It seems all of the previously relatively strong areas of the economy - consumer spending, investment in non-residential structures, and exports (and manufacturing) - are all in a steep slide.
Very steep slide - even Deere & Co. saying profits next year will be down [maybe a lot].
Great time to be on the sidelines. I think a once in a lifetime buying opportunity for energy stocks will occur in a few months. Coal and nat gas, especially.
It seems there is very little keeping this economy from freefall.. Fed/Treasury will need to pump a lot more money in to at least stabilize any remaining productive sectors. Not sure what those really are in the US economy anymore...
And now all the lights on the big control panel are red. Well, energy's cheaper -- but what does that get you when your engines are dripping coolant and ready to seize up?
Revolutions are an old story to the American Citizen. To the Russian, they are still a new and startling experience; the American knows the tale of revolution almost by heart. His national existence began with one, many of the most illustrious names in his history books are associated with that celebrated rebellion.
...
The country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of existing government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it, or their revolutionary right to dismember and overthrow it.
What is the American with the revolutionary birthright htinking about these days? His own country and the world are now in the midst of a vast economic upheaval. The systems of production and distribution have been badly jammed, and some of the parts will never again be of any use. You and I and the citizen begin to have a feeling that perhaps we shall have to deal with a number of problems that we have never touched before. This word revolution is heard at every hand; we seem to face revolutions of all sorts and kinds. We use what intelligence we have, not as experts of finance but as ordinary citizens, watching the news of the world as our neighbors and the newspapers give it to us.
For the most part, the men who now occupy our seats of government were there at the high tide of the boom. They were in office when the crash came and, barring the fatalilties of the last elections, they are still there. Mr. Hoover is, of course, the most obvious example. In business the same captains of industry, the same banking authorities, the same investment counselors are holding on to their jobs. It is true that the mortality has been great, but there are a good many fat, prosperous names left. When the storm came, these men, who had so industriously presdicted prosperity eternal and who had diagrams and charts to prove it, were helpless. We could have stomached their helplessness with far better grace, perhaps, if the great ones had been willing to admit it. But they were not. We ourselves had been crippled; so had our neighbors. It was impossible for us to conceal the consequences of our idiocy, and there was nothing to do but make the best of it and try to start again. But the captains and the senators and the cabinet members could not admit their folly or their helplessness. They had been omnipotent and omniscient for so long that a stepdown was impossible.
There's more... this is shockingly parallel. It's weirding me out.
Also - I've been having companies tell me their EAU forecasts (estimated annual usage) is dropping like a stone and are worried this will result in price increases [there really are higher costs associated with lower volumes in most mfg processes - ways to mitigate some but 'economies of scale' are real things that never go away]... so far falling raw material prices negated increases from lower volumes but we'll see that 'bottom out' too.
Once you see lower demand AND higher component part prices - that's when a lot of mfgrs scream 'uncle' and lay offs come in earnest.
BTW - midlevel white collar 'support function' jobs (IT, mktg, acctng, supply chain & logistics, engineering, finance) will get massacred - that's the only place they can cut enough to make a difference. Look for it coming to a company near you.
Whatever is driving it, the 3.3% 30-year bond yield is the most negative signal I've seen yet.
I believe it is due in part to insurance company and pension implosions.
These entities, with giant fixed income portfolios, can lose control of their own fates. They are mandated to slash default/price risk, and every day they invest in T-bills at zero they would just deepen their financial crisis.
A lot going on behind the scenes. So long as long bond yields keep falling, it is very negative for the stock market. Silent panic.
During recent holiday conversations with friends and family, I was surprised by the heightened awareness of the issues at hand. I had conversations about the housing market over the past few years as well as Credit Default Swaps with people who would otherwise not be informed about these subjects.
Unfortunately, although well read, these people were mostly repeating recent articles in major newspapers and magazines.
They had little, if any, understanding of the massive debt overhang, the value of the dollar, or the huge malinvestment over the past.
Ponyless in NJ(Good) writes:
It seems there is very little keeping this economy from freefall.. Fed/Treasury will need to pump a lot more money in to at least stabilize any remaining productive sectors. Not sure what those really are in the US economy anymore...
Ponyless in NJ | 12.01.08 - 11:58 am | #
Yup - and there is still more here than you realize. The problem is the jobs are in midlevel white collar - I think a lot of those are gone regardless.
Ask yourself - if I don't go to work today does the plant/company shut down? If the answer is 'no' - then you are expendable.
And even if you are 'essential' consider this - grave yards are full of people who once thought they were indispensable yet the world kept going around the sun.
This recession goes from 'virtual' to 'real' when the job loss kicks into hyperdrive.
...And so we were treated to a most extraordinary spectable. We saw these men, like a troop of savages, attempt with chanting and loud cries to abate the wrath of the storm. It is needless to rehearse their shibboleths and incantations, their magic words "optimism" and "just around the corner." We know them all by heart and we know they didn't work. But now, as we move into the third year of hard times, we discovers that these gentlemen are still positive, still knowing, still as farsighted as ever they were. We learn that they had no share of responsibility for the disaster. The eminent banker who declared twelve days before the crash that "the industrial condition of the United States is absolutely sound and our credit system is nin no way critical" is still authoritative and serene. Recently he appeared before a senate committee and testified that the extravagant lending of money to corporations and individuals for speculation "should have been stopped ten years ago." Stopped by whom? He declared that the bankers would never be governed by any code set up by themselves, and, when questioned about the possibilities of government control over unruly finance, was horrified. "We are frankly skeptical," said he, "That the ideal can be attained; freedom for the individual to engage in whatever business he chooses and to develop that business in accordance with his talent and judgment is a privilege which all Americans cherish. It involves freedom to make mistakes."
Freedom to make mistakes! A remarkable stetementi nthe face of an army of bankrupts and an ever-growing horde of unemployed. Is it for this freedom that he and his colleagues plead for public confidence and support while eveyr available means of publicity is invoked to cajole money out of hiding? What can the citizen think? .. The only trouble is that we won't believe it. And from this we can draw but one conclusion: The captains and the cabinet members have learned nothing... even the Dean of the Harvard Business School is willing to admit that "capitalism is on trial and on the issue of this trial may depend the whole future of western civilzation."
This crisis is creating a bigger crisis--instead of trying to break up financials into manageable sizes (not too big to fail), we're making the villains even bigger. Instead of inflating ourselves out of over priced real estate, we're deflating--making foreclosures more certain. Instead of cheapening the dollar to improve exports, we're encouraging more imports with an appreciating dollar.
When the fan is fully shitted, we'll be a banana republic with a national debt equal to our gdp. The stock market is so overpriced because people and institutions are not facing reality--and there's no place else to park money. If we're going to go into hock, we should at least nationalize the industries we bail out--so that the dollars get used for society and not for sociopaths.
Whoocouldanode that Bush was worse in domestic policy than foreign policy?
"BTW - midlevel white collar 'support function' jobs (IT, mktg, acctng, supply chain & logistics, engineering, finance) will get massacred - that's the only place they can cut enough to make a difference. Look for it coming to a company near you."
dryfly | 12.01.08 - 12:04 pm | #
dryfly,
I have always been amazed at mgr to hourly ratio at other companies. My boss has 21 guys reporting to him.
Almost 20 mgrs report to the senior.
It is nice to be tossed the plan and allowed to run with it. Lots of techs off the street don't survive the first year here. If you can't plan and organize you are dead..
OT- Anecdotal--I was up in Tahoe this weekend. Took my 4 year old for beginner ski lessons on their man-made snow. Last year the kids ski school had 30 plus kids over the Thanksgiving weekend, this year, just my kid and one other on Saturday for lessons. Place was dead on Sunday.
I have always been amazed at mgr to hourly ratio at other companies. My boss has 21 guys reporting to him.
Almost 20 mgrs report to the senior.
It is nice to be tossed the plan and allowed to run with it. Lots of techs off the street don't survive the first year here. If you can't plan and organize you are dead..
That is the future Chris - but if you plan to do that [as an organizational strategy] then you need to have VERY GOOD front line people and knowledgeable supervisors who only 'supervise' [then stay out of the workers way so they can execute].
Most organizations have weak front lines & midlevel mgrs who compensate by trying to 'micro-manange'. It's a losing proposition all around.
Anybody else see the 3-month T-bill hit ½ basis point today?
No, but I'm not watching continuously. It's been 10 basis points or less for some time now anyway. It's amazing how quickly we have become inured to being in a liquidity trap. Every day at those numbers should be front page news, but nobody cares anymore.
IT jobs that can further out-sourced will be. My wife works at a gov agency that is outsourcing the help desk - support peeps to one national site. They will login to your PC and fix it from there.
Most companies do not need the number of onsite people they have. A lot could get by with none, and a good on call contractor. Outsource your servers to a site and you can cut some high paid bodies.
UPDATE: Prize? The winners get their names mentioned, their comments featured, the admiration of their peers, and a free subscription to Calculated Risk!
UPDATE 2&3&4: Elaine is already a winner! Here are the picks so far (updates in bold):
Aug 2005 Kirk Spencer, wharf rat
Sep 2005 Vernon Bush
Oct 2005 BE, David Bennett
Nov 2005 David Yaseen, Fernando Margueirat, steve kyle, Nguyen Khuu
Jan 2006 Yusef Asabiyah, dryfly, Frank, redfish
Feb 2006 Mish, E.Robinson
Mar 2006 Colin H, ChasHeath, Alan Greenspend, Movie Guy, F.Hagan
Apr 2006 battlepanda
May 2006 Ken Houghton, navin
Jun 2006 DOR
Aug 2006 Jason Wright
Mar 2008 dilbert dogbert
Jul 2008 jl
Nov 2008 Elaine Supkis
March, 2011 Paul
NEVER Larry Kudlow's doppelganger
crispy&cole(Unrated) writes:
NBER MAKES IT OFFICIAL!!
crispy&cole | Homepage | 12.01.08 - 12:16 pm | #
In other news - NBER weather forecasting division are waiting for Dec 21 to announce 'winter has come to North America'... meanwhile residents of Minnesota continue to scrape ice & snow off their driveways.
Tudor Jones hedge fund suspends withdrawals
Paul Tudor Jones, the billionaire hedge fund manager, is splitting his flagship $10bn Tudor BVI Global Fund in two
He told clients - who include racing driver Sir Jackie Stewart - he is splitting the $10billion Tudor BVI Global Fund in two.
Clients will then have their money split between that fund and a new fund, called Legacy, which will contain illiquid investments such as corporate bonds and emerging market debt.
Investors will be allowed to get their money out from next March, once the harder-to-sell investments have been shed off into Legacy, while Mr Tudor Jones will not charge them a performance fee its assets have exceeded their peak value. The move follows requests from investors for some $1.4billion worth of their money back........Born in Memphis, Tennassee, Mr Tudor Jones is a hunting fanatic who owns a 346,000-acre safari park in Zimbabwe and a game lodge in the Serengeti in Tanzania.
His UK headquarters are at Great Burgh House, a Grade II-listed mansion on the Epsom Downs, which boasts its own cricket pitch
----"This is not what a recession looks like....no way!" Mike Green and Jim Benham show 11/16/07
----Mike Green: "Wallstreet thinks things are bad, but in reality things are very good. 12/18/07 (At the time: DOW at 13,323, Nas at 2596, S&P 1454
----"I have a real problem with people not using facts in basing their opinions." Pat Powell, Powell investments (Reference Peter Schiff's opinion that we are in a recession right now 11/22/07) Q208 revisions prove he is right when Q407 comes in at -.02
----"all the bad news is priced into financials" Mike Green and Jim Benham show 12/14/07
----Fred Layne on Bloomerg (layne and Barry) "This is a great time to be a buyer of equities 12/19/07.
----Donald Luskin calls the bottom for financials on 12/07/07 (VFH financial index at $56.22 at time of call)
-=--Economist Monti says there will probably not be a recession in 2008, Bloomberg 12/17/07
----Mike Green: "This is the cheapest stocks have been in my lifetime" 12/17/07
----Michael Darda from MKM partners: "There is no evidence for that (recession)" "I think those who think a recession is coming are wrong, dead wrong". 12/20/07
----Bruce Kassim "We think growth will rebound rather smartly in the second half of 08" 12/20/07
----Larry Kudlow "It does not look like a recession to me!" 12/20/07
----Brian Wesbury on Larry Kudlow show, "Brian Wesbury is not seeing recession, so add me to that list" 12/20/07 (Estimated 3.0 real growth next year, while Roubini estimated -1.5% 2008)
----Buzz Zaino, Royce & Associates: "I think the spring will see a rise in homebuying, why wait until 2009, the early buyers will get the best deal." "I think we've seen the bottom (housing stocks)" 12/26/07
----Richard DeKaser National City Chief Economist: "I think the first half of 08 will have GDP at less than 1% with a rebound to 3% in the second half of 08".
----Joe Brusuelus "I see an average growth of 2.1% for 2008. I think we will skirt a recession." 01/02/08
----Brian Wesbury calls for Dow 15,000 by end of 2008!!!. Reaffirms a no recession call. 01/02/08
----Paul Kandel "I think we skirt by both a recession and stagflation and just see slow growth for 2008." 01/02/08
----Mike Green "These tech stocks are the cheapest I've ever seen them" 01/02/08
----01/06/08 Abby Joseph Coen calls for a 14% return on the S&P for 2008 to 1650 due to avoiding recession. (Cohen loses job calling S&P on 3/17/08, replacement calls for drop to 1160 and rebound to 1300 by year's end)
----01/06/08 Colin Glingsman of Oppenheimer Capital..."This month (Jan) is the bottom for financials, we will have a slight recession, the stock market will be up on anticipation for 2009, the bottom for housing stocks is upon us"
----01/06/08 Jeffy Kleintop (LPL Investments) "This is a great time for stocks since they are pricing in a recession that won't happen."
----01/06/08 Brian Wesbury "I don't think we are headed for a recession"
----01/08/08 NEW YORK, Jan 8 (Reuters) - BlackRock Inc global equities chief investment officer Bob Doll on Tuesday forecast U.S. stocks will reach record highs again in 2008 as the U.S narrowly escapes a recession.
(BlackRock's Doll sees record year for stocks in 2008
| Reuters
---01/28/08 Lincold Anderson (LTL Financial) on Bloomberg: "We see this as a buying opportunity (for stocks), we don't see a recession ahead" (S&P at 1353 at the time).
---01/30/08 David Boss on Bloomberg after the planned 50bps cut by Bernanke: "We think equities are going to be up 12 months from now."(S&P at 1355 at the time)
---02/04/08 Fritz Meyer on Bloomberg commenting on the highest insider buying in January since 1996 "I think the insiders know when to buy. I would guess that at the end of '08, the market would be substantially higher than it is now. (said S&P at 1600 by year's end was "entirely reasonable"(S&P at 1380 at the time))
---02/06/08 Jim Cramer, "I'm predicting a housing shortage and a bank stock shortage...There's gonna be a housing shortage a year from now!".
---02/08/08 Joe Keeting of First American Asset Mngmt, On Bloomberg, very bullish on stocks "I think we can do 10-15% this year. I think you will see low double digit gains" He also said "Bank of American is a good place to be right now. (BAC at $43.07 at the time of the call, $21.00 by 10/23/08)"
---02/11/08 Barton Biggs on Bloomberg "I think valuations are quite attractive, unless you think we are going into some kind of credit abyss...and I think that's unlikely".
---02/21/08 Neil Hennessy, (chronic bull, who was saying buy stocks all second half of 07), "We happen to be in good economic times but people just don't believe it.." Bloomberg TV interview/ Dow at 12,279.
---03/11/08 David Sewerby on Bloomberg, "there are some attractive valuations out there and the fed is easing. I think we are at the bottom for stocks." (Dow was up 400 to 12,140 on that day)
---03/14/08 Barton Biggs on Bloomberg, (after the Bear Stearns blow-up), "The markets are trying to make a bottom here. (DOW at 11,951) We think we could see a 1000 point rally soon. Sometime you have to make a stand. This is just panic and you have to buy when it's the at the worst. We are in (the market) right now.
---03/14/08 Jerry Jordon on Bloomberg, (Dow at 11,951), I think you load up on (stocks) Monday, and on Tuesday....This may sound crazy, but I think we hit all time highs (for stocks) this year(2008)!
---03/17/08 Jim Paulsen on Bloomberg, "The S&P is still expected to earn double digit profits, I think it's already priced in." S&P at 1276.
---03/20/08 Punk, Ziegel & Co.'s Richard Bove says "now is the time to invest in banks, any more bad news will be meaningless. The financial crisis is over and investors should take advantage of the "once-in-a-generation opportunity" to buy banking stocks"
---03/20/08 Brian Wesbury on CNBC "We are not going to have a recession. A recession is highly unlikely. We see 2.0% this quarter. We don't see anything close to a recession."
---03/22/08 Moe Ansari calls the bottom of the market on his radio show. Dow at 12,361, S&P at 1329.51 Nas at 2258.
---05-07-08 Brian Wesbury on CNBC says "I predict Dow 15,000 by the end of the year" (2008) Dow at 13,000 when he said it. He also reitterated his "no recession" call.
---05-07-08 Frequent CR poster Sebastian said (In response to the above Wesbury comment): "I don't know what model(s) he uses, but the fact of the matter is that DJIA at 15,000 by the end of the year isn't really out of line.
Sebastian
Sebastian | 05.07.08 - 12:39 pm | #
---05/08/08 Barton Biggs on bloomberg encouraging going long saying "The economy is just not that bad off...we are talking to companies and aren't hearing the gloom and doom that others think is out there."
---05/11/08 After Meredith Whitney sasy Citi is the most overvalued financial stock at $23, Charles Peabody on bloomberg sees Citi in the mid 30's by mid 2009, thinks many are too pessimistic on economy.
---05/11/08 On bloomberg Charles Lemonidas says MBIA is a good buy at $10 and sees a near future stock price from $25-$40. He also liked Boeing(BA) at $85, Lemonidas also recommended Freddie and Fannie the Friday before they essentially went to zero.
---06/30/08 Ron Rimcus of BB&T Financial recommends KBH at 17$ a share on Bloomberg. He says there is $17 on KBH's books so you are getting it for free. He sees healthy returns a "few years out".
---07/01/08 Phil Orlando on Bloomberg says the second half of the year will show positive growth and the current weakness in the market will be a good buying opportunity.
---07/03/08 US Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson said here on Thursday that the US economy would most likely be stronger at the end of 2008, even as oil prices surged to new records above 146 dollars."I think there is a very strong possibility that we will be growing at the end of the year. We will have stronger growth at the end of the year than we have right now," he said during a press conference after talks with his British counterpart Alistair Darling. "http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=080703120512.75gtwijc&show_article=1
---07/07/08 UBS among others came out with 1650 year-end call on the S&P500. At the time of the call the S&P was at 1245. They were calling for an 18% rally in the index in 6 months.
---07/29/08 Win Smith of WHS Holdings on Bloomberg says the financials are making a bottom (VFH at 39.12) and said he is starting to buy Merryl (MER 24$) after they raised 8 billion for cash they previously said they didn't need.
---08/05/08 Thomas Lee, Equity Strategist, says stocks will be higher by year's end and the S&P500 will be at about 1450 by the end of 2008. (S&P at 1289 at the time).
---08/11/08 James Chessen, American Bankers Assoc, on Bloomberg laughed at the prospect that the FDIC is facing a crisis. He pointed out that we are "no where near" the crisis on the 1990's and that the FDIC is adequately funded to handle the coming bank failures.
---08/27/08 S&P 500 at 1281 Sebastian writes:
Just looking at the chart, the closest "match" to the current numbers looks like about mid-1982...a huge rebound out of a major generational low, also coinciding with the beginning of a major new secular bull market in stocks.
The insanity we're seeing in the bond market - ridiculously low long bond rates, "impossible" TIP/treasury spreads - shows the credit market is coming apart. This is what you'd expect from a liquidity trap, because in a liquidity trap it no longer makes sense to save and invest. The market ceases to function and consequently prices become meaningless. I keep hoping the Fed will realize forcing the economy into a liquidity trap by lowering nominal interest rates to 0% is going to create a Greater Depression, but I'm getting less and less hopeful.
The definition below makes perfect sense as an investment strategy. Why lose what you have? Yet, if everyone begins to believe that; you get a very bad result.
The only 2 ways out? If I understand it correctly is pay the consumer to consume. Or let the system crash and rebuild. Neither is really all the cool of an option...
In this kind of situation, people do not expect high returns on physical or financial investments, so they keep assets in short-term cash bank accounts or hoards rather than making long-term investments. This makes a recession even more severe, and can contribute to deflation.
I saw a chart which subtracted home equity withdraws from GDP. If people hadn't been draining their home equity, we would have had negative GDP for most quarters since 2001.
And for anyone who missed it a couple of weeks ago, my (continued) apologies to CR and all the other recession-callers. I was dead-wrong all the way with no excuses, and you were dead-right.
And for anyone who missed it a couple of weeks ago, my (continued) apologies to CR and all the other recession-callers. I was dead-wrong all the way with no excuses, and you were dead-right.
The Massive 8.5 Tril QE being done by the Fed/Treas is at this point the only bazooka they have left to prevent this asset implosion. Will it work? I don't think so. The one thing that surprises me more than anything about those more optomistic than I am, they actually believe that there is a painless way out of this mess.
In other news - NBER weather forecasting division are waiting for Dec 21 to announce 'winter has come to North America'... meanwhile residents of Minnesota continue to scrape ice & snow off their driveways.
dryfly | 12.01.08 - 12:21 pm | #
I think NBER would be announcing that winter 2007 had indeed arrived last winter...
Is a recession still supposed to be two consecutive quarters of negative GDP--or any contraction at all, even though GDP growth may have remained positive?
Nice apology Sebastian....although since you didnt take anyone's money for your investment skill (I assume), you don't need to apologize.
All those idiots who got paid as "financial" experts...who came on TV to encourage others to put their hard earned money where there mouth was...for all those who took a small piece of other people's investment money as a fee for their "financial prowess"....they should resign today and return every penny.
This was the easiest most obvious call in financial history.
Even the Average Joe, with no financial training could see it plain as day.
All you "financial experts" were frauds and we need the same media that held them in high esteem, to embarrass and shame them.
I keep hoping the Fed will realize forcing the economy into a liquidity trap by lowering nominal interest rates to 0% is going to create a Greater Depression, but I'm getting less and less hopeful.
Crowding out real savings to preserve fictitious wealth is no way to manage an eCONomy.
The bottom 95% of wealth holders will be destroyed for a generation. Perhaps forever.
Wow, so all this time we've been in a recession? WHOCOODANODE! I am glad I waited for the official announcement, you know, just to be sure. I wish there was a place on the internet where I could have found out sooner about these important economic issues.
I always tried to give Sebastian the credit he was due, for his reasonable and fair opinions. We need balance, and I hope he continues to speak his mind.
Cramer is an idiot. I did switch and get a package for Bloomberg. Much better, an interview lasts more than 90 seconds.Plus the package I had to buy has two channels of COPS.
Seb: I saw you post a few weeks ago, and I admire that you were up front and public about your wrong call on the economy. I always value opposing viewpoints so don't stop posting. Curious, in hindsight, why do you think your model didn't work this time, (or what economic indicators would you have looked at differently given perfect hindsight)?
Pavel Chichikov(Unrated) writes:
"...grave yards are full of people who once thought they were indispensable..."
Charles de Gaulle
Something like: The cemeteries are full of indispensable people.
Pavel Chichikov | 12.01.08 - 1:17 pm | #
And de Gaulle should know - some of them are his neighbors.
[BTW I knew de Gaulle said that - I was too lazy to get the exact quote & citation - my bad. One of the best quotes ever though - especially for those with really 'big heads'...]
Average Joe said: "Nice apology Sebastian....although since you didn't take anyone's money for your investment skill (I assume), you don't need to apologize."
Thanks, but I certainly am obligated to apologize for my condescending attitude over the past couple of years towards the "recession-callers" here.
"...This was the easiest most obvious call in financial history...."
On this point I have to disagree. It clearly wasn't, and I'm speaking as one of the people who caught on early to the dot.com bust several years ago. It was obvious to the people for whom it was obvious, but not Greenspan, the Fed, derivatives traders, investment banks, homebuilders, mainstream economists, stock market analysts/strategists, the majority of mutual fund managers etc., etc.
It wasn't just the industry spokesmen, personal-agenda-driven shills and mindless permabulls who got caught off-guard, but also serious, data-driven people, too.
Both developments worrisome - consumer credit contraction and industrial output contraction. The retail economy runs on consumer credit. I know that's obvious to a small child, but when I see people paying for their muffin and coffee at Whole Foods with a credit card, I start to wonder how precarious their financial situation is. Extrapolation makes you wonder about the whole country.
"While just over 70 per cent of US households have access to credit cards, 90 per cent of these people use credit cards as a cash-flow management vehicle, or revolve payments at least once a year. While the credit card market is small relative to the mortgage market, it has grown to play a key role in consumer liquidity. Declining liquidity here will have disastrous effects on consumer spending and the economy"
Bottoming process.
It seems all of the previously relatively strong areas of the economy - consumer spending, investment in non-residential structures, and exports (and manufacturing) - are all in a steep slide.
Very steep slide - even Deere & Co. saying profits next year will be down [maybe a lot].
Great time to be on the sidelines. I think a once in a lifetime buying opportunity for energy stocks will occur in a few months. Coal and nat gas, especially.
It seems there is very little keeping this economy from freefall.. Fed/Treasury will need to pump a lot more money in to at least stabilize any remaining productive sectors. Not sure what those really are in the US economy anymore...
And now all the lights on the big control panel are red. Well, energy's cheaper -- but what does that get you when your engines are dripping coolant and ready to seize up?
So it begins. If these bond deals were done as part of a criminal enterprise, the citizens of Birmingham out of the bond deals:
Birmingham Mayor Larry Langford arrested on federal charges | Breaking News from The Birmingham News - al.com
Anybody else see the 3-month T-bill hit ½ basis point today?
It has rebounded all the way to 1 basis point now.
OT: Is there a connection between the Fed refusing to settle the repo market and the fixed 30 year. Deflation aside, how evil can the T market get??
Judging by Ca traffic. We have returned to our old ways...
From Harper's Magazine, 1932
Revolutions are an old story to the American Citizen. To the Russian, they are still a new and startling experience; the American knows the tale of revolution almost by heart. His national existence began with one, many of the most illustrious names in his history books are associated with that celebrated rebellion.
...
The country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of existing government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it, or their revolutionary right to dismember and overthrow it.
What is the American with the revolutionary birthright htinking about these days? His own country and the world are now in the midst of a vast economic upheaval. The systems of production and distribution have been badly jammed, and some of the parts will never again be of any use. You and I and the citizen begin to have a feeling that perhaps we shall have to deal with a number of problems that we have never touched before. This word revolution is heard at every hand; we seem to face revolutions of all sorts and kinds. We use what intelligence we have, not as experts of finance but as ordinary citizens, watching the news of the world as our neighbors and the newspapers give it to us.
For the most part, the men who now occupy our seats of government were there at the high tide of the boom. They were in office when the crash came and, barring the fatalilties of the last elections, they are still there. Mr. Hoover is, of course, the most obvious example. In business the same captains of industry, the same banking authorities, the same investment counselors are holding on to their jobs. It is true that the mortality has been great, but there are a good many fat, prosperous names left. When the storm came, these men, who had so industriously presdicted prosperity eternal and who had diagrams and charts to prove it, were helpless. We could have stomached their helplessness with far better grace, perhaps, if the great ones had been willing to admit it. But they were not. We ourselves had been crippled; so had our neighbors. It was impossible for us to conceal the consequences of our idiocy, and there was nothing to do but make the best of it and try to start again. But the captains and the senators and the cabinet members could not admit their folly or their helplessness. They had been omnipotent and omniscient for so long that a stepdown was impossible.
There's more... this is shockingly parallel. It's weirding me out.
Pilgrim's Pride files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy: court filing
Also - I've been having companies tell me their EAU forecasts (estimated annual usage) is dropping like a stone and are worried this will result in price increases [there really are higher costs associated with lower volumes in most mfg processes - ways to mitigate some but 'economies of scale' are real things that never go away]... so far falling raw material prices negated increases from lower volumes but we'll see that 'bottom out' too.
Once you see lower demand AND higher component part prices - that's when a lot of mfgrs scream 'uncle' and lay offs come in earnest.
BTW - midlevel white collar 'support function' jobs (IT, mktg, acctng, supply chain & logistics, engineering, finance) will get massacred - that's the only place they can cut enough to make a difference. Look for it coming to a company near you.
MOT
The irony. 4 days after Thanksgiving
Whatever is driving it, the 3.3% 30-year bond yield is the most negative signal I've seen yet.
I believe it is due in part to insurance company and pension implosions.
These entities, with giant fixed income portfolios, can lose control of their own fates. They are mandated to slash default/price risk, and every day they invest in T-bills at zero they would just deepen their financial crisis.
A lot going on behind the scenes. So long as long bond yields keep falling, it is very negative for the stock market. Silent panic.
During recent holiday conversations with friends and family, I was surprised by the heightened awareness of the issues at hand. I had conversations about the housing market over the past few years as well as Credit Default Swaps with people who would otherwise not be informed about these subjects.
Unfortunately, although well read, these people were mostly repeating recent articles in major newspapers and magazines.
They had little, if any, understanding of the massive debt overhang, the value of the dollar, or the huge malinvestment over the past.
Ponyless in NJ(Good) writes:
It seems there is very little keeping this economy from freefall.. Fed/Treasury will need to pump a lot more money in to at least stabilize any remaining productive sectors. Not sure what those really are in the US economy anymore...
Ponyless in NJ | 12.01.08 - 11:58 am | #
Yup - and there is still more here than you realize. The problem is the jobs are in midlevel white collar - I think a lot of those are gone regardless.
Ask yourself - if I don't go to work today does the plant/company shut down? If the answer is 'no' - then you are expendable.
And even if you are 'essential' consider this - grave yards are full of people who once thought they were indispensable yet the world kept going around the sun.
This recession goes from 'virtual' to 'real' when the job loss kicks into hyperdrive.
Ask yourself - if I don't go to work today does the plant/company shut down? If the answer is 'no' - then you are expendable.
Good point.
...And so we were treated to a most extraordinary spectable. We saw these men, like a troop of savages, attempt with chanting and loud cries to abate the wrath of the storm. It is needless to rehearse their shibboleths and incantations, their magic words "optimism" and "just around the corner." We know them all by heart and we know they didn't work. But now, as we move into the third year of hard times, we discovers that these gentlemen are still positive, still knowing, still as farsighted as ever they were. We learn that they had no share of responsibility for the disaster. The eminent banker who declared twelve days before the crash that "the industrial condition of the United States is absolutely sound and our credit system is nin no way critical" is still authoritative and serene. Recently he appeared before a senate committee and testified that the extravagant lending of money to corporations and individuals for speculation "should have been stopped ten years ago." Stopped by whom? He declared that the bankers would never be governed by any code set up by themselves, and, when questioned about the possibilities of government control over unruly finance, was horrified. "We are frankly skeptical," said he, "That the ideal can be attained; freedom for the individual to engage in whatever business he chooses and to develop that business in accordance with his talent and judgment is a privilege which all Americans cherish. It involves freedom to make mistakes."
Freedom to make mistakes! A remarkable stetementi nthe face of an army of bankrupts and an ever-growing horde of unemployed. Is it for this freedom that he and his colleagues plead for public confidence and support while eveyr available means of publicity is invoked to cajole money out of hiding? What can the citizen think? .. The only trouble is that we won't believe it. And from this we can draw but one conclusion: The captains and the cabinet members have learned nothing... even the Dean of the Harvard Business School is willing to admit that "capitalism is on trial and on the issue of this trial may depend the whole future of western civilzation."
This crisis is creating a bigger crisis--instead of trying to break up financials into manageable sizes (not too big to fail), we're making the villains even bigger. Instead of inflating ourselves out of over priced real estate, we're deflating--making foreclosures more certain. Instead of cheapening the dollar to improve exports, we're encouraging more imports with an appreciating dollar.
When the fan is fully shitted, we'll be a banana republic with a national debt equal to our gdp. The stock market is so overpriced because people and institutions are not facing reality--and there's no place else to park money. If we're going to go into hock, we should at least nationalize the industries we bail out--so that the dollars get used for society and not for sociopaths.
Whoocouldanode that Bush was worse in domestic policy than foreign policy?
In my years of employment one thing has always stuck with me. EVERYONE is expendable...Take that to the bank, if it's still open for business...
Great googly moogly!
CR, did you get a gander on the CP 30 day spread - 596 bps! - caramba!
FRB Commercial Paper
"BTW - midlevel white collar 'support function' jobs (IT, mktg, acctng, supply chain & logistics, engineering, finance) will get massacred - that's the only place they can cut enough to make a difference. Look for it coming to a company near you."
dryfly | 12.01.08 - 12:04 pm | #
dryfly,
I have always been amazed at mgr to hourly ratio at other companies. My boss has 21 guys reporting to him.
Almost 20 mgrs report to the senior.
It is nice to be tossed the plan and allowed to run with it. Lots of techs off the street don't survive the first year here. If you can't plan and organize you are dead..
Chris
OT- Anecdotal--I was up in Tahoe this weekend. Took my 4 year old for beginner ski lessons on their man-made snow. Last year the kids ski school had 30 plus kids over the Thanksgiving weekend, this year, just my kid and one other on Saturday for lessons. Place was dead on Sunday.
don't expect BRIC to decouple from the global decline. the ecuadorian bond default is making central and south america very nervous -
ecuador press -
Brazil fears that other countries question their external debts
Google Translate
Brazilian press -
Google Translate
I'll stop transcribing this depression-era editorial if nobody is interested. My fingers hurt.
It's official - we're in a recession. NBER dates recession start to Dec.07. Just in case there was any doubt.
CR CALLS IT!
NBER CALLS RECESSION STARTING DECEMBER 2007.
Just heard US Recession started December 2007.
CR vindicated.
.
.
Wow, Dec. 2007. Where's Seb. Great from Harper's Hoop.
NBER MAKES IT OFFICIAL!!
Dec 2007!
CR is the man! Perfect recession call!
Sebastian = dumbshit!
So that means a fierce rally this week, right?
Do you think NBER was waiting for the election to be over to announce the recession?
CR for Treasury Secretary!
Congratulations CR!!! Your date for "probable" recession has been confirmed by the NBER!!!!
anyone have a link for the NBER info?
I have always been amazed at mgr to hourly ratio at other companies. My boss has 21 guys reporting to him.
Almost 20 mgrs report to the senior.
It is nice to be tossed the plan and allowed to run with it. Lots of techs off the street don't survive the first year here. If you can't plan and organize you are dead..
That is the future Chris - but if you plan to do that [as an organizational strategy] then you need to have VERY GOOD front line people and knowledgeable supervisors who only 'supervise' [then stay out of the workers way so they can execute].
Most organizations have weak front lines & midlevel mgrs who compensate by trying to 'micro-manange'. It's a losing proposition all around.
headline at marketwatch.com and bloomberg tv
take the market up on that NBER news!
The recession's a year old already.... gotta be priced in.
Anybody else see the 3-month T-bill hit ½ basis point today?
No, but I'm not watching continuously. It's been 10 basis points or less for some time now anyway. It's amazing how quickly we have become inured to being in a liquidity trap. Every day at those numbers should be front page news, but nobody cares anymore.
But Sean Hannity said it was 2 qtrs of negative gdp...lmfao!!
Business Cycle Dating Committee, National Bureau of Economic Research
IT jobs that can further out-sourced will be. My wife works at a gov agency that is outsourcing the help desk - support peeps to one national site. They will login to your PC and fix it from there.
Most companies do not need the number of onsite people they have. A lot could get by with none, and a good on call contractor. Outsource your servers to a site and you can cut some high paid bodies.
Do you think NBER was waiting for the election to be over to announce the recession?
Is the Pope Catholic? Seriously, how blatant can you get?
I am so very sorry for your loss. It brings a catch of breath, a grieving, a wish for you and yours that things could be better for you all.
My deepest condolences and heartfelt wishes for better days ahead while knowing they will not soon be coming.
Dec. 07, dang, i was off by 8 months in our mugs game here at CR back in 05.
Calculated Risk: The Mug's Game Challenge: Predict the Start of the Next Recession
UPDATE: Prize? The winners get their names mentioned, their comments featured, the admiration of their peers, and a free subscription to Calculated Risk!
UPDATE 2&3&4: Elaine is already a winner! Here are the picks so far (updates in bold):
Aug 2005 Kirk Spencer, wharf rat
Sep 2005 Vernon Bush
Oct 2005 BE, David Bennett
Nov 2005 David Yaseen, Fernando Margueirat, steve kyle, Nguyen Khuu
Jan 2006 Yusef Asabiyah, dryfly, Frank, redfish
Feb 2006 Mish, E.Robinson
Mar 2006 Colin H, ChasHeath, Alan Greenspend, Movie Guy, F.Hagan
Apr 2006 battlepanda
May 2006 Ken Houghton, navin
Jun 2006 DOR
Aug 2006 Jason Wright
Mar 2008 dilbert dogbert
Jul 2008 jl
Nov 2008 Elaine Supkis
March, 2011 Paul
NEVER Larry Kudlow's doppelganger
I just saw we lost Tanta.
God bless her.
My 'flavor' of religion believe we work in the afterlife for the common good. I see her quickly rising to be a lead auditor for St. Peter.
She will be missed,
Neil
crispy&cole(Unrated) writes:
NBER MAKES IT OFFICIAL!!
crispy&cole | Homepage | 12.01.08 - 12:16 pm | #
In other news - NBER weather forecasting division are waiting for Dec 21 to announce 'winter has come to North America'... meanwhile residents of Minnesota continue to scrape ice & snow off their driveways.
Why there should be a publicly traded chicken producer is beyond me. Is there some new hybrid I don't know about?
Hoopajoops LTD | 12.01.08 - 12:12 p
Rest your fingers. thanks tho.
Tudor Jones hedge fund suspends withdrawals
Paul Tudor Jones, the billionaire hedge fund manager, is splitting his flagship $10bn Tudor BVI Global Fund in two
He told clients - who include racing driver Sir Jackie Stewart - he is splitting the $10billion Tudor BVI Global Fund in two.
Clients will then have their money split between that fund and a new fund, called Legacy, which will contain illiquid investments such as corporate bonds and emerging market debt.
Investors will be allowed to get their money out from next March, once the harder-to-sell investments have been shed off into Legacy, while Mr Tudor Jones will not charge them a performance fee its assets have exceeded their peak value. The move follows requests from investors for some $1.4billion worth of their money back........Born in Memphis, Tennassee, Mr Tudor Jones is a hunting fanatic who owns a 346,000-acre safari park in Zimbabwe and a game lodge in the Serengeti in Tanzania.
His UK headquarters are at Great Burgh House, a Grade II-listed mansion on the Epsom Downs, which boasts its own cricket pitch
energyecon --
Great Googly Moogly indeed.
Short-term rates on government paper are essentially zero. I wonder how far the Fed is willing to go buying riskier and longer-duration assets.
rich writes:
Whatever is driving it, the 3.3% 30-year bond yield is the most negative signal I've seen yet.
rich | 12.01.08 - 12:07 pm
Translation: Buy long positions in TLT for the next few weeks to get the RoI would you normally get from the 30 yr Treasury?
Dryfly - nothin runs like a Deere!
Just downhill running now
In honor of the Recession call:
----"This is not what a recession looks like....no way!" Mike Green and Jim Benham show 11/16/07
----Mike Green: "Wallstreet thinks things are bad, but in reality things are very good. 12/18/07 (At the time: DOW at 13,323, Nas at 2596, S&P 1454
----"I have a real problem with people not using facts in basing their opinions." Pat Powell, Powell investments (Reference Peter Schiff's opinion that we are in a recession right now 11/22/07) Q208 revisions prove he is right when Q407 comes in at -.02
----"all the bad news is priced into financials" Mike Green and Jim Benham show 12/14/07
----Fred Layne on Bloomerg (layne and Barry) "This is a great time to be a buyer of equities 12/19/07.
----Donald Luskin calls the bottom for financials on 12/07/07 (VFH financial index at $56.22 at time of call)
-=--Economist Monti says there will probably not be a recession in 2008, Bloomberg 12/17/07
----Mike Green: "This is the cheapest stocks have been in my lifetime" 12/17/07
----Michael Darda from MKM partners: "There is no evidence for that (recession)" "I think those who think a recession is coming are wrong, dead wrong". 12/20/07
----Bruce Kassim "We think growth will rebound rather smartly in the second half of 08" 12/20/07
----Larry Kudlow "It does not look like a recession to me!" 12/20/07
----Brian Wesbury on Larry Kudlow show, "Brian Wesbury is not seeing recession, so add me to that list" 12/20/07 (Estimated 3.0 real growth next year, while Roubini estimated -1.5% 2008)
----Buzz Zaino, Royce & Associates: "I think the spring will see a rise in homebuying, why wait until 2009, the early buyers will get the best deal." "I think we've seen the bottom (housing stocks)" 12/26/07
----Richard DeKaser National City Chief Economist: "I think the first half of 08 will have GDP at less than 1% with a rebound to 3% in the second half of 08".
----Joe Brusuelus "I see an average growth of 2.1% for 2008. I think we will skirt a recession." 01/02/08
----Brian Wesbury calls for Dow 15,000 by end of 2008!!!. Reaffirms a no recession call. 01/02/08
----Paul Kandel "I think we skirt by both a recession and stagflation and just see slow growth for 2008." 01/02/08
----Mike Green "These tech stocks are the cheapest I've ever seen them" 01/02/08
"NBER dates recession start to Dec.07."
Of course, we had the inside track on this information.
Thanks, CR!
----01/06/08 Abby Joseph Coen calls for a 14% return on the S&P for 2008 to 1650 due to avoiding recession. (Cohen loses job calling S&P on 3/17/08, replacement calls for drop to 1160 and rebound to 1300 by year's end)
----01/06/08 Colin Glingsman of Oppenheimer Capital..."This month (Jan) is the bottom for financials, we will have a slight recession, the stock market will be up on anticipation for 2009, the bottom for housing stocks is upon us"
----01/06/08 Jeffy Kleintop (LPL Investments) "This is a great time for stocks since they are pricing in a recession that won't happen."
----01/06/08 Brian Wesbury "I don't think we are headed for a recession"
----01/08/08 NEW YORK, Jan 8 (Reuters) - BlackRock Inc global equities chief investment officer Bob Doll on Tuesday forecast U.S. stocks will reach record highs again in 2008 as the U.S narrowly escapes a recession.
(BlackRock's Doll sees record year for stocks in 2008
| Reuters
---01/28/08 Lincold Anderson (LTL Financial) on Bloomberg: "We see this as a buying opportunity (for stocks), we don't see a recession ahead" (S&P at 1353 at the time).
---01/30/08 David Boss on Bloomberg after the planned 50bps cut by Bernanke: "We think equities are going to be up 12 months from now."(S&P at 1355 at the time)
---02/04/08 Fritz Meyer on Bloomberg commenting on the highest insider buying in January since 1996 "I think the insiders know when to buy. I would guess that at the end of '08, the market would be substantially higher than it is now. (said S&P at 1600 by year's end was "entirely reasonable"(S&P at 1380 at the time))
---02/06/08 Jim Cramer, "I'm predicting a housing shortage and a bank stock shortage...There's gonna be a housing shortage a year from now!".
---02/08/08 Joe Keeting of First American Asset Mngmt, On Bloomberg, very bullish on stocks "I think we can do 10-15% this year. I think you will see low double digit gains" He also said "Bank of American is a good place to be right now. (BAC at $43.07 at the time of the call, $21.00 by 10/23/08)"
---02/11/08 Barton Biggs on Bloomberg "I think valuations are quite attractive, unless you think we are going into some kind of credit abyss...and I think that's unlikely".
---02/21/08 Neil Hennessy, (chronic bull, who was saying buy stocks all second half of 07), "We happen to be in good economic times but people just don't believe it.." Bloomberg TV interview/ Dow at 12,279.
---03/11/08 David Sewerby on Bloomberg, "there are some attractive valuations out there and the fed is easing. I think we are at the bottom for stocks." (Dow was up 400 to 12,140 on that day)
---03/14/08 Barton Biggs on Bloomberg, (after the Bear Stearns blow-up), "The markets are trying to make a bottom here. (DOW at 11,951) We think we could see a 1000 point rally soon. Sometime you have to make a stand. This is just panic and you have to buy when it's the at the worst. We are in (the market) right now.
---03/14/08 Jerry Jordon on Bloomberg, (Dow at 11,951), I think you load up on (stocks) Monday, and on Tuesday....This may sound crazy, but I think we hit all time highs (for stocks) this year(2008)!
---03/17/08 Jim Paulsen on Bloomberg, "The S&P is still expected to earn double digit profits, I think it's already priced in." S&P at 1276.
---03/20/08 Punk, Ziegel & Co.'s Richard Bove says "now is the time to invest in banks, any more bad news will be meaningless. The financial crisis is over and investors should take advantage of the "once-in-a-generation opportunity" to buy banking stocks"
---03/20/08 Brian Wesbury on CNBC "We are not going to have a recession. A recession is highly unlikely. We see 2.0% this quarter. We don't see anything close to a recession."
---03/22/08 Moe Ansari calls the bottom of the market on his radio show. Dow at 12,361, S&P at 1329.51 Nas at 2258.
---05-07-08 Brian Wesbury on CNBC says "I predict Dow 15,000 by the end of the year" (2008) Dow at 13,000 when he said it. He also reitterated his "no recession" call.
---05-07-08 Frequent CR poster Sebastian said (In response to the above Wesbury comment): "I don't know what model(s) he uses, but the fact of the matter is that DJIA at 15,000 by the end of the year isn't really out of line.
Sebastian
Sebastian | 05.07.08 - 12:39 pm | #
---05/08/08 Barton Biggs on bloomberg encouraging going long saying "The economy is just not that bad off...we are talking to companies and aren't hearing the gloom and doom that others think is out there."
---05/11/08 After Meredith Whitney sasy Citi is the most overvalued financial stock at $23, Charles Peabody on bloomberg sees Citi in the mid 30's by mid 2009, thinks many are too pessimistic on economy.
---05/11/08 On bloomberg Charles Lemonidas says MBIA is a good buy at $10 and sees a near future stock price from $25-$40. He also liked Boeing(BA) at $85, Lemonidas also recommended Freddie and Fannie the Friday before they essentially went to zero.
---06/30/08 Ron Rimcus of BB&T Financial recommends KBH at 17$ a share on Bloomberg. He says there is $17 on KBH's books so you are getting it for free. He sees healthy returns a "few years out".
---07/01/08 Phil Orlando on Bloomberg says the second half of the year will show positive growth and the current weakness in the market will be a good buying opportunity.
---07/03/08 US Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson said here on Thursday that the US economy would most likely be stronger at the end of 2008, even as oil prices surged to new records above 146 dollars."I think there is a very strong possibility that we will be growing at the end of the year. We will have stronger growth at the end of the year than we have right now," he said during a press conference after talks with his British counterpart Alistair Darling. "http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=080703120512.75gtwijc&show_article=1
---07/07/08 UBS among others came out with 1650 year-end call on the S&P500. At the time of the call the S&P was at 1245. They were calling for an 18% rally in the index in 6 months.
YouTube
- Peter Schiff & Don Luskin - CNBC - Kudlow & Company - 7/2/2007 Awesome peter schiff clip
---07/29/08 Win Smith of WHS Holdings on Bloomberg says the financials are making a bottom (VFH at 39.12) and said he is starting to buy Merryl (MER 24$) after they raised 8 billion for cash they previously said they didn't need.
---08/05/08 Thomas Lee, Equity Strategist, says stocks will be higher by year's end and the S&P500 will be at about 1450 by the end of 2008. (S&P at 1289 at the time).
---08/11/08 James Chessen, American Bankers Assoc, on Bloomberg laughed at the prospect that the FDIC is facing a crisis. He pointed out that we are "no where near" the crisis on the 1990's and that the FDIC is adequately funded to handle the coming bank failures.
---08/27/08 S&P 500 at 1281 Sebastian writes:
Just looking at the chart, the closest "match" to the current numbers looks like about mid-1982...a huge rebound out of a major generational low, also coinciding with the beginning of a major new secular bull market in stocks.
But I'm sure it's different this time.
Sebastian
Sebastian | 08.27.08 - 6:14 pm |
GS -15%. Smothered by the tarp like that baseball player?
CR--congratulations on getting the start of the recession call spot on. Someday you ought to write a book.
Next time a financial expert tries to tell you anything....remember those most in "the know"........DIDN'T!!!!
Why does the dollar hate American manufacturing?
Rich
Whatever is driving it, the 3.3% 30-year bond yield is the most negative signal I've seen yet.
Think so too.
The insanity we're seeing in the bond market - ridiculously low long bond rates, "impossible" TIP/treasury spreads - shows the credit market is coming apart. This is what you'd expect from a liquidity trap, because in a liquidity trap it no longer makes sense to save and invest. The market ceases to function and consequently prices become meaningless. I keep hoping the Fed will realize forcing the economy into a liquidity trap by lowering nominal interest rates to 0% is going to create a Greater Depression, but I'm getting less and less hopeful.
Liquidity trap from Wiki
The definition below makes perfect sense as an investment strategy. Why lose what you have? Yet, if everyone begins to believe that; you get a very bad result.
The only 2 ways out? If I understand it correctly is pay the consumer to consume. Or let the system crash and rebuild. Neither is really all the cool of an option...
In this kind of situation, people do not expect high returns on physical or financial investments, so they keep assets in short-term cash bank accounts or hoards rather than making long-term investments. This makes a recession even more severe, and can contribute to deflation.
I saw a chart which subtracted home equity withdraws from GDP. If people hadn't been draining their home equity, we would have had negative GDP for most quarters since 2001.
(OT) Re: NBER recession call.
And for anyone who missed it a couple of weeks ago, my (continued) apologies to CR and all the other recession-callers. I was dead-wrong all the way with no excuses, and you were dead-right.
Sincerely,
Sebastia
Though I guess the gov has decided to give $ to the banks so they can, as a proxy, give us money? The plan is to shop our way out?
Wow Sebastian, very classy of you, many people can never admit being wrong.
Wow Sebastian, very classy of you, many people can never admit being wrong
And some people never stop
(OT) Re: NBER recession call.
And for anyone who missed it a couple of weeks ago, my (continued) apologies to CR and all the other recession-callers. I was dead-wrong all the way with no excuses, and you were dead-right.
Sincerely,
Sebastian
Very gentleman of you Sebastian.
Cheers to you.
The recession will officially end when the depression begins. Bank on it. Or uhm better yet, mattress it.
Average Joe,
Thanks for the trip down memory lane.
Money (mis)managers!
The Massive 8.5 Tril QE being done by the Fed/Treas is at this point the only bazooka they have left to prevent this asset implosion. Will it work? I don't think so. The one thing that surprises me more than anything about those more optomistic than I am, they actually believe that there is a painless way out of this mess.
In other news - NBER weather forecasting division are waiting for Dec 21 to announce 'winter has come to North America'... meanwhile residents of Minnesota continue to scrape ice & snow off their driveways.
dryfly | 12.01.08 - 12:21 pm | #
I think NBER would be announcing that winter 2007 had indeed arrived last winter...
Is a recession still supposed to be two consecutive quarters of negative GDP--or any contraction at all, even though GDP growth may have remained positive?
Nice apology Sebastian....although since you didnt take anyone's money for your investment skill (I assume), you don't need to apologize.
All those idiots who got paid as "financial" experts...who came on TV to encourage others to put their hard earned money where there mouth was...for all those who took a small piece of other people's investment money as a fee for their "financial prowess"....they should resign today and return every penny.
This was the easiest most obvious call in financial history.
Even the Average Joe, with no financial training could see it plain as day.
All you "financial experts" were frauds and we need the same media that held them in high esteem, to embarrass and shame them.
It's only fair.
I keep hoping the Fed will realize forcing the economy into a liquidity trap by lowering nominal interest rates to 0% is going to create a Greater Depression, but I'm getting less and less hopeful.
Crowding out real savings to preserve fictitious wealth is no way to manage an eCONomy.
The bottom 95% of wealth holders will be destroyed for a generation. Perhaps forever.
I see a bubble in "wards of the state".
Hey Seb, nothing wrong with being wrong. Sometimes you become a CR icon.
I think NBER would be announcing that winter 2007 had indeed arrived last winter...
Lionel | 12.01.08 - 12:40 pm | #
LOL!!! Ya - exactly.
And to all of you who have thanked me for saving and posting those quotes.
You are welcome.
NBER is now working on the question of whether paint actually dries
Here's a good one I used to hear often from the CNBC dingbats:
Service eCONomies are more resilient.
HAHAAHAHAHA!
Ya Seb - you weren't anymore 'wrong' than a lot of folks like myself who had been calling it since Jesus was a baby.
The balance was and still is a good thing - don't be a stranger around these parts.
Wow, so all this time we've been in a recession? WHOCOODANODE! I am glad I waited for the official announcement, you know, just to be sure. I wish there was a place on the internet where I could have found out sooner about these important economic issues.
and we need the same media that held them in high esteem, to embarrass and shame them.
The media should also be publicly shamed and then fired forever. Make Cramer the poster child of financial idiocy and lies.
Cheer leading is not news reporting.
CNBC is a sham. So is Bloomberg.
OT re: Sebastian and recession timing
I always tried to give Sebastian the credit he was due, for his reasonable and fair opinions. We need balance, and I hope he continues to speak his mind.
Eric
...."And to all of you who have thanked me for saving and posting those quotes"
Thank you Joe.......
The whole financial industry is a sham. CNBC and Bloomberg are just part of their PR team.
Cramer is an idiot. I did switch and get a package for Bloomberg. Much better, an interview lasts more than 90 seconds.Plus the package I had to buy has two channels of COPS.
Thank you Joe. That was a lot to read through. Looks like you hold grudges for a long time...
I hope to stay on your good side.
Yen rally continues. SP 840 area interesting also.
"...grave yards are full of people who once thought they were indispensable..."
Charles de Gaulle
Something like: The cemeteries are full of indispensable people.
Seb: I saw you post a few weeks ago, and I admire that you were up front and public about your wrong call on the economy. I always value opposing viewpoints so don't stop posting. Curious, in hindsight, why do you think your model didn't work this time, (or what economic indicators would you have looked at differently given perfect hindsight)?
Pavel Chichikov(Unrated) writes:
"...grave yards are full of people who once thought they were indispensable..."
Charles de Gaulle
Something like: The cemeteries are full of indispensable people.
Pavel Chichikov | 12.01.08 - 1:17 pm | #
And de Gaulle should know - some of them are his neighbors.
[BTW I knew de Gaulle said that - I was too lazy to get the exact quote & citation - my bad. One of the best quotes ever though - especially for those with really 'big heads'...]
Average Joe said: "Nice apology Sebastian....although since you didn't take anyone's money for your investment skill (I assume), you don't need to apologize."
Thanks, but I certainly am obligated to apologize for my condescending attitude over the past couple of years towards the "recession-callers" here.
"...This was the easiest most obvious call in financial history...."
On this point I have to disagree. It clearly wasn't, and I'm speaking as one of the people who caught on early to the dot.com bust several years ago. It was obvious to the people for whom it was obvious, but not Greenspan, the Fed, derivatives traders, investment banks, homebuilders, mainstream economists, stock market analysts/strategists, the majority of mutual fund managers etc., etc.
It wasn't just the industry spokesmen, personal-agenda-driven shills and mindless permabulls who got caught off-guard, but also serious, data-driven people, too.
Sebastia
Both developments worrisome - consumer credit contraction and industrial output contraction. The retail economy runs on consumer credit. I know that's obvious to a small child, but when I see people paying for their muffin and coffee at Whole Foods with a credit card, I start to wonder how precarious their financial situation is. Extrapolation makes you wonder about the whole country.
Deere stands behind every product except its manure spreader.
Whitney:
"While just over 70 per cent of US households have access to credit cards, 90 per cent of these people use credit cards as a cash-flow management vehicle, or revolve payments at least once a year. While the credit card market is small relative to the mortgage market, it has grown to play a key role in consumer liquidity. Declining liquidity here will have disastrous effects on consumer spending and the economy"
Love the quotes Average Joe! Keep up the "good" (well-intention?) work.
ummm why is the ten year bond falling off the table, now at 2.7?
demand spiking?
leibnitz didn't get credit for calculus, newton did. newton had more important friends.
I agree that the market crash and the housing crash were about the most obvious calls imaginable, except maybe dot.crash.
most anyone disassociated from the mass media knew what was coming.
the current debacle was readily apparent in 2004 to anyone who had common sense and an understanding of arithmatic.