Every time I read these reports the only thing I can think of is "Who is buying a home these days?"
It just boggles my mind. Even with stupid loans to stupid people on the decline, are there that many stupid people with money still buying homes? Shouldn't they have parted ways with their money long ago?
A move by the Bank of Japan is out of the question,'' said Takehiro Sato, chief economist at Morgan Stanley Securities Japan Ltd. in Tokyo.A cloud is hanging over the domestic and global economy.''
crashcadia, I completely agree with you. It just boggles my mind that some folks are still buying at near-peak price levels. Do they read the papers? Perhaps they see this as a buying opportunity, perhaps they are relatives of Sebastian, I don't know.
We sold our Silicon Valley home in a nice, desirable (but not rich)neighborhood in Los Gatos back in Spring 2005. Despite all that's gone on, prices there are up by 10-15% since we sold!! Tear-downs are still selling for $1.2M!!! People just don't understand what's coming.
Lack of skepticism in the land of the DotCom bust is amazing.... But this week I saw for the first time on foreclosureradar.com, a pre-foreclosure in this nice neighborhood.
If true, August sales can only be described as a vicious hammering for the LA REIC.
I suspect there were similar declines in other markets that depend on jumbo loans, though LA will have been hit hardest because so many mortgages firms were based in that area.
This is not just in Southern California. Anyone who was access to MLS in bay area will tell you that August sales where 60% off August 2004 levels. Currently September sales look even worse. I suspect September might be down 70% off 2004 level. This is pretty serious.
Thanks RE Bear.
The last Posting of the Installment debt showed 10% Yoy increase(Barrons). I am
looking for a bigger increase this time. 15% increase in installment debt is supposed to be ominous.
Some of my co-workers are still buying. Young lawyers just out of law school with a good salary.
Some of them know there is downside risk on prices. Some of them know they should not sign up for a variable rate mortgage in this environment. Most of them, even the ones who know the foregoing, still say "Oh well, I got a five year hybrid arm and I can sell or refinance in a few years." Five years is a very long time to them.
I have noticed that many people will buy whatever they want, when they want it ,as long as they think they can afford it.Price level fluctuations are never an issue.
Every time I read these reports the only thing I can think of is "Who is buying a home these days?"
Well, I have a friend who just purchased an almost new home for $1.1m, not too far from us (he moved closer, which means we'll probably meet more often now).
He perfectly understand that his home will drop another $300k in price. So what? The quality of life now is more important than losing $300k, he can afford that. Two year-end bonuses will make the difference.
It is definitely entertaining watching denial crack in LA. I was sure getting tired of listening to these snobs say it won't happen here. Well guess what...ITS HAPPENING! An observation... it seems with this last bout of data many Los Angelenos that I talk to are coming to accept this down turn more quickly than they did in say Orange County. I guess the early 90's are fresh in people's memories.
The sales volumes are even more alarming when put into historical perspective. For July (latest mo avail) the San Fernando Valley had 617 single family sales. The lowest level hit in the 90s for July was 670 in July '92. All through 2001-2005 each July had sales over 1200. Each of the last four months has been the lowest total sales for that month since tracking begins- 1984.
The August sales should be maybe about 70% off the levels of '01-'05. At some point it must begin to dawn on sellers that they are not going to wait this market out.
I am amazed when I hear talk of taking a home of the market to wait for conditions to improve. Are they prepared to wait 10 years to get their price?
Since we are told, and I believe it so, that this is a consumer driven economy...what happens when (if)the credit card game and the MEW game loose steam right before the Thanksgiving and Christmas buying season which occasions more than 30 percent of all retail sales! All the legs knocked out from under. Can you feel the fear?
California misses all time high default notices by 102:
La Jolla, CA.--Lenders sent California homeowners the highest number of mortgage default notices in over a decade last quarter, the result of flat or falling prices, anemic sales and a market struggling with the excesses of the 2004-2005 home buying frenzy, a real estate information service reported.
Lenders filed 53,943 Notices of Default (NoDs) during the April-through-June period. That was up 15.4 percent from 46,760 for the previous quarter, and up 158.0 percent from 20,909 for second-quarter 2006, according to DataQuick Information Systems of La Jolla.
Last quarter's default level was the highest since 54,045 NoDs were recorded statewide in fourth-quarter 1996. Defaults peaked in first-quarter 1996 at 61,541. A low of 12,417 was reached in third-quarter 2004. An average of 34,172 NoDs have been filed quarterly since 1992, when DataQuick's NoD statistics begin. [link]
I'm guessing the third and fourth quarters are gonna set a record for the year too.
Meanwhile, here in 'it's different here Oregon', there are two 700k homes for sale next door to me. They tore down a perfectly good, 50 year old house on a half acre, and squeezed these two monstrosities on the lot. No privacy.
Today was Open House, 12 to 4. I was outside working on my yard all day. Two cars showed up, one of them the realtor.
What a surprise. I didn't think that even one car would show up.
We've been told, over and over in this world, that big changes happen slowly. And this is true. But the thing about change is not it's not always recognized while it's in process; in fact, not usually.
So the final death rattle of an institution, a regime, a market, sometimes seems so sudden. Because by that point there's nothing left but the outer shell of the thing; the inner structure has been rotting away for years.
50 percent drop in sales year over year? This isn't the beginning of the end. This is more like the end of the end. The central supports have collapse and the building's on its way down.
I find it infuriating when they insist on trumpeting the median price, as if the median when there were 1200 listings and 1200 sales in a month means the same thing as now when there were 8000 listings and 600 sales.
The "median" is only the median sales price of the homes that sold that month, it tells you NOTHING about what is selling. Even CAR and the local boards admit that the median is only going up due to market mix.
what happens when (if)the credit card game and the MEW game loose steam right before the Thanksgiving and Christmas buying season which occasions more than 30 percent of all retail sales!
mock turtle,
You will see retailers slashing prices to move stuff out the door. The last thing that a retailer wants is to open the doors on Jan 2nd and still have 50% of his holiday merchandise collecting dust. The retailers will slash and burn, and possibly shutter any stores that did especially poorly. With respect to that point, I would be keeping an eye on Kmart and TRU.
Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground.Hard times ahead for everyone now,and dr dobbs,were you perhaps referring to our regime as well?
edgar, I plotted the DataQuick California foreclosure activity data here. It's a stunning graph!
BTW, when I predicted record foreclosure activity in 2007, I took some heat in the comments ... for some reasons those people haven't been posting in the comments lately.
Vader,
I liquided all my apartment buildings
back in 2003-2004. No regrets because
I put some of that money in Gold and some in Put--options on Homebuilders.
If the lenders had not come-up with all that creative financing back in
2004-2006, No-one would be getting laid-off now(i.e. the downturn would have been managable) Now I am not so sure.
I realize we have the War to finance,
but people like Mozzilo took advantage of the situation to their own ends. I hope they get what they deserve.
A bear whose predictions come true just as he gets laid off."
Yep. That's one reason why this bear sold his home -- to protect my family if/when that happens. There's a lot of risk owning a home in a collapsing market.
There's a comforting belief on the part of housing market bulls: lots of us housing bears represent pent up demand, sitting here waiting for buying opportunities.
I don't know how many folks sitting on the sidelines will be jumping in anytime soon with these kinds of numbers...not without some serious price drops.
"There's a comforting belief on the part of housing market bulls: lots of us housing bears represent pent up demand, sitting here waiting for buying opportunities."
If that many informed people were floating about, there wouldn't have been a bubble in the first place.
Did I read correctly in a previous thread that you had just recently lost your job? If so, I hope you find a new one soon.
As much as I want to see a return to a "normal" RE market, I'm aware that there is going to be a lot of pain for a great many people involved. While I have no feelings of pity for those who took advantage of others and are now losing their jobs, there will be lots of collateral damage, and for them I do feel sorry. It's easy to talk about the economy in an abstract way ("unemployment is up this month"), but those are real people losing their jobs (or about to).
Yossarian: I'm on the other side of the PDX metro area from you (Beaverton) and the number of forsale signs just keeps amazing me. Things were supposed to be different here with the Urban Growth Boundary and the "cheapest urban area on the West coast" - well, it looks like things are different here all right, it's just about a six months to a year different from what's happening in CA. Makes sense, as a lot of money migrates up here from CA when people sell their expensive houses down there and buy a bigger place up here - well, since there isn't much selling going on in CA anymore those 'equity locusts' (as we like to call them) are becoming scarce.
IMHO, had our betters, held the line on credit, then allow prices to reflect wages rather than the amount of credit a worker can get, we would be a lot better off.
By allowing easy credit, the market indicator that things were not good was circumvented. No Money for college borrow it. No money for medical care, borrow it. No money for housing borrow it.
So RE agents, doctors and educators are not affected by the problems of the common classes and keep the current crop of our betters in office.
Had consumption followed wages, then a heap of folks would have been pressuring the government to do things different, because their income would be affected. At the moment, it is the credit card company's problem or the mortgage holder's problem.
"Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground.Hard times ahead for everyone now,and dr dobbs,were you perhaps referring to our regime as well?"
Not directly; but as Bill Clinton said when campaigning against Bush I in recessionary times, "It's the economy, stupid!"
"Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground
Getting my Cessna SkyHawk 172P manual out ( just kidding, I've memorized this and it just rolls off ) - its MASTER SWITCH OFF, DOORS UNLATCHED, TAIL LOW -
All I can say is that in my little corner of LA in the Pico/Robertson section just south of Beverly Hills, houses are still selling for top of the market prices. Just last week a 2br/2ba 1400 square foot 1930 house sold for $875,000. That same house five years ago would've traded for $225,000-$250,000. Oh, and I rent a 2BR/1BA 1930-built house`1000 square feet, four houses down for $2200/month. Go figure!
A friend who lives in New York City tells me that its different there (Manhattan). Prices are not falling and he thinks (absent a Wall Street recession) that prices will continue to rise and that real estate remains a good investment. His theory is that supply is limited and co-op governing boards keep out speculators and the sub-prime riff raff. I remain skeptical because the bubble seems to have affected real estate the world over. Why should NYC be immune? It might take longer, but sooner or later they have to feel the pinch. If prices drop in New Jersey and Connecticut will people pay an extra million to live in Manhattan? Is Manhattan that wonderful that its worth any price?
... Otherwise the consumer finds another source of cash and keeps on going. vader
Let me know when you find a new source of cash for us consumers. MEW and wages are tapped out on this homefront but if I don't buy some more stuff pretty soon, the economy will surely tank.
Maybe you can invent transmutation of toxic waste loans into gold? Oh, wait, been there, done that, didn't quite work out, did it?
And your next assignment if you're willing to accept is to plot CA trustees deeds recorded (foreclosures). My guess is that you already have and I simply missed it. Anyhow, the referenced Dataquick article showed that CA 2Q foreclosures have increased 800% YoY and the 17.4k foreclosures are the most for 2Q going back to 1988.
Seems to me this would also be an impressive plot.
Today, bond yields show that Lehman is considered more risky than Colombia, where the government has been waging a four-decade war with drug-funded rebels and one in 10 members of the workforce is unemployed. Colombia is rated BBB- by S&P, the lowest investment-grade rating, and carries a Ba2 junk rating from Moody's Investor's Service.
FFDIC: I agree. Enronification of the financial system. The bankers were thinking they were so clever with their SIVs, but it turned out the magic money machine wasn't so magic once everybody had to own up to their obligations. Off-balance-sheet is a systemic flaw in the accounting/legal system, effectively unaccounted for obligations via "cheating". Is it used for anything legitimate? SIVs rolling back on to bank balance sheets should add some serious trouble to the liquidity problem. Awfully interesting how these complex systems are so non-linear.
Doc -
It would be nice to know how many bank examiners are trained to look into this stuff? FDIC is hiring a new army of grade 7 examiners with starting pay I'm guessing at 40K (check out the FDIC's career on-line site). And, these recent college grads are expected to go up against buff badass billionaire bankers. I don't think so.
"A friend who lives in New York City tells me that its different there (Manhattan). Prices are not falling and he thinks (absent a Wall Street recession) that prices will continue to rise and that real estate remains a good investment. "
I live in Manhattan and as you point out, NJ, CT, even Queens and Brooklyn provide a buffer for Manhattan's prices. All said, the infamous median prices keeps on going up. I live close to 4 realties, Corcoran and the like. there is stuff in their windows that's being sitting there for more than a year! Seller's anchoring/denial keeps on surprising me as prices are not being reduced.
Coops used to represent 75% of the supply but since 2000, all the new developments had been condos. So much is being built that both accounted for the same number of transactions last year. Also the requirements on coops are strict for outsiders, not for insiders. It's not a transparent process and got relaxed lately. So it cannot provide the protection that used to (this was explained by Jonathan Miller, as I also thought that coops will prevent a big drop in prices).
"Is Manhattan that wonderful that its worth any price?" not in my opinion. i'm very happy living here, but i could be happy in a trailer in oklahoma too.
if wall street has a couple of bad years not only bonuses and lay offs are going to hit the city badly. also city revenues (public employment) and indirect jobs (like fancy restaurants-bars-clubs) are going to feel the pain.
DH: you are a kick ass investor! congrats!!!
all said, i would like to know to what extent the availability of jumbo loans has been hurt. that's key for nyc, california, florida, ...
U.S. Housing Collapse May Bypass Some Markets Since the U.S. real estate market is composed of hundreds of smaller metro markets -- several of which were not as severely affected by the bubble or subprime mortgages -- not all of the news is gloomy.
Today I passed a very dejected looking sign spinner in WeHo, sitting under a tree taking a break. I wish I'd had a camera. This could be the new Time cover for 2007.
Now it's just a race to the bottom, as every 2 bed 1 toilet bungalow in the city goes begging for $600K, $500k, 300K and on DOWN.
Well, the only thing I would add is that the Yen is trying to weaken this morning, which to me means that big players are going to try to play the juice game this morning: juice the indices with some free money from Japan and see if they can get the momentum suckers to go along.
But I daresay they will sell into it the second they can. Those borrowed yen are finger-burning hot.
I completely agree with you. It just boggles my mind that some folks are still buying at near-peak price levels. Do they read the papers? Perhaps they see this as a buying opportunity, perhaps they are relatives of Sebastian for sure. My friend at web design company too earlier have faced a similar fate so its really heart rendering...
"I am thinking the next bubble being "live aboard boats".
- Funny. My wife and I just started looking into renting a houseboat for a week to see if we like the lifestyle.
Things to consider going into a period of increasingly worse economic news and fundamentally deteriorating conditions-
1) More leverage than anytime in our history.
2) The greatest concentration of financially engineered, "illiquid" assets held by IB's, hedge funds, and conventional banks across the globe.
3) A Fed which is dramatically behind the curve.
4) Confidience levels that are rapidly deteriorating.
5) The all-or-nothing move into Treasuries.
6) A Housing situation which will likely deteriorate into 2009.
7) Default rates on HY which have nowhere to go but up.
8) Peak corporate earnings.
As this situation takes hold, the need to liquify illiquid assets will increase. The liklihood of a repeat of the August scare is pronounced and the potential for a much larger problem exists.
The commercial paper fiasco poses serious risks, the crisis of confidence that could potentially result would be devestating.
You read that many are touting this asset class versus another in this environment, the funny thing is that they have very recently been proven completely wrong in most cases. The leverage in the system is so great that August showed that hedged strategies were child's play and useless.
That said, tak away all of the "noise".
A step back shows you specifcally what lies ahead, a very difficult period.
A fact that nobody seems to be discussing as of yet is the potential for unfunded pension liabilities to increase dramatically, this due to the move in interest rates, not assuming any decrease on their equity holdings which could add to the underfunded status of some plans.
These potential shortfalls will need to be eliminated and could further stress balance sheets going into a slowing economy.
Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground.Hard times ahead for everyone now,and dr dobbs,were you perhaps referring to our regime as well?
So in that analogy, we're the automated alarm that you hear earlier in the tape saying "WHOOOP WHOOOP PULL UP! PULL UP!" just before the pilot says, "Can you turn off that damn alarm?"
When I see reports like this, my mind imagines the sounds from an old WWII film clip, such as a B-36 getting hit with anti-aircraft fire and spiralling into the ground in a huge fireball.
risk capital, another bullseye IMO. All I can add is that we need to be mindful of both private sector and governmental pensions.....tax shortfalls, earmarks...all that boring stuff that puts people to sleep.....
"Did you see the game?" "What's Paris Hilton up to today?"
600 New
480 Price Change (lower)
130 Sold (lots of credits, reductions, and CONFORMING level prices)
200 Expired
Been my feeling for quite some time: we gotta roll these prices back to yr2000 levels. If the financing stays under $417k and you price aggressively, you can likely sell. Higher end stuff, can take a while, but yeah. It's that mediocre but priced btwn $500 - $1m stuff that, eeeeehhhhh, who knows?
central scrutinizer: I'll be a bit of a pedant here and point out that the B-36 first flew in 1946, so not too many were shot down during the second world war. John's B-36 Peacemaker Page
"Why should NYC be immune? It might take longer, but sooner or later they have to feel the pinch. "
NYC will be the last to fall. They're the very epicenter of the bubble. Hell, the NY Times will still be publishing pablum about the Loyfstoyles of the Rich and Famous long after the rest of the country is eating out of cat food cans.
In other words, don't look to NYC for any indicators of reality. In fact, I think 50 years from now, Manhattan will be the world's most exclusive gated community.
Ah we were boring in August in Colorado Springs, our sales were only down 21.1%. We are on pace to sell about 800-900 new homes. Unfortunately there were 3000 or so permits given out.
Risk Capital - Anyone who has looked at the ratio of financial corporate profits to all other profits over the last few years realizes just how unpleasant things may get!
FFDIC - I'm waiting to find out more details about Norlarco. Looks like they thought the Brians' business plan was a no-brainer!
The FDIC needs to get the middle-aged talent back into the game ASAP. The college kids don't have the experience to handle this.
Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?
The alternative scenario has a sharp falloff in August-October home sales. Then, a year or more of stalemate, with low resale activity, HBs going bust, and prices drifting down slowly in many markets.
This can only happen if lenders don't flood the market with REOs. But one of the strangest things so far has been lenders' willingness to let REOs pile up.
How could Countrywide just keep collecting so many REOs without trying more aggressively to sell them? Neglected homes rot away.
What's holding them back from doing the apparently rational thing?
Answer that question and you may have the answer to what happens next. (A slow drift down would not be a happy scene for the economy or REIC.)
most of the agencies and state banking departments do not have the front-line talent to perform thorough exams of problem institutions. how do you think a situation like coast bank happened. inexperienced examiners coupled with strict limits on the amount of time that can be spent on-site performing an exam. the bonus system for executives is calibrated to time savings, not performing an effective exam. they will mouth some BS that an examiner can expand the scope of an exam if necessary but in reality, it is a zero-sum game. if you use hours here, they must come out of somewhere else.
some have speculated that an examiner with less than 12 years experience does not have the ability to identify a problem situation as they have only been trained to do "drive-by" examinations. we have seen this movie before and we all know how it ends.
In the Northeast, 28 year-olds with a good Big-4 background in audit can easily land jobs for 80-100k with huge prospects for growth. These are the ones the govt needs and will never get.
"Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?"
Then there will be no sales.
Reprice, reprice, reprice! Until that happens there will be no end to it - true in credit markets, house markets, in EVERY overpriced market. The Fed can't change it; Congress can't change it.... overpriced things must reprice or they will not sell.
Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?
i believe i read that the abx implies something like a 13% drop in home prices, and you should always believe what subprime traders think about things.
How could Countrywide just keep collecting so many REOs without trying more aggressively to sell them? Neglected homes rot away.
What's holding them back from doing the apparently rational thing?
At a guess, there are two factors:
1.) They're carrying the homes on their books at the mose recent appraisal. Actually selling at market means putting losses on the books.
2.) They simply don't have the manpower to choke through the backlog. Telling the big bosses that they have to hire more people to realize more losses has got to be a tough sell.
NYC will be hit by a fall in financial jobs and year-end bonuses in early 2008 (these make up a huge % of the local economy on Manhattan), plus there are a lot of new condo projects finishing up or still under construction.
Real estate people there think foreign buyers will keep things going because the dollar is cheap. But why would a European buy a depreciating asset valued in a depreciating currency, just because the current currency exchange rate makes it somewhat cheaper than it was 6 months ago?
Re the LA stats, I can only say wow...
Phoenix and Las Vegas must be just as bad or worse. And Florida, already reeling...
Why is it surprsing that some people are still buying homes? Even when times are bad, it's hard to make a market stop completely. Generally it takes something on the order of a sustained Allied bombing campaign or Nigerian-government-level corruption, though even that usually allows some black-market activity. People will continue to buy and sell, no matter what.
The New York market will see some trouble in the next year or two, as a very large number of new condos are expected to come on the market--they're still building at a fast pace. We can only hope that Ratner's Atlantic Yards project ends up as the world's most expensive public housing project.
"Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?"
In bubbly California, in my 'desirable area' there has been widespread drama pricing of 20-30% easy. If you're expecting country wide re-pricing it'll take longer as conditions vary quite a bit.
It's like expecting a room full of people who all had heart attacks to start eating less fat. Some will and slim down quickly, others take longer, the average therefore moves slowly.
"A fact that nobody seems to be discussing as of yet is the potential for unfunded pension liabilities to increase dramatically, this due to the move in interest rates, not assuming any decrease on their equity holdings which could add to the underfunded status of some plans."
This will hit the public sector hardest, especially state/local government entities.
I believe the poster child for unfunded pension liabilities and for state/local government insolvency will be the same -- New Jersey.
I believe NJ already is technically bankrupt.
We live in a mobile society, especially among the growing numbers of seniors on fixed incomes. They will move away from high-tax states. Ultimately, for every dollar of higher taxes that New Jersey is forced to raise, the state will lose two dollars of revenue.
There's many ways that New Jersey can mask or postpone insolvency. But eventually, it will be a fiasco and take down the municipal bond insurers, too.
I was seeing reports saying that jobless claim remains low enough to indicate that the US job market is still tight.
I was just thinking aloud why there is such a huge discrepanies between jobless claims and employment data.
It seems to me that maybe the reason is that many that are laid off are relatively high income earners (bankers, lenders, financial engineers, engineers etc) and may not find the jobless claim benefits worth the trouble.
On the other hands, if jobs lost are burger flippers and waiters or Walmart cashiers, they would have filed for jobless claims quite promptly.
How much is the exact weekly amount received for filing as jobless. Maybe someone can enlighten me.
Update on Asia markets-
The hedgies have made a strong push on the equity markets in the last 2 weeks, and another effort a few hours ago before monday markets closed. Not likely to give up their (long equity and short Yen) positions and fold until credit or economic environment in the US/ Europe get worse or when corporate profit start taking a hit. However, I suspect that when things start to unfold, it could get ugly fast, and not without a few hedge fund casualties to get the margin calls going....
I suspect many hedgies are holding on like boiling frogs even as the Yen strengthen by nearly 10% over the past month against the US$. Some may be quite close to the edge of the cliff.
Phoenix resale market report should be out either today or tomorrow, I doubt even their pollyannas will be able to drink that number pretty. It should go below 4k, which would be 60% off August 05 volume.
A big condo complex in Tempe is only 50% sold, in all likelihood their phase 3 won't get built. Other planned projects where land was cleared haven't progressed at all, and will never get built as funding has been pulled.
"NYC will be hit by a fall in financial jobs and year-end bonuses in early 2008 (these make up a huge % of the local economy on Manhattan), plus there are a lot of new condo projects finishing up or still under construction."
For a family with children, the cost of living in Manhattan, compared to the best close-in suburbs, is about 20-30% higher. The components of higher cost are: 1) real estate; 2) city income tax; 3) private school tuitions. Since quality-of-life and commutes are comparable whether you live in Manhattan or close suburbs, living in Manhattan is a luxury that affluent families can afford in good times.
Manhattan real estate prices = still high.
Quality close-in suburb prices = deteriorating.
As soon as the economy softens, you will see many Manhatan families forced out to the suburbs. I've talked to some of them, and they see it coming.
Just the other night my husband and I watched a program on the Discovery channel on Mega Cruise Ship building in Finland. We are talking the largest and most elabrate cruise ships in the world, all destined for the US market. Finland can compete and build these incredibaly large vessels( the other major cruise ship building countrys are France and Italy)and provide high quality jobs because they have nationalized medicine. Per capita income for Finland versus the US in dollars for 2006 is Finland $37,178; US $33,050.
When are our politicians going to make this a must issue. When are Americans going to realize that there standard of living is dependent upon nationalized medicine.
Trying to grow an economy on housing and high cost low value added financial products and credit just isn't going to work anymore. We need to make products that people are going to buy. And our young people can make a living on.
So what did they say about the malpractice industry and the tort liability system in Finland? Speaking of jobs, seems like there was a time when lots of Norteamericanos worked in construction.
How much is the exact weekly amount received for filing as jobless. Maybe someone can enlighten me.
Every state has different unemployment benefit amounts. I live in Ohio and the benefit here is 50% of what you made during the last 12 months. You also must have worked at least 6 of the last 12 months and not had a claim for at least a year. The maximum benefit is around $450 per week and you can claim up to 26 weeks of benefits. Unemployment is not available for CEO's and officers of companies as well as those self employed who receive 1099's. I think most real estate agents are self employed and would not be eligible for benefits in Ohio. So are a lot of the roofers, plumbers, electricians, heating and cooling guys. I am sure a lot of these workers are either out of work or are working less than a year ago, but are unable to file for benefits so the unemployment rate looks good when in reality it's not.
If someone from another state has more to add, I'd be interested in hearing about your benefit program.
Hurray
first
It's been a long time coming. The Bulls were worthy opponents, The taste of victory is bittersweet.
Every time I read these reports the only thing I can think of is "Who is buying a home these days?"
It just boggles my mind. Even with stupid loans to stupid people on the decline, are there that many stupid people with money still buying homes? Shouldn't they have parted ways with their money long ago?
My brain hurts.
Japan's Economy Contracts More-Than-Expected 1.2%
Japan's Economy Contracts a More-Than-Expected 1.2% (Update6) - Bloomberg.com
A move by the Bank of Japan is out of the question,'' said Takehiro Sato, chief economist at Morgan Stanley Securities Japan Ltd. in Tokyo.A cloud is hanging over the domestic and global economy.''
Something about that word.
Collapse.
The twin towers just collapsed.
The stock market just collapsed.
There was an earthquake and hundreds of homes collapsed.
Your mother in law came down stairs and just collapsed on the floor.
The economy is collapsing.
The persons heart just collapsed and they died instantly.
Collapse.
Interesting word it is.
I hope you have your puts ready.
The Consumer credit tomorrow will be
HORRENDOUS
CR,
Will you consider doing a plot of
YOY growth in consumer credit VS
recessions?
DH,
Recessions are not marked.
Briefing.com: Consumer Credit
pjt,
It is an interesting word. It is even worse than sinking. It doesn't even give you a chance to hear the music stop playing.
DH, I'll take a look.
Best to all.
crashcadia, I completely agree with you. It just boggles my mind that some folks are still buying at near-peak price levels. Do they read the papers? Perhaps they see this as a buying opportunity, perhaps they are relatives of Sebastian, I don't know.
We sold our Silicon Valley home in a nice, desirable (but not rich)neighborhood in Los Gatos back in Spring 2005. Despite all that's gone on, prices there are up by 10-15% since we sold!! Tear-downs are still selling for $1.2M!!! People just don't understand what's coming.
Lack of skepticism in the land of the DotCom bust is amazing.... But this week I saw for the first time on foreclosureradar.com, a pre-foreclosure in this nice neighborhood.
If true, August sales can only be described as a vicious hammering for the LA REIC.
I suspect there were similar declines in other markets that depend on jumbo loans, though LA will have been hit hardest because so many mortgages firms were based in that area.
Calculated Risk,
This is not just in Southern California. Anyone who was access to MLS in bay area will tell you that August sales where 60% off August 2004 levels. Currently September sales look even worse. I suspect September might be down 70% off 2004 level. This is pretty serious.
Thanks RE Bear.
The last Posting of the Installment debt showed 10% Yoy increase(Barrons). I am
looking for a bigger increase this time. 15% increase in installment debt is supposed to be ominous.
Some of my co-workers are still buying. Young lawyers just out of law school with a good salary.
Some of them know there is downside risk on prices. Some of them know they should not sign up for a variable rate mortgage in this environment. Most of them, even the ones who know the foregoing, still say "Oh well, I got a five year hybrid arm and I can sell or refinance in a few years." Five years is a very long time to them.
I have noticed that many people will buy whatever they want, when they want it ,as long as they think they can afford it.Price level fluctuations are never an issue.
Is there a behavioral finance expert in the room?
Well, I have a friend who just purchased an almost new home for $1.1m, not too far from us (he moved closer, which means we'll probably meet more often now).
He perfectly understand that his home will drop another $300k in price. So what? The quality of life now is more important than losing $300k, he can afford that. Two year-end bonuses will make the difference.
It is definitely entertaining watching denial crack in LA. I was sure getting tired of listening to these snobs say it won't happen here. Well guess what...ITS HAPPENING! An observation... it seems with this last bout of data many Los Angelenos that I talk to are coming to accept this down turn more quickly than they did in say Orange County. I guess the early 90's are fresh in people's memories.
Where's deb? She's usually got the first hand, "in the trenches" take on this.
theroxylandr,
Folks like your friend will be fine I guess... As long as recession doesn't eliminate his bonus, or worse, his job.
The sales volumes are even more alarming when put into historical perspective. For July (latest mo avail) the San Fernando Valley had 617 single family sales. The lowest level hit in the 90s for July was 670 in July '92. All through 2001-2005 each July had sales over 1200. Each of the last four months has been the lowest total sales for that month since tracking begins- 1984.
Sales Data by Month
The August sales should be maybe about 70% off the levels of '01-'05. At some point it must begin to dawn on sellers that they are not going to wait this market out.
I am amazed when I hear talk of taking a home of the market to wait for conditions to improve. Are they prepared to wait 10 years to get their price?
Since we are told, and I believe it so, that this is a consumer driven economy...what happens when (if)the credit card game and the MEW game loose steam right before the Thanksgiving and Christmas buying season which occasions more than 30 percent of all retail sales! All the legs knocked out from under. Can you feel the fear?
Bittersweet
A bear whose predictions come true just as he gets laid off.
California misses all time high default notices by 102:
La Jolla, CA.--Lenders sent California homeowners the highest number of mortgage default notices in over a decade last quarter, the result of flat or falling prices, anemic sales and a market struggling with the excesses of the 2004-2005 home buying frenzy, a real estate information service reported.
Lenders filed 53,943 Notices of Default (NoDs) during the April-through-June period. That was up 15.4 percent from 46,760 for the previous quarter, and up 158.0 percent from 20,909 for second-quarter 2006, according to DataQuick Information Systems of La Jolla.
Last quarter's default level was the highest since 54,045 NoDs were recorded statewide in fourth-quarter 1996. Defaults peaked in first-quarter 1996 at 61,541. A low of 12,417 was reached in third-quarter 2004. An average of 34,172 NoDs have been filed quarterly since 1992, when DataQuick's NoD statistics begin. [link]
I'm guessing the third and fourth quarters are gonna set a record for the year too.
mock turtle
Only if the legs are truly knocked out. Otherwise the consumer finds another source of cash and keeps on going.
Meanwhile, here in 'it's different here Oregon', there are two 700k homes for sale next door to me. They tore down a perfectly good, 50 year old house on a half acre, and squeezed these two monstrosities on the lot. No privacy.
Today was Open House, 12 to 4. I was outside working on my yard all day. Two cars showed up, one of them the realtor.
What a surprise. I didn't think that even one car would show up.
Sorry, 8000+. edit. Still, 2007 will give 1996 a run for its money, 2008 should blow it out of the water.
Forgot to mention, the Open House was in West Linn, 'Tree City', a very nice neighborhood, where 'prices never go down'.
"Something about that word.
Collapse."
We've been told, over and over in this world, that big changes happen slowly. And this is true. But the thing about change is not it's not always recognized while it's in process; in fact, not usually.
So the final death rattle of an institution, a regime, a market, sometimes seems so sudden. Because by that point there's nothing left but the outer shell of the thing; the inner structure has been rotting away for years.
50 percent drop in sales year over year? This isn't the beginning of the end. This is more like the end of the end. The central supports have collapse and the building's on its way down.
deb
thanks for the excellent graph
I find it infuriating when they insist on trumpeting the median price, as if the median when there were 1200 listings and 1200 sales in a month means the same thing as now when there were 8000 listings and 600 sales.
The "median" is only the median sales price of the homes that sold that month, it tells you NOTHING about what is selling. Even CAR and the local boards admit that the median is only going up due to market mix.
what happens when (if)the credit card game and the MEW game loose steam right before the Thanksgiving and Christmas buying season which occasions more than 30 percent of all retail sales!
mock turtle,
You will see retailers slashing prices to move stuff out the door. The last thing that a retailer wants is to open the doors on Jan 2nd and still have 50% of his holiday merchandise collecting dust. The retailers will slash and burn, and possibly shutter any stores that did especially poorly. With respect to that point, I would be keeping an eye on Kmart and TRU.
Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground.Hard times ahead for everyone now,and dr dobbs,were you perhaps referring to our regime as well?
LINK Fixed, CR.
edgar, I plotted the DataQuick California foreclosure activity data here. It's a stunning graph!
BTW, when I predicted record foreclosure activity in 2007, I took some heat in the comments ... for some reasons those people haven't been posting in the comments lately.
Best to all.
Edited By Siteowner
Vader,
I liquided all my apartment buildings
back in 2003-2004. No regrets because
I put some of that money in Gold and some in Put--options on Homebuilders.
If the lenders had not come-up with all that creative financing back in
2004-2006, No-one would be getting laid-off now(i.e. the downturn would have been managable) Now I am not so sure.
I realize we have the War to finance,
but people like Mozzilo took advantage of the situation to their own ends. I hope they get what they deserve.
Vader said,
"Bittersweet
A bear whose predictions come true just as he gets laid off."
Yep. That's one reason why this bear sold his home -- to protect my family if/when that happens. There's a lot of risk owning a home in a collapsing market.
CR,
It's lonely at the top. You know that
better than anyone.
The smarter you are, the more idiots you have to deal with.(Corollery)
need i go on?
CR-
Bad link, I think, for the foreclosure graph.
Thanks for such an insightful blog!
There's a comforting belief on the part of housing market bulls: lots of us housing bears represent pent up demand, sitting here waiting for buying opportunities.
I don't know how many folks sitting on the sidelines will be jumping in anytime soon with these kinds of numbers...not without some serious price drops.
deb,
Thanks for your insight -- always appreciated!
CR, I sent you and Tanta an email regarding the Weiss report to the Fed.
Hope it was properly addressed
"There's a comforting belief on the part of housing market bulls: lots of us housing bears represent pent up demand, sitting here waiting for buying opportunities."
If that many informed people were floating about, there wouldn't have been a bubble in the first place.
vader,
Did I read correctly in a previous thread that you had just recently lost your job? If so, I hope you find a new one soon.
As much as I want to see a return to a "normal" RE market, I'm aware that there is going to be a lot of pain for a great many people involved. While I have no feelings of pity for those who took advantage of others and are now losing their jobs, there will be lots of collateral damage, and for them I do feel sorry. It's easy to talk about the economy in an abstract way ("unemployment is up this month"), but those are real people losing their jobs (or about to).
Anyway, sorry to go all sappy and all.
Yossarian: I'm on the other side of the PDX metro area from you (Beaverton) and the number of forsale signs just keeps amazing me. Things were supposed to be different here with the Urban Growth Boundary and the "cheapest urban area on the West coast" - well, it looks like things are different here all right, it's just about a six months to a year different from what's happening in CA. Makes sense, as a lot of money migrates up here from CA when people sell their expensive houses down there and buy a bigger place up here - well, since there isn't much selling going on in CA anymore those 'equity locusts' (as we like to call them) are becoming scarce.
DH
IMHO, had our betters, held the line on credit, then allow prices to reflect wages rather than the amount of credit a worker can get, we would be a lot better off.
By allowing easy credit, the market indicator that things were not good was circumvented. No Money for college borrow it. No money for medical care, borrow it. No money for housing borrow it.
So RE agents, doctors and educators are not affected by the problems of the common classes and keep the current crop of our betters in office.
Had consumption followed wages, then a heap of folks would have been pressuring the government to do things different, because their income would be affected. At the moment, it is the credit card company's problem or the mortgage holder's problem.
waitinginnj
Thanks.
I became a US citizen in 1989. I love USA and what it stands for.
It pains me to see some of our political and corporate leaders bring USA down for just a few bucks.
Hell, thats why I left the OLD country?
BITTER-SWEET feelings indeed.
deb, oops, here is the correct link for the foreclosure graph. It is pretty stunning.
Best to all.
"Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground.Hard times ahead for everyone now,and dr dobbs,were you perhaps referring to our regime as well?"
Not directly; but as Bill Clinton said when campaigning against Bush I in recessionary times, "It's the economy, stupid!"
RE:
"Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground
Getting my Cessna SkyHawk 172P manual out ( just kidding, I've memorized this and it just rolls off ) - its MASTER SWITCH OFF, DOORS UNLATCHED, TAIL LOW -
O - Ok.. THEN you say - O Sh!t
-K
All I can say is that in my little corner of LA in the Pico/Robertson section just south of Beverly Hills, houses are still selling for top of the market prices. Just last week a 2br/2ba 1400 square foot 1930 house sold for $875,000. That same house five years ago would've traded for $225,000-$250,000. Oh, and I rent a 2BR/1BA 1930-built house`1000 square feet, four houses down for $2200/month. Go figure!
A friend who lives in New York City tells me that its different there (Manhattan). Prices are not falling and he thinks (absent a Wall Street recession) that prices will continue to rise and that real estate remains a good investment. His theory is that supply is limited and co-op governing boards keep out speculators and the sub-prime riff raff. I remain skeptical because the bubble seems to have affected real estate the world over. Why should NYC be immune? It might take longer, but sooner or later they have to feel the pinch. If prices drop in New Jersey and Connecticut will people pay an extra million to live in Manhattan? Is Manhattan that wonderful that its worth any price?
His theory is that supply is limited and co-op governing boards keep out speculators and the sub-prime riff raff.
Did he explain why the prices weren't this high before the boom, since both those conditions existed prior?
New York, California Metro Home Prices May Fall as Rates Climb
From buyers who can't afford costly loans to homeowners who can't find a buyer, the mortgage market is a mess.
New York, California Metro Home Prices May Decline (Update1) - Bloomberg.com
CR,
Stunning!! CR are you implying a quality associated with beauty?
You dog.If you start a REIT in a few years, count me in.
... Otherwise the consumer finds another source of cash and keeps on going. vader
Let me know when you find a new source of cash for us consumers. MEW and wages are tapped out on this homefront but if I don't buy some more stuff pretty soon, the economy will surely tank.
Maybe you can invent transmutation of toxic waste loans into gold? Oh, wait, been there, done that, didn't quite work out, did it?
Otherwise the consumer finds another source of cash and keeps on going. - vader
We'll dedicate this song to the consumer...
YouTube
- Chumbawamba - Tubthumping
"Maybe you can invent transmutation of toxic waste loans into gold?"
I've heard they can be woven into a cloth fit only for an emperor.
At this point it isn't about price, its about the implosion of financing over the past 60 days.
Don't worry BenB, a black hole contains everything. . .
Interesting article regarding the Bad News Bearsterns trying to skip town...
But Basis Capital Fund shows them how it's done.
404 Not Found
Juicy details about our beloved canary in the credit mine, Coast Bank.
Suit offers inside look at Coast's meltdown | HeraldTribune.com | Sarasota Florida | Southwest Florida's Information Leader
Taking bets this will be the major financial story of the week unless a major bank fails.
In Tight Market, Banks Woo Buyers For Commercial Paper - WSJ.com
CR,
And your next assignment if you're willing to accept is to plot CA trustees deeds recorded (foreclosures).
My guess is that you already have and I simply missed it. Anyhow, the referenced Dataquick article showed that CA 2Q foreclosures have increased 800% YoY and the 17.4k foreclosures are the most for 2Q going back to 1988.
Seems to me this would also be an impressive plot.
Best,
Matt
Houston Chronicle Editorial
No Way Taxpayers Should Bail Out Homeowners
404 Error, No such article | Chron.com - Houston Chronicle
Today, bond yields show that Lehman is considered more risky than Colombia, where the government has been waging a four-decade war with drug-funded rebels and one in 10 members of the workforce is unemployed. Colombia is rated BBB- by S&P, the lowest investment-grade rating, and carries a Ba2 junk rating from Moody's Investor's Service.
Doc - thanks. FDICers dubbed it Toast Bank. I'm searching for that complaint.
"Every time I read these reports the only thing I can think of is 'Who is buying a home these days?' - crashcadia "
People still get relocated, with various types of corp assistance.
Bank Lawyers Blog
The Circus Is Back in Town
"Malum consilium quod mutari non potest"
D'Oh
"The federal banking regulators, joined by the Conference of State Bank Supervisors, hurled down from Mt. Olympus this thunderclap of sagacity."
Bank Lawyer's Blog: FDIC
FFDIC: I agree. Enronification of the financial system. The bankers were thinking they were so clever with their SIVs, but it turned out the magic money machine wasn't so magic once everybody had to own up to their obligations. Off-balance-sheet is a systemic flaw in the accounting/legal system, effectively unaccounted for obligations via "cheating". Is it used for anything legitimate? SIVs rolling back on to bank balance sheets should add some serious trouble to the liquidity problem. Awfully interesting how these complex systems are so non-linear.
Doc -
It would be nice to know how many bank examiners are trained to look into this stuff? FDIC is hiring a new army of grade 7 examiners with starting pay I'm guessing at 40K (check out the FDIC's career on-line site). And, these recent college grads are expected to go up against buff badass billionaire bankers. I don't think so.
Doc,
Did you see this Toast class action update from March 2007?
Lerach Coughlin Stoia Geller Rudman & Robbins LLP Files Class Action Suit against Coast Financial Holdings, Inc | Business Wire | Find Articles at BNET
Zarkov,
"A friend who lives in New York City tells me that its different there (Manhattan). Prices are not falling and he thinks (absent a Wall Street recession) that prices will continue to rise and that real estate remains a good investment. "
I live in Manhattan and as you point out, NJ, CT, even Queens and Brooklyn provide a buffer for Manhattan's prices. All said, the infamous median prices keeps on going up. I live close to 4 realties, Corcoran and the like. there is stuff in their windows that's being sitting there for more than a year! Seller's anchoring/denial keeps on surprising me as prices are not being reduced.
Coops used to represent 75% of the supply but since 2000, all the new developments had been condos. So much is being built that both accounted for the same number of transactions last year. Also the requirements on coops are strict for outsiders, not for insiders. It's not a transparent process and got relaxed lately. So it cannot provide the protection that used to (this was explained by Jonathan Miller, as I also thought that coops will prevent a big drop in prices).
"Is Manhattan that wonderful that its worth any price?" not in my opinion. i'm very happy living here, but i could be happy in a trailer in oklahoma too.
if wall street has a couple of bad years not only bonuses and lay offs are going to hit the city badly. also city revenues (public employment) and indirect jobs (like fancy restaurants-bars-clubs) are going to feel the pain.
DH: you are a kick ass investor! congrats!!!
all said, i would like to know to what extent the availability of jumbo loans has been hurt. that's key for nyc, california, florida, ...
U.S. Housing Collapse May Bypass Some Markets
Since the U.S. real estate market is composed of hundreds of smaller metro markets -- several of which were not as severely affected by the bubble or subprime mortgages -- not all of the news is gloomy.
"Collapse" truly is the word of the day.
I hate to say that I am right, but I am right.
Today the dollar is kind of, shall we say, stable. It probably has some more downside, but it's hanging in there.
The Tokyo stock market on the other hand is crashing. Europe is not crashing yet.
I think the American market will crash.
So, the Fed is good to its word: it will protect the dollar, but equities and other assets have to take care of themselves.
arbogast,
I tend to agree. I'm also not very worried that It Could Be Different This Time.
Today I passed a very dejected looking sign spinner in WeHo, sitting under a tree taking a break. I wish I'd had a camera. This could be the new Time cover for 2007.
Now it's just a race to the bottom, as every 2 bed 1 toilet bungalow in the city goes begging for $600K, $500k, 300K and on DOWN.
Well, the only thing I would add is that the Yen is trying to weaken this morning, which to me means that big players are going to try to play the juice game this morning: juice the indices with some free money from Japan and see if they can get the momentum suckers to go along.
But I daresay they will sell into it the second they can. Those borrowed yen are finger-burning hot.
I completely agree with you. It just boggles my mind that some folks are still buying at near-peak price levels. Do they read the papers? Perhaps they see this as a buying opportunity, perhaps they are relatives of Sebastian for sure. My friend at web design company too earlier have faced a similar fate so its really heart rendering...
Lots of for sale signs!!
Old Agent Mantra:
"If you don't buy now you never will"
New Agent Mantra:
"If you don't sell now you never will"
Great posts!!
I am thinking the next bubble being "live aboard boats".
Or, live in travel trailers you can park free at Wall Mart.
US stock open looks flat
Pre-Market: Stock Trading Before the Markets Open from CNNMoney.com
Europe looks flat
World Markets - CNNMoney.com
Maybe a boring Monday.
"I am thinking the next bubble being "live aboard boats".
- Funny. My wife and I just started looking into renting a houseboat for a week to see if we like the lifestyle.
Things to consider going into a period of increasingly worse economic news and fundamentally deteriorating conditions-
1) More leverage than anytime in our history.
2) The greatest concentration of financially engineered, "illiquid" assets held by IB's, hedge funds, and conventional banks across the globe.
3) A Fed which is dramatically behind the curve.
4) Confidience levels that are rapidly deteriorating.
5) The all-or-nothing move into Treasuries.
6) A Housing situation which will likely deteriorate into 2009.
7) Default rates on HY which have nowhere to go but up.
8) Peak corporate earnings.
As this situation takes hold, the need to liquify illiquid assets will increase. The liklihood of a repeat of the August scare is pronounced and the potential for a much larger problem exists.
The commercial paper fiasco poses serious risks, the crisis of confidence that could potentially result would be devestating.
You read that many are touting this asset class versus another in this environment, the funny thing is that they have very recently been proven completely wrong in most cases. The leverage in the system is so great that August showed that hedged strategies were child's play and useless.
That said, tak away all of the "noise".
A step back shows you specifcally what lies ahead, a very difficult period.
Armegeddon, no, tough period, absolutley.
A fact that nobody seems to be discussing as of yet is the potential for unfunded pension liabilities to increase dramatically, this due to the move in interest rates, not assuming any decrease on their equity holdings which could add to the underfunded status of some plans.
These potential shortfalls will need to be eliminated and could further stress balance sheets going into a slowing economy.
Suppose that suddenly a lot of Americans needed jobs? Just suppose.
Where would those jobs come from?
Who's hiring?
Real estate agencies?
Oh sh!t!! is supposed to be the most common last phrase of pilots before they hit the ground.Hard times ahead for everyone now,and dr dobbs,were you perhaps referring to our regime as well?
So in that analogy, we're the automated alarm that you hear earlier in the tape saying "WHOOOP WHOOOP PULL UP! PULL UP!" just before the pilot says, "Can you turn off that damn alarm?"
When I see reports like this, my mind imagines the sounds from an old WWII film clip, such as a B-36 getting hit with anti-aircraft fire and spiralling into the ground in a huge fireball.
risk capital, another bullseye IMO. All I can add is that we need to be mindful of both private sector and governmental pensions.....tax shortfalls, earmarks...all that boring stuff that puts people to sleep.....
"Did you see the game?" "What's Paris Hilton up to today?"
lama-
I am beside myself knowing that "Britney" is making her comeback appearance, no time really to concentrate on anything else.
FWIW:
Last 7 days mkt activity - East Bay Area:
600 New
480 Price Change (lower)
130 Sold (lots of credits, reductions, and CONFORMING level prices)
200 Expired
Been my feeling for quite some time: we gotta roll these prices back to yr2000 levels. If the financing stays under $417k and you price aggressively, you can likely sell. Higher end stuff, can take a while, but yeah. It's that mediocre but priced btwn $500 - $1m stuff that, eeeeehhhhh, who knows?
Shoulda bot Wheat
central scrutinizer: I'll be a bit of a pedant here and point out that the B-36 first flew in 1946, so not too many were shot down during the second world war.
John's B-36 Peacemaker Page
"Why should NYC be immune? It might take longer, but sooner or later they have to feel the pinch. "
NYC will be the last to fall. They're the very epicenter of the bubble. Hell, the NY Times will still be publishing pablum about the Loyfstoyles of the Rich and Famous long after the rest of the country is eating out of cat food cans.
In other words, don't look to NYC for any indicators of reality. In fact, I think 50 years from now, Manhattan will be the world's most exclusive gated community.
Ah we were boring in August in Colorado Springs, our sales were only down 21.1%. We are on pace to sell about 800-900 new homes. Unfortunately there were 3000 or so permits given out.
Risk Capital - Anyone who has looked at the ratio of financial corporate profits to all other profits over the last few years realizes just how unpleasant things may get!
FFDIC - I'm waiting to find out more details about Norlarco. Looks like they thought the Brians' business plan was a no-brainer!
The FDIC needs to get the middle-aged talent back into the game ASAP. The college kids don't have the experience to handle this.
Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?
The alternative scenario has a sharp falloff in August-October home sales. Then, a year or more of stalemate, with low resale activity, HBs going bust, and prices drifting down slowly in many markets.
This can only happen if lenders don't flood the market with REOs. But one of the strangest things so far has been lenders' willingness to let REOs pile up.
How could Countrywide just keep collecting so many REOs without trying more aggressively to sell them? Neglected homes rot away.
What's holding them back from doing the apparently rational thing?
Answer that question and you may have the answer to what happens next. (A slow drift down would not be a happy scene for the economy or REIC.)
FFDIC and Doc,
most of the agencies and state banking departments do not have the front-line talent to perform thorough exams of problem institutions. how do you think a situation like coast bank happened. inexperienced examiners coupled with strict limits on the amount of time that can be spent on-site performing an exam. the bonus system for executives is calibrated to time savings, not performing an effective exam. they will mouth some BS that an examiner can expand the scope of an exam if necessary but in reality, it is a zero-sum game. if you use hours here, they must come out of somewhere else.
some have speculated that an examiner with less than 12 years experience does not have the ability to identify a problem situation as they have only been trained to do "drive-by" examinations. we have seen this movie before and we all know how it ends.
In the Northeast, 28 year-olds with a good Big-4 background in audit can easily land jobs for 80-100k with huge prospects for growth. These are the ones the govt needs and will never get.
"Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?"
Then there will be no sales.
Reprice, reprice, reprice! Until that happens there will be no end to it - true in credit markets, house markets, in EVERY overpriced market. The Fed can't change it; Congress can't change it.... overpriced things must reprice or they will not sell.
Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?
i believe i read that the abx implies something like a 13% drop in home prices, and you should always believe what subprime traders think about things.
How could Countrywide just keep collecting so many REOs without trying more aggressively to sell them? Neglected homes rot away.
What's holding them back from doing the apparently rational thing?
At a guess, there are two factors:
1.) They're carrying the homes on their books at the mose recent appraisal. Actually selling at market means putting losses on the books.
2.) They simply don't have the manpower to choke through the backlog. Telling the big bosses that they have to hire more people to realize more losses has got to be a tough sell.
Short Courage said "Do they read the papers? "
YES they do, Just the sports page.
NYC will be hit by a fall in financial jobs and year-end bonuses in early 2008 (these make up a huge % of the local economy on Manhattan), plus there are a lot of new condo projects finishing up or still under construction.
Real estate people there think foreign buyers will keep things going because the dollar is cheap. But why would a European buy a depreciating asset valued in a depreciating currency, just because the current currency exchange rate makes it somewhat cheaper than it was 6 months ago?
Re the LA stats, I can only say wow...
Phoenix and Las Vegas must be just as bad or worse. And Florida, already reeling...
Why is it surprsing that some people are still buying homes? Even when times are bad, it's hard to make a market stop completely. Generally it takes something on the order of a sustained Allied bombing campaign or Nigerian-government-level corruption, though even that usually allows some black-market activity. People will continue to buy and sell, no matter what.
The New York market will see some trouble in the next year or two, as a very large number of new condos are expected to come on the market--they're still building at a fast pace. We can only hope that Ratner's Atlantic Yards project ends up as the world's most expensive public housing project.
"Almost everybody on this board assumes home prices will decline sharply soon. But what if they don't?"
In bubbly California, in my 'desirable area' there has been widespread drama pricing of 20-30% easy. If you're expecting country wide re-pricing it'll take longer as conditions vary quite a bit.
It's like expecting a room full of people who all had heart attacks to start eating less fat. Some will and slim down quickly, others take longer, the average therefore moves slowly.
"A fact that nobody seems to be discussing as of yet is the potential for unfunded pension liabilities to increase dramatically, this due to the move in interest rates, not assuming any decrease on their equity holdings which could add to the underfunded status of some plans."
This will hit the public sector hardest, especially state/local government entities.
I believe the poster child for unfunded pension liabilities and for state/local government insolvency will be the same -- New Jersey.
I believe NJ already is technically bankrupt.
We live in a mobile society, especially among the growing numbers of seniors on fixed incomes. They will move away from high-tax states. Ultimately, for every dollar of higher taxes that New Jersey is forced to raise, the state will lose two dollars of revenue.
There's many ways that New Jersey can mask or postpone insolvency. But eventually, it will be a fiasco and take down the municipal bond insurers, too.
"bobwally" was me, not sure how I managed that.
I was seeing reports saying that jobless claim remains low enough to indicate that the US job market is still tight.
I was just thinking aloud why there is such a huge discrepanies between jobless claims and employment data.
It seems to me that maybe the reason is that many that are laid off are relatively high income earners (bankers, lenders, financial engineers, engineers etc) and may not find the jobless claim benefits worth the trouble.
On the other hands, if jobs lost are burger flippers and waiters or Walmart cashiers, they would have filed for jobless claims quite promptly.
How much is the exact weekly amount received for filing as jobless. Maybe someone can enlighten me.
Update on Asia markets-
The hedgies have made a strong push on the equity markets in the last 2 weeks, and another effort a few hours ago before monday markets closed. Not likely to give up their (long equity and short Yen) positions and fold until credit or economic environment in the US/ Europe get worse or when corporate profit start taking a hit. However, I suspect that when things start to unfold, it could get ugly fast, and not without a few hedge fund casualties to get the margin calls going....
I suspect many hedgies are holding on like boiling frogs even as the Yen strengthen by nearly 10% over the past month against the US$. Some may be quite close to the edge of the cliff.
Phoenix resale market report should be out either today or tomorrow, I doubt even their pollyannas will be able to drink that number pretty. It should go below 4k, which would be 60% off August 05 volume.
A big condo complex in Tempe is only 50% sold, in all likelihood their phase 3 won't get built. Other planned projects where land was cleared haven't progressed at all, and will never get built as funding has been pulled.
Suppose that suddenly a lot of Americans needed jobs? Just suppose.
Where would those jobs come from?
Dust off the operating instructions for the WPA and CCC ?
"NYC will be hit by a fall in financial jobs and year-end bonuses in early 2008 (these make up a huge % of the local economy on Manhattan), plus there are a lot of new condo projects finishing up or still under construction."
For a family with children, the cost of living in Manhattan, compared to the best close-in suburbs, is about 20-30% higher. The components of higher cost are: 1) real estate; 2) city income tax; 3) private school tuitions. Since quality-of-life and commutes are comparable whether you live in Manhattan or close suburbs, living in Manhattan is a luxury that affluent families can afford in good times.
Manhattan real estate prices = still high.
Quality close-in suburb prices = deteriorating.
As soon as the economy softens, you will see many Manhatan families forced out to the suburbs. I've talked to some of them, and they see it coming.
I wonder how credit crunch is playing it out:
Is it that only 4,000 buyers in L.A. were credit-worthy in August or is it that banks could only lend to 4,000 buyers?
Just the other night my husband and I watched a program on the Discovery channel on Mega Cruise Ship building in Finland. We are talking the largest and most elabrate cruise ships in the world, all destined for the US market. Finland can compete and build these incredibaly large vessels( the other major cruise ship building countrys are France and Italy)and provide high quality jobs because they have nationalized medicine. Per capita income for Finland versus the US in dollars for 2006 is Finland $37,178; US $33,050.
When are our politicians going to make this a must issue. When are Americans going to realize that there standard of living is dependent upon nationalized medicine.
Trying to grow an economy on housing and high cost low value added financial products and credit just isn't going to work anymore. We need to make products that people are going to buy. And our young people can make a living on.
So what did they say about the malpractice industry and the tort liability system in Finland? Speaking of jobs, seems like there was a time when lots of Norteamericanos worked in construction.
Candyman_Asia
How much is the exact weekly amount received for filing as jobless. Maybe someone can enlighten me.
Every state has different unemployment benefit amounts. I live in Ohio and the benefit here is 50% of what you made during the last 12 months. You also must have worked at least 6 of the last 12 months and not had a claim for at least a year. The maximum benefit is around $450 per week and you can claim up to 26 weeks of benefits. Unemployment is not available for CEO's and officers of companies as well as those self employed who receive 1099's. I think most real estate agents are self employed and would not be eligible for benefits in Ohio. So are a lot of the roofers, plumbers, electricians, heating and cooling guys. I am sure a lot of these workers are either out of work or are working less than a year ago, but are unable to file for benefits so the unemployment rate looks good when in reality it's not.
If someone from another state has more to add, I'd be interested in hearing about your benefit program.