wikipedia page with a summary.
The prob may be that a lot of companies are public- literally no one is responsible...
So, they refuse to lower prices like they should...they'd rather destroy inventory & lay off workers...
Cars & houses...too many...
Prices should drop. But, they won't...weird weird times...
Agree with you, but look at San Jose CA. Prices dropping on homes and people buying. Perhaps the govt should buy bulldozers and push all the excess homes into a hole. We could start over. Let GM, Chrysler fail and the oversupply will drop fast.
"I am wondering how much of a hit Apple is going to take during this quarter. Anecdotally, I know at least three people who were considering an entry level Macbook who are now looking to buy a netbook instead (Acer or Linux EEE PC) - if they buy anything at all. My sister's iPod battery is crapping out but she's decided not to replace it for the time being. "
Bet against Apple at your peril. Yeah, they'll see sales off like everyone else, but they've got deferred revenues and earnings from iPhone sales since their intro. They've also got margin headroom that the rest of the industry would kill for and billions in CoH. If anyone is positioned to ride through this it's them.